Mid forceps did not cause “compromised babies” – “compromise” caused forceps: an approach toward safely lowering the cesarean delivery rate*

Abstract

Objective

Over 5 decades, Cesarean Delivery rates (CDR) have risen 6-fold while vaginal operative deliveries [VODs] decreased from >20% to ∼3%. Poor outcomes (HIE and cerebral palsy) haven’t improved. Potentiating the virtual abandonment of forceps (F), particularly midforceps (Mid), were allegations about various poor neonatal outcomes. Here, we evaluate VOD and CDR outcomes controlling for prior fetal risk metrics (PR) ascertained an hour before birth.

Methods

Our 45-year-old database from a labor research unit of moderate/high risk laboring patients (288 NSVDs, 120 Lows, 30 Mids, and 32 CDs) had multiple fetal scalp samples for base excess (BE), pH, cord blood gases (CB), and umbilical artery bloods. ANOVA established relationships between birth methods and outcomes (Cord blood BE and pH and 1 and 5 min Apgar scores); correlations, and two-step multiple regression assessed PR for delivery method and neonatal outcomes. The main outcome measures were correlations of outcome measures with fetal scalp sample BE and pH up to an hour before delivery and fetal reserve index scores scored concurrently.

Results

NSVDs had the best immediate neonatal outcomes with significantly higher CB pH and BE as compared to forceps and CDs. However, controlling for PR revealed: (1) PR at 1 h before delivery correlated with delivery mode, i.e. the decrements in outcomes were already present before the delivery was performed; and (2) The presumed deleterious effects of interventional deliveries, per se, were significantly reduced, and (3) Fetal Reserve Index predicted neonatal outcomes better than fetal scalp sample BE, pH, or delivery mode.

Conclusion

The historical belief that MF deliveries caused poorer outcomes than NSVDs seems mostly backwards. Appreciating PR’s impact on delivery routes, and when appropriate, properly performing VODs could safely reduce CDR. If our approach lowered CDR by only ∼2%, in the United States about 80,000 CDs might be avoided, saving ∼$750 Million yearly. In the post pandemic world, safely apportioning medical expenses will be even more critical than previously.

Keywords:

• Forceps
• electronic fetal monitoring
• cardiotocography
• fetal reserve index
• fetal scalp sampling
• base excess
• pH
• ACOG Category system
• metabolic acidosis
• cerebral palsy
• screening test

Acknowledgment

No funding for project.

Disclosure statement

One of the authors (MIE) has patents on the FRI approach; others are pending. No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).