Testing for calcium, magnesium, and potassium in soilless potting media: Differences and similarities between extractants

Abstract

Interpretation guidelines for the availability of calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg), and potassium (K) in soilless media have been developed through plant growth studies and comparisons amongst extractants. The extractants used were 70% ethanol (EtOH), water, DTPA, ammonium acetate (NH₄OAc) and silver thiourea (AgTu). Ethanol, which removes ions in pore water, extracted only 4.5, 13, and 26% of the Ca, Mg, and K, respectively, that could be extracted by AgTu from Pinus radiata bark of pH 5.66 and CEC of 11.2 cmol⁺/L. Acidification to pH 4.62 increased these proportions to 22, 40, and 38%. Correlations between water and DTPA for 39 media were excellent for both individual elements and the ratios Ca/Mg, K/Mg, and Ca, Mg, and K/(the sums of their concentrations in the extractants) (r² = 0.88–0.98). Correlations between these extractants and AgTu and NH₄OAc were poor for individual elements (r² = 0.37–0.75) but high for ratios (r² = 0.71–0.96). For Petunia ’Celebrity Salmon’ growing in peat media of similar pH but widely different Ca, Mg, and K proportions, the ratios of these elements in the shoots were highly correlated with their ratios in 2 mM DTPA extracts of the media. Similarly high correlations were obtained between the Ca/Mg ratios of the shoots of three Asplenium species growing in pinebark media and this ratio for DTPA, NH₄OAc, and AgTu extracts of the media. The results indicate that the ratios of Ca, Mg, and K to one another in water and DTPA extracts of soilless media are good indicators of the availability of these elements to plants. Healthy specimens of the test plants grew in media whose DTPA extracts had a minimum Ca/Mg mole ratio of 1 or 2, depending on the Ca requirements of the species. The upper limit for good growth was deduced to be about 6. Limits for NH₄OAc and AgTu extracts were similar to those found for crop plants in soils, at 1.6 or 3 to about 9. Minimum amounts of Ca, Mg, and K extracted by water and DTPA that were adequate for short‐term growth in the absence of further inputs were about 9,2.5, and 5 cmol⁺/L medium, respectively, at pH 6.0. The effect of pH on cations removed by water and DTPA raises the minima to about 19, 5, and 7.5 cmol⁺/L at pH 5.0.