Influence of the Reason for the Other's Affect on Preschoolers' Empathic Response

Abstract

Forty-six preschoolers were individually presented four slide-sequence stories in which the main character performed acts that resulted in the character displaying happiness (in two stories) or sadness (in two stories). Within each happy and sad story pair, one story portrayed the main character as having an “acceptable” reason for his or her affect (e.g., the character was happy after finding a friend to play with) and one story portrayed the character as having an “unacceptable” reason for his or her affect (e.g., the character was happy after transgressing against another child). Affective and evaluative responses to the main characters in the four stories were assessed. The preschoolers generally empathized more with (and evaluated more favorably) a story character whose affect was associated with the performance of an acceptable rather than an unacceptable act.