Cohesion without participation: immigration and migrants' associations in Italy

ABSTRACT

Italian migration and citizenship policies tend to deny the fact that immigration in Italy is now a structural phenomenon embedded in the labour market and Italian society. The first part of Mantovan's article examines this denial in terms of the apparent difficulty many in Italian society have in accepting the social changes caused by Italy's rapid transition from a country of emigration to one of immigration. She argues that this reluctance to accept the fact of immigration is exacerbated by Italy's fragile national social cohesion, which has led to policy attempts to buttress social cohesion with respect to immigrants' relationship to Italian society. The Italian version of social cohesion is based on an ‘implicit model’ of immigrant integration and a citizenship regime defined by jus sanguinis. The second part of her paper evaluates Italian social cohesion as to how it manages the social changes caused by immigration, and looks at the evolution and characteristics of immigrants' participation in migrant associations. The principal measure adopted, that is, to include selected, co-opted migrant representatives from immigrant groups in consultative and advisory bodies, remained too dependent on the Italian authorities and voluntary organizations. These political migrants' associations ultimately failed, and led immigrants to withdraw and form their own cultural associations that better met their needs. Accordingly, the measures taken to promote migrants' participation through immigrants' associations functioned more as a mechanism to reduce ethnic complexity and the Otherness represented by migrants rather than as a viable, long-term means of facilitating their access to Italian citizenship. Overall, Italian policies have weakened social cohesion by reproducing and reinforcing structural inequalities among immigrants.

Keywords:

• citizenship
• immigrants
• Italian social cohesion
• migrants' associations
• migration policies
• participation
• social change
• social cohesion

Acknowledgments

I would like to acknowledge Vincenzo Pace for his lively and useful discussions of earlier drafts of this article.

Notes

¹Stephen Castles and Alastair Davidson, Citizenship and Migration: Globalisation and the Politics of Belonging (Basingstoke: Macmillan 2000).

²Steven Vertovec, ‘Minority associations, networks and public policies: re-assessing relationships’, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, vol. 25, no. 1, 1999, 21–42.

³Claudia Mantovan, ‘Muslim self-organisation and state interaction with Muslim organisations in Italy’, in Mark Bodenstein and Axel Kreienbrink (eds), Muslim Organisations and the State-European Perspectives (Nuremberg: Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge 2010), 93–110.

⁴Charles Tilly, From Mobilization to Revolution (Reading MA and London: Addison-Wesley 1978); John D. McCarthy and Mayer N. Zald, ‘Resource mobilization and social movements: a partial theory’, American Journal of Sociology, vol. 82, no. 6, 1977, 1212–41; Ruud Koopmans and Paul Statham (eds), Challenging Immigration and Ethnic Relations Politics: Comparative European Perspectives (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2000).

⁵Adrian Lyttleton, ‘The national question in Italy’, in Mikuláš Teich and Roy Porter (eds), The National Question in Europe in Historical Context (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1993), 99–100.

⁶Carl-Ulrik Schierup, Peo Hansen and Stephen Castles, Migration, Citizenship, and the European Welfare State: A European Dilemma (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2006), 163.

⁷Enzo Pace, La Nation italienne en crise: perspectives européennes, trans. from the Italian by Patrick Michel (Paris: Bayard Éditions 1998).

⁸Feruccio Pastore, La comunità sbilanciata: diritto della cittadinanza e politiche migratorie nell'Italia post-unitaria, Laboratorio CeSPI no. 7, June 2002, available on the Centro Studi di Politica Internazionale website at www.cespi.it/Laboratorio/Lab__7=2002.pdf (viewed 26 March 2013).

⁹Franco Pittau, ‘35 anni di immigrazione in Italia’, in Caritas/Migrantes, Immigrazione: Dossier Statistico 2005 (Rome: Nuova Anterem 2005), 69–76.

¹⁰Marzio Barbagli, Asher Colombo and Giuseppe Sciortino (eds), I sommersi e i sanati: le regolarizzazioni degli immigrati in Italia (Bologna: Il Mulino 2004).

¹¹Fabio Perocco, ‘L'apartheid italiano’, in Pietro Basso and Fabio Perocco (eds), Gli immigrati in Europa: diseguaglianze, razzismo, lotte (Milan: Franco Angeli 2003), 211–33.

¹²Marcello Maneri, ‘Lo straniero consensuale: la devianza degli immigrati come circolarità di pratiche e discorsi’, in Alessandro Dal Lago (ed.), Lo straniero e il nemico: materiali per l'etnografia contemporanea (Genoa: Costa & Nolan 1998), 236–72.

¹³Maurizio Ambrosini, La fatica di integrarsi: immigrati e lavoro in Italia (Bologna: Il Mulino 2001).

¹⁴Perocco, ‘L'apartheid italiano’.

¹⁵Ralph Grillo and Jeff Pratt (eds), The Politics of Recognizing Difference: Multiculturalism Italian-style (Aldershot, Hants: Ashgate 2002).

¹⁶Oliviero Forti, ‘Immigrati e cittadinanza: dal codice civile del 1865 alla riforma del 1992’, in Caritas/Migrantes, Immigrazione: Dossier Statistico 2003 (Rome: Nuova Anterem 2003), 153–62.

¹⁷William Bonapace, ‘Le acquisizioni di cittadinanza: il dibattito teorico e i mutamenti giuridici’, in Caritas/Migrantes, Immigrazione: Dossier Statistico 2009 (Rome: Nuova Anterem 2009), 110–17.

¹⁸Pastore, La comunità sbilanciata, 15.

¹⁹Vladimiro Polchi, ‘Gli italiani? Stipendiati dagli stranieri’, Il Venerdì di Repubblica, 26 October 2012.

²⁰Caritas/Migrantes, Dossier Statistico Immigrazione 2011 (Rome: Nuova Anterem 2011).

²¹Paolo Attanasio and Andrea Facchini, ‘Rappresentanza politica e diritto di voto’, in Caritas/Migrantes, Immigrazione: Dossier Statistico 2004 (Rome: Nuova Anterem 2004), 186–95.

²²Mark Miller, ‘Political participation and representation of non-citizens’, in Rogers Brubaker (ed.), Immigration and the Politics of Citizenship in Europe and North America (Lanham, MD and London: University Press of America 1989), 129–43; Catherine Wihtol de Wenden, Les Immigrés et la politique: cent-cinquante ans d’évolution (Paris: Presses de la Fondation nationale des sciences politiques 1988).

²³Claudia Mantovan, Immigrazione e cittadinanza: auto-organizzazione e partecipazione dei migranti in Italia (Milan: Franco Angeli 2007).

²⁴Giovanna Campani, ‘Ethnic networks and associations, Italian mobilisation and immigration issues in Italy’, in Beatrice Drury and John Rex (eds), Ethnic Mobilisation in a Multi-cultural Europe (Aldershot, Hants: Avebury 1994), 143–7.

²⁵Udo Enwereuzor, conference presentation at ‘La partecipazione politica degli immigrati: esperienze, limiti, prospettive’, Università Cà Foscari, Venice, 24 May 2006.

²⁶Istituto di ricerche educative e formative (Iref), ‘Immigrati e associazionismo’, Notizie Iref, no. 55/56, July–December 1989, 5–32.

²⁷Ottavia Schmidt di Friedberg, Islam, solidarietà e lavoro: i muridi senegalesi in Italia (Turin: Fondazione Giovanni Agnelli 1994), 151–2.

²⁸Fabio Berti, ‘La funzione di controllo sociale dell'associazionismo tra immigrati: tre casi in provincia di Siena’, in Giuseppe Scidà (ed.), I sociologi italiani e le dinamiche dei processi migratori (Milan: Franco Angeli 2000), 103–11.

²⁹Raffaele Sciortino, ‘L'organizzazione del proletariato immigrato in Italia’, in Basso and Perocco (eds), Gli immigrati in Europa, 376–405.

³⁰Bruno Murer, ‘L'associazionismo in emigrazione: percorsi comunitari e identitari dei migranti’, in Germano Garatto and Fredo Olivero (eds), Immigrati: la sfida di una società multietnica (Casale Monferrato: Piemme 1995), 104–19; Anna Meli and Udo C. Enwereuzor, Participation of Foreigners in Public Life at the Local Level, COSPE, National Focal Point of the European Monitoring Centre on Racism and Xenophobia (EUMC), 2003, available on the COSPE website at www.cospe.it/uploads/documenti/allegati/partecipazione_politica_dei_cittadini_stranieri_a_livello_locale.pdf (viewed 10 April 2013).

³¹Tiziana Caponio, ‘Policy networks and immigrants' associations in Italy: the cases of Milan, Bologna and Naples’, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, vol. 31, no. 5, 2005, 931–50.

³²Ankica Kosic and Anna Triandafyllidou, Active Civic Participation of Immigrants in Italy, Country Report prepared for the European research project POLITIS, Oldenburg 2005, available on the POLITIS website at www.uni-oldenburg.de/politis-europe/download/Italy.pdf (viewed 4 April 2013).

³³Maurizio Ambrosini, Sociologia delle migrazioni (Bologna: Il Mulino 2005).

³⁴See the material available on the Primo Marzo 2012 Sciopero degli ‘stranieri’ website at http://primomarzo2010.blogspot.com (viewed 4 April 2013).

³⁵Members of the Lega Nord (the xenophobic Northern League Party) define themselves as ‘Padani’, a reference to the Pianura Padana, or the Po Valley.

³⁶Loïc Wacquant, ‘“Suitable enemies”: foreigners and immigrants in the prisons of Europe’, Punishment & Society, vol. 1, no. 2, 1999, 215–22

³⁷Loris Vergolini, ‘Coesione sociale e vulnerabilità economica in Europa’, Sociologia del Lavoro, no. 110, 2008, 173–85.