The Evaluation of Pyrosis and Long-term Satisfaction after Gastric Restrictive Procedures: a Retrospective Study

Abstract

Objective: To compare gastric banding (GB) and vertical banded gastroplasty (VBG) with respect to the evolution of pyrosis and patient satisfaction.

Summary Background Data: Although weight loss is the most immediate end-point in the evaluation of surgical treatment of obesity, the demonstration of changes in long-term patient satisfaction and in co-morbidity, like reflux, is an essential outcome measure.

Material and methods: Retrospective study of 243 morbidly obese patients. All patients received a questionnaire regarding the evolution of pyrosis and their satisfaction after surgery. The evolution of pyrosis was compared between 2 patient groups who had different oesophagitis stages. Group A had oesophagitis I, or no oesophagitis, and group B had oesophagitis II, III or IV.

Results: In group A of the GB group 57.8% had no complaints, 11.1% had improvement and 22.2% had aggravation of the pyrosis. In group B of the GB group 50.0% had improvement. In group A of the VBG group 51.4% had no complaints, 11.1% improvement and 23.6% aggravation of the pyrosis. In group B of the VBG group 16.7% had no complaints, 66.6% had improvement and 16.7% had aggravation of the pyrosis complaints. Statistically there is no significant difference between GB and VBG. The experience after GB is good with 67.9%, mediocre with 25.0% and bad with 7.1% of the patients; 60.7% is pleased with the weight loss. The experience after VBG is good with 47.4%, mediocre with 29.5% and bad with 23.1% of the patients. 52.6% is satisfied with the weight loss.

Conclusion: VBG and GB have a similar effect on pyrosis. From our point of view it has been evidenced that the presence or absence of pyrosis before the operation is a possible predictor of the evolution afterwards. Long-term patient satisfaction is the same after GB and VBG. Other factors influence the satisfaction.

Key Words:

• Vertical banded gastroplasty
• gastric banding
• gastro-oesophageal reflux
• pyrosis
• satisfaction after surgery
• obesity

Additional information

Notes on contributors

B. Balduyck

B. Balduyck and s. vansteenkiste Jozef Lambrechtslei 5 B-2540 Hove, Belgium.