Socio-environmental systems in technology adoption in animal husbandry in South-East Asia: A framework synthesis approach

ABSTRACT

In agriculture innovation adoption research, socio-institutional and environmental factors are often not addressed. This study employed a framework synthesis approach to identified factors affecting the smallholders’ decision-making in innovation adoption in animal husbandry in South-East Asia (SEA) and unravelled the interactions between these factors. First, we composed an initial framework based on worldwide reviews on (agriculture) innovation adoption. Next, we conducted a systematic review and identified 19 adoption factors: 7 individual, 6 socio-institutional, and 6 environmental factors. These factors were subdivided into 58 subfactors and scored both absolutely and relatively on their influence on farmers’ decision-making processes. At the individual farmers’ level, human and social capital subfactors with high importance were skills and knowledge, education, access to training, and being a member of a farmer group. At the socio-institutional level, learning platforms (extension services and training) were moderately important. These subfactors were interrelated and influenced by other factors, like age and culture. Important innovation characteristics affecting farmers’ motivation for innovation adoption were benefits, price, and compatibility. Highly important (sub)factors that contributed to the financial capital of farmers at the socio-institutional level, are the provision of grants, incentives, and loans. Water, soil condition, and climate risk were highly important environmental pressures affecting farmers’ innovation adoption. Finally, we synthesized the factors with (high) importance into the Framework for Innovation Adoption of Animal Husbandry Farmers in SEA (FIFSEA¹

¹ The Framework for Innovation Adoption of Animal Husbandry Farmers in SEA.

). The FIFSEA can help stakeholders to understand the complexity of innovation (dis)adoption and to guide actions and develop strategies for technology transfer.

KEYWORD:

• Animal husbandry
• socio-institutional factors
• socio-environmental system
• South-East Asia
• innovation adoption factors

Acknowledgments

The authors thank Peter Tamas for his kind assistance with the initial preparation for literature review.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

¹ The Framework for Innovation Adoption of Animal Husbandry Farmers in SEA.

² South-East Asia.

³ The Model of Determinants of Diffusion, Dissemination, and Implementation of Innovations.

⁴ Mixed crop livestock is included because 60–75% of animal products in developing countries come from this farming system. All the 20 selected papers include animals in their case studies of farming systems.

⁵ For mixed method studies, the scoring system followed the approach for quantitative studies because the adoption factors were found in the quantitative part of the articles.

Additional information

Funding

This work was supported by the Smart Indonesian Agriculture (Smart-In-Ag project) through the Interdisciplinary Research and Education Fund (INREF) of Wageningen University & Research.