Non-Esophageal symptoms cannot differentiate between erosive reflux esophagitis and non-erosive reflux disease in a referred population

Abstract

Background. Non-esophageal symptoms are highly prevalent in non-erosive reflux disease (NERD). However, their prevalence in erosive esophagitis (ErE) is unclear. The aims of this study were to compare patients with pH-positive NERD and ErE in terms of non-esophageal symptoms and to investigate whether such symptoms can differentiate between these two conditions. Material and methods. A prospective observational study of ErE and pH-positive NERD patients matched for age and gender with a nested case-control analysis. Symptoms were scored on validated scales. The association between the scale scores and diagnosis was evaluated in a random group comprising 67% of the total (group A) and was validated on the rest (group B). Results. 124 ErE and 248 pH-positive NERD patients were studied. In group A, pH-positive NERD patients scored higher than ErE patients on all symptom scales. Scores on chest, constipation, sleep and urinary symptoms scales were significantly associated with diagnosis. A composite weighted score on these scales was 41.5% sensitive and 86.0% specificity in the differentiation of ErE from pH-positive NERD patients. When applied to group B, the sensitivity and specificity of this score were 48.8% and 70.3%, respectively. Conclusions. Digestive and non-digestive symptoms occurred with a significant higher prevalence in pH-positive NERD compared with ErE patients. However a composite score on scales of constipation, chest, sleep and urinary symptoms was not enough sensitive and specific to differentiate these two conditions.

Key Words::

• NERD
• reflux esophagitis
• symptoms

Declaration of interest: The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.