Negative emotions can attenuate the influence of beliefs on logical reasoning

Abstract

Although the influence of beliefs on logical reasoning is well documented, how emotions modulate the effect of beliefs during reasoning remains unexamined. We instructed participants to reason about syllogisms involving neutral or emotionally charged content. We also manipulated the consistency of beliefs with logical validity. When content was neutral, participants exhibited the belief-bias effect observed in previous studies of reasoning. In contrast, when confronted with emotionally charged content participants were less likely to be influenced by their beliefs. Our results suggest that under certain conditions negative emotions can attenuate the influence of beliefs during logical reasoning. Drawing on the affect infusion model, we attribute this effect to a more vigilant, systematic scrutiny of beliefs in the presence of negative emotions.

Keywords:

• Belief
• Emotion
• Reasoning

Acknowledgements

This study was supported by a McDonnell-Pew Program in Cognitive Neuroscience Award, a Premier's Research Excellence Award, and NSERC research grants to Vinod Goel.