Abstract
There are three major approaches used to estimate index numbers. The first is Fisher's test approach whereby indexes are judged on their ability to satisfy certain criteria. The economic theory of index numbers is the second approach and this deals with their foundations in utility theory. The third approach is a less well-known methodology, but one which is now attracting considerable attention, the stochastic approach which is a new way of viewing index numbers in which uncertainty and statistical ideas play a central role. While providing a point estimate for the index number like the other two approaches, the stochastic approach additionally provides the SE of the point estimate. This article enhances understanding of stochastic index numbers by showing that they are formally equivalent to the familiar optimal combination of forecasts with the individual prices playing the role of n forecasts of the overall rate of inflation. This leads to new analytical results on the impact of adding additional information within the stochastic approach framework. We provide two concrete examples of the sources of such additional information: (i) the quantity theory of money; and (ii) the use of quantity data in addition to price data. We also illustrate some of these theoretical results using real data.
Acknowledgement
We would like to acknowledge the research support of the Australian Research Council and the help of Yihui Lan.
Notes
1 The main literature on the SA is Balk (Citation1980), Clements and Izan (Citation1981, Citation1987), Crompton (Citation2000), Diewert (Citation1995), Giles and McCann (Citation1994), Miller (Citation1984), Ogwang (Citation1995), Ong
et al
. (Citation1999), Prasada Rao and Selvanathan (Citation1992a,Citationb), Selvananthan (Citation1989, Citation1991, Citation1993), Selvanathan and Prasado Rao (Citation1992, Citation1994, Citation1999), Selvanathan
et al
. (Citation1997), Selvanathan and Selvanathan, Citation2005.
2 The above has been extended to allow for more general specifications for the distribution of the disturbance terms. Crompton (Citation2000) analyses White-type heteroscedasticity and derives analytical scalar expressions for the standard error of inflation under this formulation. Selvanathan and Rao (Citation1999) also consider a more general error covariance structure. Even with these extensions, the basic insight remains unchanged, namely, the variance of the estimate of the rate of inflation increases with the degree of variability of relative prices.
3 Essentially, this idea is Fisher's (Citation1927, pp. 72–6) ‘factor reversal test’ whereby the product of the price index in period t with base period 0 and the corresponding quantity index equals the ratio of observed total expenditure in the two periods. That is, if
denote the product of the price and quantity indexes, then according to the factor reversal test
where
pit
,
qit
are the price and quantity consumed of good
i (
i = 1, … ,
n) in period
t. The right-hand side of the above equation is what Fisher called the ‘value ratio’, which ‘unlike an index number of prices or quantities, is not an estimate but a fact … [It], therefore, afford [s] a fixed rock of truth, by which we may reckon the drifting courses of the various index numbers of prices and quantities.’ (Fisher,
Citation1927, pp. 74–5). The equation in the previous sentence of the text is (F1) above in the form of logarithmic changes over time.
Balk
,
BM
.
1980
.
A method for constructing price indices for seasonal commodities
.
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A
,
142
:
68
–
75
.
Clements
,
KW
and
Izan
,
HY
.
1981
.
A note on estimating divisia index numbers
.
International Economic Review
,
22
:
745
–
47
.
(1982) Corrigendum, 23, 499
Clements
,
KW
and
Izan
,
HY
.
1987
.
The measurement of inflation: a stochastic approach
.
Journal of Business and Economic Statistics
,
5
:
339
–
50
.
Crompton
,
P
.
2000
.
Extending the stochastic approach to index numbers
.
Applied Economics Letters
,
7
:
367
–
71
.
Diewert
,
WE
.
1995
.
On the stochastic approach to index numbers. Discussion Paper No. 95–31
,
Columbia
:
Department of Economics, University of British
.
Giles
,
D
and
McCann
,
E
.
1994
.
Price indices: systems estimation and tests
.
Journal of Quantitative Economics
,
10
:
219
–
35
.
Miller
,
S
.
1984
.
Purchasing power parity and relative price variability: evidence from the 1970s
.
European Economic Review
,
26
:
353
–
67
.
Ogwang
,
T
.
1995
.
The stochastic approach to price index numbers: an expository note
.
Economics Letters
,
49
:
373
–
9
.
Ong
,
LL
,
Clements
,
KW
and
Izan
,
HY
.
1999
.
The world real interest rate: stochastic index number perspectives
.
Journal of International Money and Finance
,
18
:
225
–
49
.
Prasada Rao
,
DS
and
Selvanathan
,
EA
.
1992a
.
Uniformly minimum variance unbiased estimators of Theil-Tornqvist index numbers
.
Economics Letters
,
39
:
123
–
7
.
Prasada Rao
,
DS
and
Selvanathan
,
EA
.
1992b
.
Computations of standard errors for Geary-Khamis parities and international prices
.
Journal of Business and Economics Statistics
,
10
:
109
–
15
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
.
1989
.
A note on the stochastic approach to index numbers
.
Journal of Business and Economic Statistics
,
7
:
471
–
4
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
.
1991
.
Standard errors for laspeyres’ and Paasche index numbers
.
Economics Letters
,
35
:
35
–
8
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
.
1993
.
More on laspeyres’ price index
.
Economics Letters
,
43
:
157
–
62
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
and
Prasada Rao
,
DS
.
1992
.
An econometric approach to the construction of generalised Theil-Törnqvist indices for multilateral comparisons
.
Journal of Econometrics
,
54
:
335
–
46
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
and
Prasada Rao
,
DS
.
1994
.
Index Numbers: A Stochastic Approach
,
London
:
Macmillan
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
and
Prasada Rao
,
DS
.
1999
.
The stochastic approach to index numbers revisited
,
Unpublished Paper, Griffith University and University of New England
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
,
Prasada Rao
,
DS
and
Doran
,
HE
.
1997
.
Estimation of general and commodity-specific rates of inflation using linear time-varying constraints
.
Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics
,
34
:
67
–
74
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
and
Selvanathan
,
S
.
2006
.
Measurement of inflation: an alternative approach
.
Journal of Applied Economics
,
IX
:
403
–
18
.
Crompton
,
P
.
2000
.
Extending the stochastic approach to index numbers
.
Applied Economics Letters
,
7
:
367
–
71
.
Selvanathan
,
EA
and
Prasada Rao
,
DS
.
1999
.
The stochastic approach to index numbers revisited
,
Unpublished Paper, Griffith University and University of New England
.
Fisher
,
I
.
1927
.
The Making of Index Numbers
,
3rd
,
Boston
:
Houghton Muffin
.
Fisher
,
I
.
1927
.
The Making of Index Numbers
,
3rd
,
Boston
:
Houghton Muffin
.