Mild traumatic brain injuries in early adolescent rugby players: Long-term neurocognitive and academic outcomes

Abstract

Background: Information is scant concerning enduring brain injury effects of participation in the contact sport of Rugby Union (hereafter rugby) on early adolescents.

Objective: The objective was prospectively to investigate differences between young adolescent male rugby players and non-contact sports controls on neurocognitive test performance over 3 years and academic achievement over 6 years.

Method: A sample of boys from the same school and grade was divided into three groups: rugby with seasonal concussions (n = 45), rugby no seasonal concussions (n = 21) and non-contact sports controls (n = 30). Baseline neurocognitive testing was conducted pre-season in Grade 7 and post-season in Grades 8 and 9. Year-end academic grades were documented for Grades 6–9 and 12 (pre-high school to year of school leaving). A mixed model repeated measures ANOVA was conducted to investigate comparative neurocognitive and academic outcomes between the three sub-groups.

Results: Compared with controls, both rugby groups were significantly lower on the WISC-III Coding Immediate Recall sub-test. There was a significant interaction effect on the academic measure, with improved scores over time for controls, that was not in evidence for either rugby group.

Conclusions: Tentatively, the outcome suggests cognitive vulnerability in association with school level participation in rugby.

• Academic performance
• adolescence
• concussion
• mild traumatic brain injury
• MTBI
• neurocognitive
• rugby

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to acknowledge and thank Professor Soraya Seedat, Dr. Karen Cloete, Anthea Joseph, the school, teachers and boys for their support, assistance and involvement with this project.

Declaration of interest

The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.