Perceptions, interpretations and implications of abortions: A qualitative enquiry among the legal community of Pakistan

ABSTRACT

Background The number of unsafe abortions is increasing across South Asia, also in Pakistan, where abortion is only permitted under special circumstances. The law on abortion is vaguely interpreted by the legal community.

Methods Using Grounded Theory, 33 in-depth interviews of representatives of the legal profession and law enforcement agencies were conducted in 2010.

Results Abortion is perceived as forbidden by both law and religion, and a punishable crime. Respondents believed that sentences are highly dependent on the social status of the woman who had the abortion. A few consider the current law as relevant and sufficient whereas the majority would support amendments. A number of them agreed that the high abortion rate reflects the denial of women's rights, social injustice, and a failure of public health intervention.

Conclusion To facilitate access of women to abortion and related care, the knowledge of the existing law among legal professionals must improve. The implications of abortion for maternal health and its repercussions on a community governed by the Islamic dogmas must be publicised. The legal community could have an instrumental role in bringing about attitudinal changes vis-à-vis abortions in the society.

KEYWORDS:

• Abortions
• Islamic law
• Legal community
• Qualitative study
• Reproductive health
• Pakistan

Acknowledgements

The Asia Safe Abortion Partnership (ASAP) provided feedback on the draft tools for the data collection for this study. The Marie Stopes Society (MSS) funded the entire study in Pakistan.

Declaration of interest: The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and the writing of the paper.