Entomological evaluation of the Gambia's National Impregnated Bednet Programme

Abstract

Entomological studies were conducted in paired study villages in three of the five study areas used for the epidemiological assessment of the Gambia's National Impregnated Bednet Programme. Baseline data collected in 1991 were compared with post-intervention data from 1992, when one of each village pair (from areas II, III and V) was included in the treatment programme in which villagers' nets were dipped in permethrin. In a longitudinal study, indoor-resting densities of Anopheles gambiae s.l. in the treated villages were significantly reduced, when compared with their paired untreated village, in areas II (t=3·32, 13 degrees of freedom, P=0·006) and III (t = 3·71, 13 degrees of freedom, P=0·003). However, this was not associated with higher outdoor-biting rates in the evenings in the treated villages than in the controls. The reduction in vector population was most evident in area II, where the treated village was relatively isolated and 74% of the population slept under a treated net.

Anopheles gambiae s.l. were also collected during two fortnightly periods in area V, where the sporozoite rates in 1991 had been relatively high (7·65% and 6·07%). There was no significant decrease in the sporozoite rate in the treated village in area V in 1992, despite the fact that this village was over 5 km from its nearest neighbouring village. However, the proportion of villagers sleeping under a treated net in this village was <50%.

No clear evidence for an epidemiologically significant ‘mass killing effect’, resulting from the village-wide use of treated nets, emerges in this or any other study undertaken in The Gambia. However, such an effect is indicated by results from Salikene, where the village mosquito population was relatively isolated and where the majority of the population slept under a treated net. This situation is unlikely to be repeated in most Gambian villages in the primary-health-care scheme, since treated and untreated villages are generally interspersed and the mosquito populations move freely between them. We must therefore conclude that, on a national scale, the nets provide an exceptionally high level of personal rather than community protection. The mechanisms underlying the personal protection are, however, still unclear.