Culture, utility or social systems? Explaining the cross-national ties of emigrants from Borşa, Romania

Abstract

Emigrants from Borşa, Romania, display two quite distinct patterns of ties with their community of origin: migration to Italy is discernibly transnational, with a strong reliance on migrant networks; while migration to the UK is more individualistic, with emigrants shunning interaction with compatriots and retaining only weak ties to Borşa. We argue that prevalent theories of cross-national ties fail adequately to explain this divergence. Instead, we draw on systems theory to explain the discrepancy in terms of divergent conditions for societal inclusion. In Italy, incorporation into parallel, unofficial structures of work, welfare and accommodation encouraged a reliance on cultural criteria for maintaining social ties. In the UK, migrants were obliged to integrate into state-sponsored systems, encouraging the relinquishing of ethnic ties in favour of more strategic networking to facilitate societal inclusion.

Keywords:

• Culture of migration
• transnational migration
• migrant networks
• social interactions
• Romanian migration
• irregular migration

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank Michael Bommes, Tim Elrick, Alistair Hunter and Lynn and the anonymous reviewers of ERS Staeheli for their very useful comments on earlier drafts.