Fatal shortcomings of stationary AR (1) exogeneous variables in econometric monte carlo tudies of estimators

Abstract

The paper first shows that the stationary normal AR(1) process (SNAR1), the most frequently used process for generating exogenous variables in econometric Monte Carlo studies, cannot generate realistic exogenous variables, which are generally trended and similar to those generated by ARIMA (p,d,q) process withd≧1 and positive drift (trend). Then, it illustrates that in the context of AR(1) disturbances,trends in exogenous variables can frequently alter the very ranking of two competing estimators, the ordinary least squares estimator (OLS) and the Cochrane-Orcutt estimators (CO). For three common econometric models—a standard regression model, a dynamic model (i.e., a model with a lagged dependent variable), and a seemingly unrelated regression model, OLS becomes superior in many cases. This is so in spite of the fact that the CO estimator in the study utilizes the true value of the first-order autocorrelation coefficient of the disturbances. The message to be derived from these findings should be ccear. If one accepts the fact that most if not all economic time series are trended, and endorses a proposition that the fundamental if not sole purpose of Monte Carlo studies in econometrics should be to provide useful guidelines to practicing econometricians, then, he must not employ SNARl (nor anyother artificially created nontrended series) as a generator of exogenous variables in a Monte Carlo study, at least in the econometrics of autocorrelated disturbances. Alternative methods of generating stochastic exogenous variables that are trended are suggested in the paper. For almost four decades, the principle of the autoregressive transformation of a regression model with first-order autocorrelated disturbances (the Coestimation priciple) has been taken for granted as a method of correcting for the autocorrelation in the disturbances—be it in the two-stage Cochrane—Orcutt estimator, the iterative Cochrane-Orcutt estimator, or an estimator utilizing nonlinear techniques or search procedures. (Comitting the first observation due to transformation is not considered very crucial in general.) The results of the pertinent Monte Carlo studies appear to justify such a procedure only because most studies have employed SNARl exogenous variables, not trended ones. Thus, Monte Carlo experimenters must be blamed, at least partially, for this prevailining malpractice. It is hoped that they will not commit additional sins by not using realistic data in their future experiments.

Keywords:

• Monte Carlo Experiment
• Exogenous Variables
• Autocorrelated Disturbances

^∗The author is grateful to an anonymous referee for useful comments. The original version of this paper was presented at the 1977 American Statistical Association Annual Meeting and was abstracted in its Business and Economic Statistics Section Proceedings.

^∗The author is grateful to an anonymous referee for useful comments. The original version of this paper was presented at the 1977 American Statistical Association Annual Meeting and was abstracted in its Business and Economic Statistics Section Proceedings.

Notes

^∗The author is grateful to an anonymous referee for useful comments. The original version of this paper was presented at the 1977 American Statistical Association Annual Meeting and was abstracted in its Business and Economic Statistics Section Proceedings.