Optimal dose–response relationships in voice therapy

Abstract

Like other areas of speech-language pathology, the behavioural management of voice disorders lacks precision regarding optimal dose–response relationships. In voice therapy, dosing can presumably vary from no measurable effect (i.e., no observable benefit or adverse effect), to ideal dose (maximum benefit with no adverse effects), to doses that produce toxic or harmful effects on voice production. Practicing specific vocal exercises will inevitably increase vocal load. At ideal doses, these exercises may be non-toxic and beneficial, while at intermediate or high doses, the same exercises may actually be toxic or damaging to vocal fold tissues. In pharmacology, toxicity is a critical concept, yet it is rarely considered in voice therapy, with little known regarding “effective” concentrations of specific voice therapies vs “toxic” concentrations. The potential for vocal fold tissue damage related to overdosing on specific vocal exercises has been under-studied. In this commentary, the issue of dosing will be explored within the context of voice therapy, with particular emphasis placed on possible “overdosing”.

Keywords::

• Under-dosing
• over-dosing
• toxic
• intervention
• intensity

Declaration of interest: The author report no conflicts of interest. The author alone is responsible for the content and writing of the paper.