Unravelling electronic and structural requisites of triplet–triplet energy transfer by advanced electron paramagnetic resonance and density functional theory

Abstract

Advanced electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) techniques, in combination with Density Functional theory (DFT), have been applied to the comparative study of carotenoid triplet states in two major photosynthetic antenna complexes, the Peridinin-chlorophyll a–protein of dinoflagellates and the light-harvesting complex II of higher plants.

Carotenoid triplet states are populated by triplet–triplet energy transfer (TTET) from chlorophyll molecules to photoprotect the system from singlet oxygen formation under light-stress conditions. The TTET process is strongly dependent on the relative arrangement and on the electronic properties of the triplet states involved.

The proposed spectroscopic approach exploits the concept of spin conservation during TTET, which leads to recognisable spin polarisation effects in the time-resolved and field-swept echo-detected EPR spectra. The electron spin polarisation produced at the carotenoid acceptor site depends on the initial polarisation of the chlorophyll donor and on the relative geometrical arrangement of the donor-acceptor zero-field splitting axes. We have demonstrated that a proper analysis of the spectra in the framework of spin angular momentum conservation allows to derive the pathways of TTET and to gain insight into the structural requirements of this mechanism for those antenna complexes, whose X-ray structure is available. We have further proved that this method, developed for natural antenna complexes of known X-ray structure, can be extended to systems lacking structural information in order to derive the relative arrangement of the partners in the energy transfer process.

The structural requirements for efficient TTET, obtained from time-resolved and pulse EPR, have been complemented by a detailed description of the electronic structure of the carotenoid triplet state, provided by pulse Electron–Nuclear DOuble Resonance (ENDOR) experiments. Triplet-state hyperfine couplings of the α- and β-protons of the carotenoid conjugated chain have been assigned with the aid of quantum chemical calculation. DFT predictions of the electronic structure of the carotenoid triplet state, in terms of spin density distribution, frontier orbital description and orbital excitation represent suitable building blocks toward a deeper understanding of electronic requirements for efficient TTET.

Keywords:

• EPR
• pulse EPR
• pulse ENDOR
• DFT
• triplet state
• triplet–triplet energy transfer
• carotenoid
• light-harvesting complex
• PCP
• LHCII

Acknowledgements

The authors thank all collaborators, who contributed to this work and whose names are given in the references. The help of Marco Albertini and Elena Meneghin (University of Padova) in the development of the programs for structural analysis is gratefully acknowledged. Financial support from MIUR (PRIN2010-2011 prot. 2010FM738P_004) and the University of Padova (Progetto Strategico 2008, HELIOS, prot. STPD08RCX) are acknowledged.