Supratentorial masses: Stereotactic or freehand biopsy?

Abstract

CT-guided sterotactic biopsy is now an accepted method of tissue sampling in intracranial mass lesions but many surgeons still practise freehand burrhole biopsy. This study compares two groups of patients who had either stereotactically guided (n = 153) or freehand (n = 217) biopsy. Stereotactic biopsy has a lower incidence of both mortality (2.6%) and morbidity (1.3%) than freehand (7.8 and 7.8%) while diagnostic accuracy is 92.1 and 64.9%, respectively. The success rate for stereotactic biopsy is independent of the size and depth of the lesion while freehand biopsy is most successful for large, superficial lesions but its success never exceeds 88%. The stereotactic technique is superior to the freehand for all intracranial biopsies regardless of size or site.

Key Words:

• Biopsy
• cerebral neoplasm
• CT-guided stereotaxy
• freehand biopsy