Clinical simulation model of long-acting opioids for treatment of chronic non-cancer pain in the United States

Abstract

Objective:

To evaluate costs and outcomes associated with initial tapentadol ER vs oxycodone CR for the treatment of chronic non-cancer pain (CNCP) in the US.

Methods:

This study developed a Monte-Carlo simulation based on the scientific foundation established by published models of long-acting opioids (LAO) in patients having moderate-to-severe CNCP. It estimates costs and outcomes associated with the use of tapentadol ER vs oxycodone CR over a 1-year period from the perspective of a US payer. LAO effectiveness and treatment-emergent adverse event (TEAE) rates are derived from clinical trials of tapentadol ER vs oxycodone CR; other inputs are based on published literature supplemented sparingly with clinical opinion. Sensitivity analyses consider the impact of real-world dosing patterns for LAO on treatment costs.

Results:

Initial tapentadol ER consistently demonstrates better outcomes than initial oxycodone CR (proportion of patients achieving adequate pain relief and no GI TEAE; acute TEAE-free days; days free of chronic constipation; quality-adjusted life days; productive working hours). While total costs with initial tapentadol ER are slightly (2.2%) higher than with initial oxycodone CR, nearly twice as many modeled patients in the initial tapentadol ER arm (29% vs 15%) achieve adequate pain relief and no GI TEAE compared to initial oxycodone CR. In sensitivity analyses, tapentadol ER becomes a dominant strategy when real-world dosing patterns are considered.

Conclusion:

The additional costs to produce better outcomes (pain relief and no GI TEAE) associated with tapentadol ER are small in the context of double the likelihood of a patient response with tapentadol ER. When daily average consumption (DACON) for oxycodone CR is factored into the analysis, initial tapentadol ER becomes a dominant strategy. Our findings are both strengthened, and limited by the use of randomized trial-centric input parameters. These results should be validated as inputs from clinical practice settings become available.

Keywords::

• Opioids
• Chronic pain
• Oxycodone
• Tapentadol
• Cost analysis
• Economics

Transparency

Declaration of funding

This research was supported by Janssen Global Services, LLC.

Declaration of financial/other relationships

NN, DP, and KO received consulting fees from Janssen Global Services, LLC for the development of this paper. SM is an employee of Janssen Global Services, LLC. SHM is an employee of Janssen Scientific Affairs, LLC. Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. manufactures tapentadol ER.

Acknowledgments

The authors gratefully acknowledge the contributions made to this research by Stacy Rattana.