Abstract
I review and discuss the articles in this issue by Walker, by Wagner, and by Heidtman et al. There are three main themes that appear in all three papers; these flow from the shared commitment among these authors to understanding and promoting “scientific theory construction” within sociology, and to dispelling some common misconceptions about scientific sociological theory. The common themes that run through the three papers can be put in the form of questions: 1) What is a theory? 2) How should we evaluate theory? 3) How does theory grow? In addition to discussing these three main themes, I discuss four sub-themes that emerged: 1) Sociology as a Scientific Endeavor; 2) Critiques of General Theory as Being Positivistic; 3) Unitary versus Multiple Forms of Theory Building; 4) Professional / Disciplinary Barriers to Theory Construction and Theory Building in Sociology.