The State of Protected Areas and Conservation of Ethiopia’s Iconic Large Mammals: Implications for the Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework

Abstract

Despite the creation of several iconic protected areas (PAs) over the past decades, the charismatic megafauna of Ethiopia has continued to decline. Here, we identify the factors that are driving spatial and biological changes in PAs. The findings show that some iconic PAs were downsized while others remained unchanged, but almost all PAs significantly lost their ability to support iconic species, putting the survival of large mammals at risk. Human population growth, limited livelihoods, a lack of political commitment, insufficient funding, and climate change are all underlying threats to national PAs. The unrestricted use of natural resources, habitat degradation, the rapid spread of invasive species, illegal wildlife trade, disease, pollution, human–wildlife conflict, and roadkill are proximate factors that significantly impact upon PAs. As a result, it is of critical importance to change the management paradigm of the existing but largely degraded PA system. The authors, therefore, recommend that rather than focussing only on expanding protected and conserved areas (‘quantity’), management efficiency (‘quality’) should instead be prioritized to halt the dramatic loss of large mammals in Ethiopia.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 M Hocking, S Stolton and N Dudley, Evaluating Effectiveness: A Framework for Assessing the Management of Protected Areas (Gland/Cambridge, IUCN, 2000).

2 R Pankhurst, ‘Some Notes on Deforestation and Afforestation in Ethiopia Prior to World War I’ (1989) 12 Walia 10.

3 M Jacobs and C Schloeder, Impacts of Conflict on Biodiversity and Protected Areas in Ethiopia (Washington DC, World Wildlife Fund, 2001).

4 M Tesema, A Asefa and Y Dellelegn National Biodiversity Threat Assessment: Ranking Major Threats Impacting Ethiopia’s Biodiversity (Addis Ababa, IUCN, 2022).

5 Jacobs and Schloeder (n3).

6 M Pacifici, M Di Marco and JEM Watson, ‘Protected Areas Are Now the Last Strongholds for Many Imperiled Mammal Species’ (2020) 13 Conservation Letters e12748.

7 REA Almond et al, Living Planet Report 2022—Building A Nature-Positive Society (Gland, WWF, 2022).

8 Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity, Zero Draft of Post-2020 Biodiversity Framework (Montréal, CBD, 2020).

9 A Waldron et al, Protecting 30% of the Planet for Nature: Costs, Benefits and Economic Implications (Cambridge, Campaign for Nature, 2020).

10 E Di Minin and T Toivonen, ‘Global Protected Area Expansion: Creating More than Paper Parks’ (2015) 65 Bioscience 637.

11 UNEP-WCMC and IUCN, Protected Planet: The World Database on Protected Areas (WDPA) and World Database on Other Effective Area-based Conservation Measures (WD-OECM) (Cambridge, UNEP-WCMC and IUCN, 2023).

12 TW Admassu, YT Wolde and M Kaba, ‘Ethiopia Has a Long Way to go Meeting Adolescent and Youth Sexual Reproductive Health Needs’ (2022) 19 Reproductive Health (Supplement 1) 130.

13 ME Tesema, A Report on Assessment of Threat Status in Five Selected Wildlife Protected Areas of Ethiopia (Addis Ababa, Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority, 2019).

14 AD Vreugdenhil et al, Gap Analysis of the Protected Areas System of Ethiopia (Shepherdstown, World Institute for Conservation and Environment, 2012).

15 Tesema (n4).

16 C Sandbrook et al, ‘Social Considerations are Crucial to Success in Implementing the 30 × 30 Global Conservation Target’ (2023) 7 Nature Ecology & Evolution 784.

17 A Simeneh et al, ‘The Application of a Refined SWOT-AHP-Based Planning and Management Approach for the Conservation of Ethiopia’s Protected Area Systems’ (2021) 1 International Journal of Zoological and Entomological Letters 13.

18 T Asfaw et al, ‘First Record of White-eared Kob (Kobus kob leucotis) in Omo National Park, Ethiopia (Artiodactyla, Bovidae)’ (2022) 10 Biodiversity Data Journal e94114.

19 R Moreaux et al, Analysis of Potential of Further UNESCO-Biosphere Reserves in Ethiopia (Greifswald, Michael Succow Foundation for the Protection of Nature, 2015).

20 W Kassaye and A Mekonnen, Survey Report on Alledeghi Wildlife Reserve Boundary Assessments and Socioeconomic Data Collection for the Purpose of Re-demarcation (Addis Ababa, Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority, 2013).

21 K Tewodros, Human–Wildlife Conflict and Population Status of Swayne’s Hartebeest (Alcelaphus Buselaphus Swaynei) in Senkele Swayne’s Hartebeest Sanctuary. MSc thesis, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa.

22 Information drawn from UNEP-WCMC and IUCN (n11).

23 N Diplock et al, ‘Large Mammal Declines and the Incipient Loss of Mammal–Bird Mutualisms in an African Savanna Ecosystem’ (2018) 13 PLoS ONE e0202536.

24 A Tadesse, Sustaining the Alledeghi Grassland of Ethiopia: Influences of Pastoralism and Vegetation Change, PhD thesis 2009, Utah State University; T Chernet, A Resource Base and Climate Change Risk Maps for Awash National Park (Addis Ababa, PHE-Ethiopia Consortium, 2015).

25 UNEP/CMS, Conservation Road Map for the African Wild Ass Equus africanus 2017–2027 (Bonn, CMS, 2017).

26 S Shibru et al, ‘Human Pressure Threaten Swayne Hartebeest to Point of Local Extinction from the Savannah Plains of Nech Sar National Park, South Rift Valley, Ethiopia’ (2020) 8 Journal of Biodiversity and Endangered Species 1.

27 K Laurenson, Ethiopian Elephant Action Plan 2015–2020 (Addis Ababa, Ethiopian Wildlife Conservation Authority, 2015).

28 Ibid.

29 Status and remarks are drawn from the literature cited above.

30 M Tessema et al, ‘Trend, Challenges and Opportunities of Illegal Wildlife Trafficking and Trade Activities within and through Ethiopia’ (2021) 44 SINET: Ethiopian Journal of Science 47.

31 M Tefera, ‘Wildlife in Ethiopia: Endemic Large Mammals’ (2011) 6 World Journal of Zoology 108.

32 AI Dagg and JB Foster, The Girafffe: Its Biology, Behavior, and Ecology (Malabar, Krieger Publishing Company, 1982).

33 AJ Marais, S Fennessy and J Fennessy, A Rapid Assessment of the Giraffe Conservation Status in Ethiopia (Windhoek, Giraffe Conservation Foundation, 2013).

34 G Yirga et al, ‘Lion (Panthera leo) Ecology and Survival in Protected Areas of Ethiopia’ (2021) 101 Mammalian Biology 791.

35 T Woodfine and G Parker, ‘Emerging Evidence of Beisa Oryx Decline in Parts of Northern Kenya’ (2011) 29 Gnusletter 21.

36 IJM Robertson, Awash National Part. A Working Plan (Addis Ababa, EWCO, 1970).

37 C Enawgaw, Population Status and Distribution of Artiodactyls in Awash National Park with Special Reference to Beisa oryx (Oryx beisa beisa), MSc thesis, 2004, Addis Ababa University.

38 Personal communication (on file with the corresponding author).

39 A Simeneh, B Afework and A Addisu, ‘Population Size and Structure of Beisa oryx and Its Habitat Overlap with Sympatric Species in Alledeghi Wildlife Reserve, NE, Ethiopia’ (2016) 15 Ethiopian Journal of Biological Sciences 37.

40 M Rowen and J Ginsberg, ‘Grevy’s Zebra (Equus grevyi Oustalet)’ in P Duncan (ed), Zebras, Asses and Horses. An Action Plan for the Conservation of Wild Equids (Gland, IUCN, 1992) 10 − 12.

41 SD Williams, APW Nelson and F Kebede, Grevy’s Zebra Survey: Ethiopia 2003. Interim Report (Oxford, Wildlife Conservation Research Unit, 2003).

42 See https://www.iucnredlist.org/species/7950/89624491.

43 H Klingel, Status Survey of the Somali Wild Ass in the Danakil Region Ethiopia (Gland, World Wildlife Fund, 1971).

44 F Kebede Ecology and Community Based Conservation of the Grevy’s zebra (Equus grevyi) and the African Wild Ass (Equus africanus) in the Afar region, Ethiopia, PhD thesis, 2013, Addis Ababa University; see also UNEP/CMS (n25).

45 F Kebede et al, Distribution and Population Status of the African Wild Ass (Equus africanus) in Ethiopia (St Louis, St Louis Zoo, 2007).

46 D Ejigu, A Bekele and L Powell, ‘Walia Ibex Have Increased in Number and Shifted their Habitat Range Within Simien Mountains National Park, Ethiopia’ (2017) 10 Journal of Mountain Ecology 10.

47 Simien Mountain National Park, A General Management Plan (2020–2029) for the Simien Mountain National Park. Debark, Ethiopia (Addis Ababa, SMNP, 2020).

48 Z Demissie, ‘Population Status towards Ethiopian Wolf (Canis simensis) in Bale Mountains National Park, South Easter, Ethiopia’ (2021) 9 Global Scientific Journal 1472.

49 Ethiopian Wolf Conservation Programme, EWCP Annual Report (Addis Ababa, EWCP, 2022).

50 M Tamrat et al, ‘Swayne’s Hartebeest in Ethiopia: Population Estimate, Genetic Variability, and Competition with Livestock’ (2021) 56 Oryx 336.

51 A Asefa, G Mengesha and R Almaw, ‘Indigenous Institutions and Wildlife Conservation: The Case of the Oromo Gadda System Protecting Swayne’s Hartebeest in Ethiopia’ (2019) 1 Conservation Science and Practice e113.

52 P Scholte, ‘Towards Understanding Large Mammal Population Declines in Africa’s Protected Areas: A West-Central African Perspective’ (2011) 4 Tropical Conservation Science 1.

53 Ibid.

54 A Simeneh et al, ‘Underfunding, The Challenge of Federally Managed Protected Areas of Ethiopia’ (2020) 4 Advances in Environmental Studies 307.

55 See further M Wondie et al, ‘Spatial and Temporal Land Cover Changes in the Simen Mountains National Park, a World Heritage Site in Northwestern Ethiopia’ (2011) 3 Remote Sensing 752; S Belay, A Amsalu and E Abebe, ‘Land Use and Land Cover Changes in Awash National Park, Ethiopia: Impact of Decentralization on the Use and Management of Resources’ (2014) 4 Open Journal of Ecology 950; SN Hailemariam, T Soromessa and D Teketay, ‘Land Use and Land Cover Change in the Bale Mountain Eco-Region of Ethiopia during 1985 to 2015’ (2016) 5 Land 41; B Tesfaw Hailu and S Girma, ‘Spatio Temporal Lake Level Change of Lake Abijata, Ethiopia: A Remote Sensing Approach’ (2019) 6 Environmental Analysis & Ecology Studies 592; DW Sintayehu and M Kassaw, ‘Impact of Land Cover Changes on Elephant Conservation in Babile Elephant Sanctuary, Ethiopia’ (2019) 3 International Journal of Biodiversity 65; F Temesgen, B Warkineh and A Hailemicael, ‘Seasonal Land Use Land Cover Change and the Drivers in Kafta-Sheraro National Park, Tigray, Ethiopia’ (2022) 8 Heliyon e12298.

56 DW Sintayehu, ‘Impact of Climate Change on Biodiversity and Associated Key Ecosystem Services in Africa: A Systematic Review’ (2018) 4 Ecosystem Health and Sustainability 225.

57 T Estifanos et al, ‘The Impact of Protected Areas on the Rural Households’ Incomes in Ethiopia’ (2020) 91 Land Use Policy 104349.

58 W Mengist, ‘Challenges of Protected Area Management and Conservation Strategies in Ethiopia: A Review Paper’ (2020) 4 Advances in Environmental Studies 277.

59 UNDP-GEF, Sustainable Development of the Protected Area System of Ethiopia (SDPASE) (Washington DC, United Nations Development Program, 2008).

60 FW Duckworth, An Assessment of Ethiopia’s Wildlife Situation (Addis Ababa, Ethiopian Reporter, 2002); Simeneh (n54).

61 Hailemariam, Soromessa and Teketay (n55).

62 Belay, Amsalu and Abebe (n55).

63 Wondie (n55).

64 A Fetene et al, ‘Detecting Trends in Land Use and Land Cover Change of Nech Sar National Park, Ethiopia’ (2016) 57 Environmental Management 137.

65 A Simeneh ‘Impact of Land Use Land Cover Changes on Ecosystem Services in the Alledighe Wildlife Reserve, Ethiopia: Implication for Rangeland Ecosystem Management’ (under review; on file with the author).

66 Z Meng et al, ‘Post-2020 Biodiversity Framework Challenged by Cropland Expansion in Protected Areas’ (2023) 6 Nature Sustainability 758.

67 W Shiferaw, S Demissew and T Bekele, ‘Invasive Alien Plant Species in Ethiopia: Ecological Impacts on Biodiversity: A Review Paper’ (2018) 3 International Journal of Molecular Biology: Open Access 171.

68 Tadesse (n24); S Tesfaye, Impact of Prosopis juliflora on Plant Biodiversity at Alledeghi Wildlife Reserve and Surrounding Local Community, Ethiopia, MSc thesis, 2015, Addis Ababa University.

69 Tessema (n29).

70 SB Wassie, ‘Natural Resource Degradation Tendencies in Ethiopia: A Review’ (2020) 9 Environmental Systems Research 33; K Asnake, H Worku and M Argaw, ‘Assessing the Impact of Watershed Land Use on Kebena River Water Quality in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia’ (2021) Environmental Systems Research 3.

71 See further https://www.cdc.gov/onehealth/what-we-do/zoonotic-disease-prioritization/completed-workshops.html.

72 DA Randall et al, ‘Rabies in Endangered Ethiopian Wolves’ (2004) 10 Emerging Infectious Diseases 2214.

73 Wetland International Ethiopia, Biodiversity and Socio-Economic Assessment of Abijata Shalla National Park (Addis Ababa, Wetland International Ethiopia, 2020).

74 Tesfaw Hailu and Girma (n55).

75 Omo National Park, General Management Plan (2021–2030) (Addis Ababa, Omo National Park, 2021).

76 Ibid.

77 See A Schubert, A Situational and SWOT Analysis of the Awash and Nech Sar National Parks (Addis Ababa, GIZ Ethiopia, 2015), and B Zerga, ‘Awash National Park: It’s Degradation Status and Protection Measures’ (2015) 2 Palgo Journal of Agriculture 57.

78 Zerga, ibid.

79 Schubert (n55).

80 Ibid.

81 F Aramde et al ‘Study of Changes in Habitat Type Distribution and Habitat Structure of Nech Sar National Park, Ethiopia’ (2014) 4 Ecology 1.

82 E Neil and E Greengrass, ‘Illegal Settlement in the Babile Elephant Sanctuary is Threatening the Resident Elephant Population’ (2021) 56 Oryx 457.

83 Sintayehu and Kassaw (n55).

84 AW Degife, F Zabel and W Mauser, ‘Assessing Land Use and Land Cover Changes and Agricultural Farmland Expansions in Gambella Region, Ethiopia, using Landsat 5 and Sentinel 2a Multispectral Data’ (2018) 4 Heliyon e00919.

85 A Kasahun, Analyzing the Effect of Armed Conflict, Agriculture, and Fire on the Movement and Migratory Behavior of White-Eared Kob and Roan Antelope in the Boma-Gambella Landscape of Ethiopia and South Sudan, MSc thesis, 2018, Addis Ababa University.