New legislative settings and the application of the participative-democratic model of mainstreaming equality in public policy making: evidence from the UK's devolution programme

Abstract

Studies of established parliamentary contexts highlight institutional barriers to mainstreaming equality of opportunity in public policy-making. In contrast, this paper uses an actor-centred institutionalist perspective to explore the case of the new devolved legislatures in the UK purposively designed with mechanisms to broaden engagement in the policy process. It assesses progress in applying the participative-democratic model of mainstreaming to policy-making. The findings – based upon analysis of legislative proceedings and equality and human rights organisations' accounts – reveal that ‘system openness’ has afforded opportunities to engage in – and influence – policy work. Yet, problems and shortcomings are also identified – signifying a ‘disconnect’ between the rhetoric and reality of mainstreaming at the meso-level – and continuity with the pre-existing policy style in UK governance. The wider significance of this is that potential gains afforded by the adoption of mainstreaming in legislative settings purposively designed to foster the engagement of exogenous interests can be negated by leadership issues and government failure to secure the full range of pre-requisites prescribed by mainstreaming theory.

Keywords:

• mainstreaming
• equality
• neo-institutionalism
• policy
• participation
• devolution

Notes

1. Nvivo9.

2. 286 documents.

3. Minutes Of The Voluntary Sector Meeting With Sue Essex AM, 19 May 2005.

4. Meeting between Business Minister Jane Hutt AM and the Voluntary Sector, 10 June 2005.

5. Minutes of the Voluntary Sector meeting with Sue Essex AM (Minister for Finance, Local Government and Public Services) 19 October 2006.

6. Meeting between the Business Minister and the Voluntary Sector, Thursday 8 December 2005.

7. See TSPC (10) 13 Ministerial Update On Actions Arising From TSPC Meeting On 29 April 2010.

8. For example, in Wales 2008–2009 the annual value of the Promoting Equality Fund was £2M.

9. Interview, 3 July 2004.

10. Interview, 6 July 2008.

11. National Assembly for Wales (NAfW) (2008) The funding of voluntary sector organisations in Wales, p. 3.

12. Interview, 25 October 2003.

13. Interview, 10 June 2007.

14. Interview, 8 September 2008.

15. Interview, 7 February 2004.

16. Interview, 8 July 2008.

17. Interview, 16 June 2005.

18. Interview, 5 June 2004.

19. Interview, 17 November 2009.

20. Interview, 4 September 2007.

21. Interview, 7 July 2003.

22. Interview, 4 November 2008.

23. Interview, 4 December 2009.

24. Royal National Institute of Blind People Cymru (2008), p. 28.

25. Scottish Women's Aid (2010) Listen louder, unpaginated.

26. Interview, 14 March 2005.

27. Interview, 11 February 2007.

28. Interview, 17 May 2007.

29. Wales Council for the Blind (2001).

30. Interview, 11 September 2008.

31. Scottish Women's Aid (2008), p. 5.

32. Age Concern Cymru (2007), p. 6.

33. Help the Aged Wales (2007), p. 3.

34. Interview, 16 April 2007.

35. Interview, 23 April 2004.

36. Interview, 3 March 2005.

37. Cited in Reeves, 2007, pp. 38–49.

38. Interview, 19 May 2007.

39. Interview, 14 February 2007.

40. NAfW (2008) The funding of voluntary sector organisations in Wales, p. 28.

41. NAfW (2008) The funding of voluntary sector organisations in Wales, p. 32.

42. Interview, 20 May 2007.

43. Interview, 18 May 2007.

44. Cardiff and the Vale Coalition of Disabled People (2006), p. 3.

45. Minority Ethnic Women's Network Cymru (MEWN) (2007), p. 36.

46. Interview 5 April 2010.

47. Interview, 15 August 2009.

48. Interview, 17 March 2009.

49. Under the provisions of the Adult Support and Protection (Scotland) Act (2007).

50. Scottish Parliament Equal Opportunities Committee (2006), p. 10.

51. Official Record, E.O. Committee, 7 October 2003.

52. Official Record, E.O. Committee, 6 June 2006.

53. Official Record, E.O. Committee, 15 June 2004.

54. Official Record, E.O. Committee, 1 November 2005.

55. E.O. Committee Inquiry, p. 56.

56. LGBT Hearts and Minds Agenda Group (2007).

57. Official Record, E O. Committee, 24 May 2005.

58. Random Sample 42 meetings 2003–2007; N = 86; Percentages do not total 100% owing to rounding.

59. Official Record, Petitions Committee, 23 March 2010.

60. See WAG (2007).

61. Letter – Deputy Minister for Social Services to the Petitions Committee, 15 February 2008.

62. Official Record, Petitions Committee, 2 October 2008.

63. Petitions Committee, completion_report_p-03-167, 20.11.08.

64. Petition submitted by Cymdeithas yr Iaith Gymraeg, 01.07.08.

65. Official Record, Petitions Committee, 13 January 2009.

66. 17 May 2004.

67. 17 May 2004.

68. 22 November 2004.

69. 10 June 2005.

70. 25 June 2003.

71. 25 May 2006.

72. 18 May 2004.

73. 6 February 2006.

74. 19 May 2005.

75. 15 November 2004.

76. 14 November 2004.

77. 18 July 2007.

78. 7 June 2006.

79. 24 November 2005.

80. 8 December 2005.

81. 17 May 2004.

82. 19 May 2005.

83. 6 February 2006.

84. 8 December 2005.

85. 7 June 2006.

86. 14 November 2005.

87. 24 November 2005.

88. 18 July 2007.

89. 7 June 2006.

90. 10 June 2005.

91. 25 May 2006.