Comparison of Gene Therapy with the Herpes Simplex Virus Thymidine Kinase Gene and the Bacterial Cytosine Deaminase Gene for the Treatment of Hepatocellular Carcinoma

Abstract

Background: Bystander effects induced by suicide gene/prodrug systems play an essential role in achieving successful antitumor effects. Although it has been shown in several in vitro studies that the bacterial cytosine deaminase (CD) gene/5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) system is superior to the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-TK) gene/ganciclovir (GCV) system, we examined here which suicide gene system was more promising in vivo for the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Methods: BNL1ME A.7R.1 murine HCC cells were retrovirally transduced with the HSV-TK or CD gene, and bystander effects caused by the appropriate prodrug treatment were examined not only in vitro but also in vivo. Results: The CD/5-FC system was superior to the HSV-TK/GCV system in HCC cell elimination in vitro. The bystander effect of the HSV-TK/GCV was shown to be substantially dependent on cell-to-cell contact, whereas that of the CD/5-FC was not. However, antitumor effects on HCC and tumor immunity to parental HCC induced by the HSV-TK/GCV system were not inferior and even superior to those induced by the CD/5-FC system. Bystander effects induced by the suicide gene/prodrug systems in immunocompetent syngeneic mice were much more profound than those induced in vitro. However, significant bystander effects were not observed in athymic nude mice. Conclusions: These results suggest that both HSV-TK/GCV and CD/5-FC systems are useful for the treatment of HCC. The results also suggest that T-cell-mediated immune responses elicited by the suicide gene/prodrug systems play a substantial role in antitumor effects in vivo.