1,332
Views
9
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Spinning Yarns: The Archaeological Evidence for Hand Spinning and its Social Implications, c ad 1200–1500

 

Abstract

THIS PAPER EXAMINES the archaeological evidence for hand spinning in medieval Britain from c 1200 to c 1500. Ceramic, stone and baked clay spindle whorls have dominated the excavated finds, but a new corpus of lead-alloy spindle whorls, recorded through the Portable Antiquities Scheme and Scottish Treasure Trove, is presented here. Analysis of the metal whorls’ distribution, manufacture, dating and decoration is provided, illuminating the wide social and economic contexts in which they were used. From memento mori of pious spinners to sexually potent objects representative of lubricious gossips, the ubiquitous spindle whorl was a universal tool that had a powerful agency. The artefacts are small finds embodying daily life but also tie into the wider national economy of the High and Late Middle Ages.

Résumé

Filage et fusaïoles : les traces archéologiques de la filature artisanale et ses répercussions sociales, vers 1200-1500 par Eleanor R Standley

Ce papier examine les traces archéologiques en rapport avec le filage artisanal dans la Grande-Bretagne médiévale, d’environ 1200 à 1500. Les fusaïoles en céramique, en pierre et en argile cuite figurent de manière prédominante dans les résultats des fouilles, mais un nouveau corpus de fusaïoles en alliage de plomb, recensées par l’intermédiaire du « Portable Antiquities Scheme » et du « Scottish Treasure Trove », est présenté ici. La répartition des fusaïoles métalliques, ainsi que leur fabrication, leur datation et leur décoration sont analysées, permettant d’éclairer plus largement les contextes sociaux et économiques dans lesquels elles étaient utilisées. Memento mori de pieuses fileuses, ou objet imbu d’un pouvoir sexuel et représentatif de commérages lubriques, la fusaïole omniprésente était un outil universel aux puissants effets. Petits objets de la vie quotidienne, ces artefacts sont aussi liés globalement à l’économie nationale du milieu et de la fin du moyen-âge.

Zusammenfassung

Garn spinnen: Die archäologischen Nachweise für das Handspinnen und seine gesellschaftlichen Implikationen, ca. 1200-1500 n.Chr. von Eleanor R Standley

Dieser Artikel untersucht die archäologischen Nachweise für Handspinnen im mittelalterlichen Britannien zwischen 1200-1500 n.Chr. Spinnwirtel aus Keramik, Stein und gebranntem Ton dominieren in den Funden aus Ausgrabungen, aber ein neuer Korpus von Spinnwirteln aus einer Bleilegierung, der im Rahmen des Portable Antiquities Scheme und des Scottish Treasure Trove dokumentiert wurde, wird hier vorgestellt. Eine Analyse der Verteilung, Herstellung, Datierung und Verzierungen dieser Metallspinnwirteln wird vorgestellt und zeigt den weiteren sozialen und wirtschaftlichen Kontext auf, in dem diese Spinnwirteln benutzt wurden. Vom “memento mori” frommer Spinnerinnen bis hin zu sexuell expliziten Gegenständen, die eher für lüsterne Klatschmäuler zu stehen scheinen, war der Spinnwirtel ein allgemein verbreitetes Werkzeug, das eine mächtige Wirkkraft hatte. Die Gegenstände sind kleine Funde, die das Alltagsleben verkörpern, aber auch eine Verbindung zur weiteren Volkswirtschaft des Hoch- und Spätmittelalters herstellen.

Riassunto

La filatura: testimonianze archeologiche della filatura a mano e sue implicazioni sociali 1200 d.C ca -1500 d.C. ca di Eleanor R Standley

In questa pubblicazione si prendono in esame le testimonianze archeologiche della filatura a mano nella Britannia medievale dal 1200 ca al 1500 ca. Tra i fusaioli provenienti dagli scavi il predominio spetta a quelli di ceramica, di pietra e di terracotta, ma qui viene presentato un nuovo corpus di fusaioli in lega di piombo, registrati presso il Portable Antiquities Scheme e presso il Treasure Trove in Scozia. Si fornisce un’analisi della distribuzione, della manifattura, della datazione e della decorazione dei fusaioli di metallo, mettendo in luce gli ampi contesti sociali ed economici nei quali venivano usati. Dai memento mori di devote filatrici agli oggetti di prepotente sessualità a testimonianza di pettegolezzi lascivi, l’onnipresente fusaiolo era uno strumento universale dotato di potenti effetti. I manufatti sono piccoli ritrovamenti che danno forma concreta alla vita quotidiana ma che si collegano anche alla più larga economia nazionale dell’Alto e del Tardo Medioevo.

Acknowledgements

Thanks are due to Mark Hall for the information regarding the finds in the collections of Perth Museum and Art Gallery; to Nick Watson, Christopher Gerrard and Alejandra Gutiérrez for reading and commenting on earlier drafts of this paper; to Frances Pritchard and the second anonymous reviewer for their suggestions; and to the editors. My thanks also to Abi Tompkins, the Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford, the Morgan Library and Museum, New York, Perth Museum and Art Gallery, and Museum Vleeshuis, Antwerp.

Notes

2 Henry Citation1999; Meaney Citation1981; Nicholson Citation2015; Walton Rogers Citation1997; Citation2007.

3 Canmore database available at <https://canmore.org.uk>; PAS database available at <https://finds.org.uk/database>.

4 Gilchrist Citation2009, 399–401.

5 Childs Citation2006, 270; Rigby Citation2006, 24.

6 Graves and Heslop Citation2013, 99, 119.

7 Munro Citation2012, 50, 51, n 10.

8 Ibid, 106.

9 Campbell Citation2006, 187.

10 Walton Citation1991, 251.

11 Campbell Citation2006, 222.

12 Walton Citation1991, 342.

13 Campbell Citation2006, 221.

14 Campbell Citation2006, 221.

15 Dyer Citation2000, 172–3.

16 Ibid; Penn Citation1987, 6.

17 Chance et al Citation1979, tab 11.

18 Bolton Citation1980, 157.

19 Keene Citation1990; Walton Rogers Citation2002.

20 Bridbury Citation1982, 31–2; Walton Citation1991, 351.

21 Munro Citation2008, 115–6.

22 Muldrew Citation2012.

23 Wilson Citation1846.

24 Allen Citation1979.

25 Tyrell and Zeepvat Citation1992.

26 Mynard and Zeepvat Citation1992, 76–8, fig 27.

27 Gerrard with Aston Citation2007, 782, 785, S4 and S12.

28 Thorn Citation2008, 5, 19.

29 Dunning Citation2004.

30 Gilchrist Citation2008, tab 2.

31 Egan Citation1997, tab 14.

32 Coppack Citation1986.

33 Donkin Citation1963; Moorhouse Citation1989.

34 Henig Citation1976, 218, nos 46 and 47.

35 Clay Citation1981, 140, no 71, fig 51; Keily with Egan Citation2004, 151.

36 Nicholson Citation1997a, tab 10.18.

37 An unfinished whorl was found in a Period V grave (c 1250x1300–1600). Hill Citation1997b, 61; Nicholson Citation1997b.

38 Williams Citation1997, fig 64 nos 42 and 43, fig 67 no 17, fig 76 no 2.

39 Margeson and Williams Citation1985, fig 37 no 1.

40 Mayes and Butler Citation1983.

41 Austin Citation2007.

42 Ryder and Gabra-Sanders Citation1992.

43 Nutz and Ottino Citation2013.

44 Nuts and Ottino Citation2013, 55.

45 Cardon Citation1999, 225, fig 83; Øye Citation1988, 45–8.

46 Nicholason Citation1997a, tab 10.18. Of the total 63 dating from c 1000–1600, nine were lead and five were bone, the remainder were made of stone.

47 Øye Citation1988, tab II.2.

48 Daniels Citation2009, 88–90, fig 19.7.

49 Still and Pallister Citation1964, 197.

50 Goodall Citation1989, 137 no 1; Citation1979, no 3; King Citation1994, 127; Richards Citation2011, no 160.

51 British Museum Citation1964.

52 This continued error is especially prevalent in the PAS records.

53 Homer Citation1991, 64.

54 For example Henry Citation1999, 72.

55 Walton Rogers Citation1997, 1743–5.

56 Verhecken Citation2010.

57 Kania Citation2015. See also Nicholson Citation2015. In Nicholson’s experiments based on 8th-century ceramic whorls from Ribe (Denmark) and wool thread, it was suggested that the amount of twist remained the same for a given diameter of whorl, regardless of weight, but that the whorl design did affect the quality of thread produced. However, all Nicholson’s experiments were carried out by one spinner (the author), using one type of wool, meaning that other spinners may have produced different yarns based on their level of skill and competence, regardless of whorl design.

58 Canmore online database available at <http://canmore.rcahms.gov.uk> [accessed December 2014]; Mark Hall pers comm 2015.

59 See Robbins Citation2014 for discussion of these areas and their effect on PAS data.

60 Ibid, fig 6.

61 Homer Citation1991, 65.

62 Aston Citation2000, 141–2.

63 Jamroziak Citation2003.

64 See Walton Citation1991, tab 181.

65 Dyer Citation1995.

66 Ibid, 154.

67 Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna, Inv No GG_1025.

68 Standley Citation2013.

69 Hall Citation2001, 76; Citation2003, 48–9.

70 Walton Rogers Citation1997, 1736–43.

71 Gary Bankhead pers comm 2014; McCormack Citation2011.

72 Egan Citation2007, nos 2175–2201, 2293; Morris Citation2007, nos 3288–9; Ottaway with Griffiths Citation2007, nos 2749, 2754–72.

73 Egan Citation2007, 76; Griffiths and Philpott Citation2007, 436; Laughton Citation2007, 414.

74 Egan Citation2007, 76, 173–4.

75 Coulthard Citation2012.

76 Hurst and Moorhouse Citation1981.

77 Cf Egan Citation1998, 256.

78 Hall Citation2003, 48; Perth Museum and Art Gallery accession no 119.

79 Mark Hall pers comm 2015.

80 Musée Gallo-Romain de Fourvière MOU-9005.

81 Metal-detecting in France with the aim of looking for archaeological material is forbidden, therefore detectorists’ finds are not generally recorded, and there is no systematic recording allowing full analysis or interpretation of the finds.

83 For example Blevins Citation2011; Cox Citation2013; Reavill Citation2008b.

84 Gibson Citation1990; Jones and Stallybrass Citation2000, 116–7.

85 Staatliche Museum, Gemäldgalerie, Berlin.

86 Magyar Nemzeti Galéria Inv no 52.656.

87 Boda et al Citation2014, 30–1.

88 Forsyth Citation1995; Long Citation1975, 22; Scandinavian Runic-text Database <http://www.nordiska.uu.se/forskn/samnord.htm> [accessed March 2015].

89 Daubney Citation2010.

90 Burrill Citation2010.

91 Daubney Citation2008; Citation2012; Gilmore Citation2014.

92 Blake et al Citation2003, 176; Standley Citation2013.

93 Standley Citation2013, 84.

94 Found in the Chester area (Cheshire), Oakden Citation2009.

95 Blake et al Citation2003, 182.

96 Rohde Citation2007.

97 Jones and Stallybrass Citation2000, 117.

98 Gilchrist Citation2008, 133.

99 Stronach Citation2005.

100 Spencer Citation1983, 81–3. Mary is known as ‘Star of the Sea’ from the translation of her name Stella Maris. Stars also feature in later medieval depictions of the Annunciation, Christ’s Nativity, Adoration of the Magi, and the enthroned Virgin and Child, for example, a 15th-century pilgrim badge from the shrine of Our Lady, Walsingham, and a mid- to late 14th-century badge from Cologne, both in the MoL (inv nos 83.608 and 94.102). See also Spencer Citation1990, 39–40; Spencer Citation1998, 174–5 for discussion of star pilgrim badges or amulets related to Christ.

101 348 as of 31 October 2014.

102 Gilchrist Citation2008, 130–1.

103 Downes Citation2009.

104 Hall Citation2002, 92; Citation2003, fig 4.

105 Walton Rogers Citation1997, 1745.

106 Mindykowski et al Citation2010, 65.

107 Boughton Citation2012; Elisabeth Gilmore Citation2012.

108 Boughton Citation2012.

109 Laura Burnett, Mary Siraut and Naomi Payne pers comm, cited in Boughton Citation2012; see Sayers Citation2008 for terminology.

110 Haines Citation1930, 117.

111 Tymms Citation1854, 56, fn.

112 Spinning has also been associated with evil witches, spells and magic, see Jones and Stallybrass Citation2000, 128.

113 Staatsbibliothek, Berlin, MS germ qu 718, fol 65v.

114 See Stewart Citation2003 for a discussion of this image, and the religious and cultural context in Nuremberg at the time of its creation.

115 Cf Jones Citation2002 interpretation of vulva badges as good luck charms.

116 Kunera database nos 00540 and 16947 <http://www.kunera.nl>.

117 Jones Citation1993, 103.

118 St Fiacre of Breuil, an Irish saint who settled in Breuil (France); his relics were enshrined by Bishop Faro in Meaux Cathedral. Thirty-one badges on the Kunera database depict Houpdée. <http://www.kunera.nl>.

119 Kunera database no 17071 <http://www.kunera.nl>. The vulva figure is now damaged and it is not clear whether she originally held something too.

120 Kunera database no 00670 <http://www.kunera.nl>.

121 For example in St Boltoph’s, Boston (Lincolnshire), Westminster Abbey (London), Barcelona and Toledo cathedrals (Spain).

122 Add MS 42 130 fol 60r.

123 Penn Citation1987, tab 1.

124 Perry Citation1945, 68.

125 Ibid, 119.

126 Steane Citation1985, 38.

127 Bennett et al Citation2012, 9.

128 MacGregor Citation2011, 104.

129 Albarella Citation2007; Robinson Citation1980, 204–5.

130 Keene Citation1990, 213.

131 Ibid Citation1990, 214.

132 For example Cool Citation2011, 309; Oakley and Hall Citation1979, tabs 28–9; Walton Rogers Citation1997, tab 146.

133 As noted in the reports for Perth and Winchester. Bennett et al Citation2012, 9; Keene Citation1990, 213; MacGregor Citation2011, 104.

134 Muldrew Citation2012 has also shown the importance of spinners in the period 1550–1770 and that spinning was a profitable occupation carried out in the household during this time.

135 Muldrew Citation2012; Styles Citation2013, no 31. Many of the processes of textile production would have taken place in different locations, as seen in the case against John Stoby of Cirencester who failed to pay ulnage (the duty charged on cloth exposed for sale) on 36 ‘Bristol reds’ in 1459. The ‘Bristol reds’ were woven and dyed in Cirencester and then delivered by packhorses to six fullers in Stroud, eight miles away. At the fullers the cloth was watered, washed, fulled, teased and sheared, then returned to Stoby in Cirencester for transport to markets, see Childs Citation2006, 270–1.

136 Gilchrist Citation2009, 399–400.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.