Patients’ views on priority setting in neurosurgery: A qualitative study

Abstract

Object. Accountability for Reasonableness is an ethical framework which has been implemented in various health care systems to improve and evaluate the fairness of priority setting. This framework is grounded on four mandatory conditions: relevance, publicity, appeals, and enforcement. There have been few studies which have evaluated the patient stakeholders’ acceptance of this framework; certainly no studies have been done on patients’ views on the prioritization system for allocating patients for operating time in a system with pressure on the resource of inpatient beds. The aim of this study is to examine neurosurgical patients’ views on the prioritization of patients for operating theater (OT) time on a daily basis at a tertiary and quaternary referral neurosurgery center. Methods. Semi-structured face-to-face interviews were conducted with thirty-seven patients, recruited from the neurosurgery clinic at Toronto Western Hospital. Family members and friends who accompanied the patient to their clinic visit were encouraged to contribute to the discussion. Interviews were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim, and subjected to thematic analysis using open and axial coding. Results. Overall, patients are supportive of the concept of a priority-setting system based on fairness, but felt that a few changes would help to improve the fairness of the current system. These changes include lowering the level of priority given to volume-funded cases and providing scheduled surgeries that were previously canceled a higher level of prioritization. Good communication, early notification, and rescheduling canceled surgeries as soon as possible were important factors that directly reflected the patients’ confidence level in their doctor, the hospital, and the health care system. Conclusion. This study is the first clinical qualitative study of patients’ perspective on a prioritization system used for allocating neurosurgical patients for OT time on a daily basis in a socialized not-for-profit health care system with fixed resources.

Keywords::

• brain tumors
• neurosurgery
• operative experience
• theater time utilization

Declaration of interest: The authors report no declarations of interest.

Funding was supplied by the Lipton Education and Research Fund, Dr. Mark Bernstein is the Fund holder. The Fund account at UHN is 579045000733.

Both investigators contributed to developing the coding framework, examined the transcripts, and tabulated responses.

Supplementary material available online

Supplementary Appendix A: Interview Guide to be found online at http://informahealthcare.com/doi/abs/10.3109/02688697.2015.1071330.