Abstract
Sexual violence is recognised as a public health and human rights problem worldwide. Although schools are expected to be safe places for young people and are envisaged as institutions that challenge social injustices, they are increasingly identified as sites where disproportionately high levels of sexual violence occurs. This study seeks to understand how sexual violence in schooling contexts is conceptualised and interrogated by teachers with a focus on lived experiences, the consequences and the underlying causes. The study is based on qualitative research conducted at a secondary school in Ethiopia. The findings point to overwhelming evidence that sexual violence pervades in secondary schools, with a wide range of adverse consequences on girls’ wellbeing and educational attainment. The study demonstrates how nature, culture and society are included in conceptual thinking about the causes of sexual violence and explores teachers’ agency in addressing the phenomenon.
Introduction
Sexual violence is one of the most widespread public health problems and human rights violations worldwide (Leach and Mitchell Citation2006). The World Health Organisation (WHO) (Citation2002) estimated that 150 million girls and 73 million boys (below 18 years of age) experienced forced sexual intercourse or other forms of sexual violence. Consequently, the organisation declared this phenomenon in a subsequent report as a silent health emergency of global importance (WHO Citation2004). Within the context of sub-Saharan Africa, ‘it is deemed to be “un-African”, “unnatural” and very rare’ (Lalor Citation2004, 440), yet there is overwhelming evidence suggesting that sexual abuse is a pervasive problem taking place at home, school, community and in the workplace (Leach et al. Citation2003; Wible Citation2004). While the majority of available studies focus on abuse at home and in the community, schools have been increasingly implicated (Gwirayi Citation2012; Leach Citation2015). The threat to adolescent health caused by the AIDS pandemic has been, in part, the catalyst for turning the spotlight on schools in the past decade, helping to uncover the pervasive scale of sexual violence in educational settings (Leach Citation2003).
This study seeks to advance our understanding of sexual violence through a contextually located analysis at a secondary school in Ethiopia, where research on the topic is scant (Gossaye et al. Citation2003). It uses qualitative research methods and adopts an interpretive approach to analyse teacher perspectives on how sexual violence is defined, what causes it and its consequences. Teachers are reported in many studies as perpetrators and key actors in transforming a school culture that appears to legitimise and perpetuate violence. Yet most of the available studies focus on student perspectives and lack insights on teacher views (de Lange, Mitchell, and Bhana Citation2012). Understanding the role and responsibilities of teachers in addressing sexual violence is imperative since they observe, tolerate, perpetuate or confront the phenomenon in schooling contexts. The article is structured as follows: first we review relevant studies conducted within the context of sub-Saharan Africa, then we offer contextual information about Ethiopia and explain the sample involved and the methods used. This is followed by presentation of the findings, structured as lived experiences, consequences, underlying causes and addressing sexual violence. In the concluding section, we discuss our major findings and their implications.
Sexual violence, causes and consequences
Sexual violence is defined differently by different people, leading to a wide discrepancy in reporting of scale of the phenomenon. According to the most authoritative definition provided by the WHO (Citation2014), sexual violence is:
any sexual act, attempt to obtain a sexual act, unwanted sexual comments or advances, or acts to traffic or otherwise directed, against a person’s sexuality using coercion, by any person regardless of their relationship to the victim, in any setting, including but not limited to home and work. (2)
Underlying causes and risk factors
Sexual violence is a complex problem driven by a multitude of factors at the level of individuals, relationships, family, community and the broader society. Risk factors identified by research included poverty, economic decline, rapid social change and failure of governments to abide by human rights agreement and treaties (Lalor Citation2004; Leach Citation2003). Moreover, gender relations are central to understanding sexual violence. Numerous studies point to patriarchy, masculine hegemony and heteronormativity as contexts in which sexual violence is perpetuated, tolerated and even normalised (de Lange, Mitchell, and Bhana Citation2012).
Schools play a highly important role in socialising children and young people about gender relations and sexuality. Based on a study in Uganda, Muhanguzi (Citation2011) suggests that ‘schools offer a vigorous social cultural discursive environment in which students’ interaction is characterised by gendered sexual expectations and power imbalances with deep-seated lack of female sexual autonomy in sexual relationships, compulsory heterosexuality and sexual exploitation of females’ (716). Based on her study in Ghana, Malawi and Zimbabwe, Leach (Citation2003) reports that abusive behaviour towards girls by older boys and male teachers is widespread and institutionalised. Students are socialised within a school culture that tolerates and ‘normalises’ gender-based violence.
Immediate and long-term impact of sexual violence
Sexual violence is associated with a wide range of negative outcomes on physical and mental health and social wellbeing (Jewkes and Abrahams Citation2002). Negative impact on physical health includes causing physical injury or even death, teenage pregnancy, unsafe abortion, chronic pelvic pain and sexually transmitted diseases (including HIV infection). Its implications on mental health can be equally severe, such as guilt, shame, humiliation, anger, anxiety disorders, heightened levels of stress, eating disorders, low self-esteem, self-disgust, post-traumatic stress disorder, depression and withdrawal from social contact. Moreover, sexual violence can have major negative consequences for the social wellbeing of the victims as they can be stigmatised and ostracised by their own families and others in their environment (Muhanguzi Citation2011; WHO Citation2002).
Sexual violence has negative bearings on the education system as well. When it takes place between peers or when the perpetrator is a teacher, victims might feel agony about coming to school. This might eventually lead to school alienation and withdrawal. Furthermore, the psychological ramifications of sexual abuse might impair cognitive development and functioning of victims, undermine their self-confidence and limit their capacity for concentration and comprehension (Le Mat Citation2016; Muhanguzi Citation2011). Consequently, their achievement level might decrease. In some cases, it can also lead to high rates of absenteeism, loss of interest in education, change of schools and drop-out.
Contextual background
Women in Ethiopian society are often in a lower position compared to men (the country ranks 174th out of 188 in UNDP’s [2014] Gender Inequality Index). Gender inequalities include early marriages, female genital mutilation, domestic violence and fewer education and work opportunities (UN-HABITAT Citation2008). The country is under increasing international pressure because of such sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) concerns, and for reasons related to human rights in general. The 2009 Charities and Societies Proclamation law continues to severely curtail the ability of independent non-governmental organisations to work on human rights. The law bars work on human rights, good governance, conflict resolution and advocacy on the rights of women, children and people with disabilities if organisations receive more than 10% of their funds from foreign sources (Human Rights Watch Citation2016, 3). This has implications on the work of non-governmental organisations (NGOs) on sexual and reproductive health (note that ‘R’ – standing for Rights – is omitted for this reason by many NGOs on their work on SRHR).
Ethiopia’s prevalence rate of intimate partner violence is one of the highest among countries included in the WHO Multi Country Study of Violence Against Women (World Health Organization Citation2005). Results from community and school-based studies indicate that 50–67% of Ethiopian women experience gender-based violence in their lifetime (Gossaye et al. Citation2003; Mullu et al. Citation2015). Furthermore, in secondary schools there are serious concerns about the high prevalence of sexual violence, with one study reporting that in the east of Ethiopia, 70% of young men and 68% of young women, respectively, had offended or became a victim of sexual violence (Bekele Citation2012). In another study among 1401 female high school students in Addis Ababa and Western Shoa, 74% of respondents reported sexual harassment (Gelaye et al. Citation2009). A recent study on abuse of young men demonstrated that the lifetime prevalence of rape was 4.3% and the prevalence of sexual harassment was 68.2% (Haile, Kebeta, and Kassie Citation2013).
However, sexual violence is treated with secrecy, and young women in particular tend to choose silence to avoid being regarded as indecent (Kebede, Hilden, and Middelthon Citation2014). It is also considered shameful to disclose family matters and ‘personal humiliation’. Consequently, incidences of sexual violence are rarely brought to justice. Another reason for underreporting sexual violence relates to the weaknesses in the law enforcement system (Gossaye et al. Citation2003). Thus, girls and women grow up in a society in which sexual violence is widespread and fostered by a culture that reinforces men’s superiority over women (Berhane et al. Citation2001). This leaves very limited space for young girls to openly speak about their sexuality. Consequently, there have been very few studies so far on the topic in Ethiopia (Gossaye et al. Citation2003). Until now, studies on sexual violence in schools and communities in Ethiopia have been mostly quantitative, aiming to understand the scope of the problem and examine the connection between gender-based violence and indicators of depression (Deyassa et al. Citation2009; Gelaye et al. Citation2009; Gossaye et al. Citation2003). This study, however, aims to complement these findings from a more qualitative/interpretative approach, focusing on the views of teachers to better understand how and why sexual violence continues to be prevalent in schools despite increasing awareness and knowledge about the scope and urgency of the problem.
The study
The article draws on a study based on qualitative research methods to develop a deeper understanding of the ‘personal’ within its immediate and wider social and political contexts. A general, state secondary school in Addis Ababa is selected as a case study. The school is located close to the city’s bus station and Merkato, Africa’s biggest daily market. The area is known as one of the poorer neighbourhoods of the city, inhabited mostly by rural migrants. It offers the first two grades of secondary education (grades 9 and 10) and students are between 14 and 18 years old. There were 2136 students enrolled at the time of research (52% female), mostly from low-income migrant and merchant families. Education in (SRH) is not compulsory in Ethiopia, however, this school adopted a co-curricular programme to teach on SRH related issues. However, participation in the programme remains limited to a few teachers and students. It is also crucial to note that school is located in an area where sex work takes place. According to some teachers, 20–30% of parents were involved in sex work, including some of the students as well.
The data presented in this article was collected in the spring of 2013 during two-months of fieldwork by the second author. It is based on semi-structured interviews with SRH professionals (3 from an NGO that was involved in developing and implementing the SRH programme at the school and 1 SRH expert at a bilateral donor organisation) and 11 teachers (6 female and 5 male). Moreover, two focus-group discussions involving 8 teachers were conducted (one with 3 female teachers and another one with 5 male teachers). Two male teachers were interviewed and took part in focus-group discussions (FGDs) as well; hence, in total, the views of 17 teachers were explored in this study. All teachers who volunteered to take part in the study were interviewed. Considering that there were 118 teachers (24% female) at the school, there was a self-selection bias. Their age ranged between 25 and 40 years. Two of them were involved in teaching an SRH programme and the others taught different subjects. Interviews and focus-group discussions were conducted in English, which appeared to be challenging at times. The teachers’ varying levels of difficulty with English was striking as the language of instruction in the school is English. During FGDs, teachers sometimes did translations for their colleagues. During interviews, sometimes participants spoke in Amharic first, before translating to English themselves. In some cases, an additional translation was sought by an Ethiopian research assistant. No translators were used during interviews because of the sensitivity of the subject.
Interviews took between 30 and 40 minutes, while FGDs lasted between 60 and 90 minutes. The conversations with teachers took place in a quiet classroom to ensure privacy and confidentiality, and interviews with SRH professionals took place in their offices. The FGDs were conducted in same-gender compositions because this makes sharing ideas easier, especially on highly sensitive topics (Bloor et al. Citation2001). Confidentiality was ensured and emphasised before starting the interviews and FGDs, and the participants’ permission was obtained to record the conversations. Participants were free to switch off the recorder in case they felt uncomfortable or withdraw from the study without giving a reason. No reimbursements were provided to the participants.
Recordings of the interviews and FGDs were transcribed verbatim into narrative reports and coded by using Atlas.ti. A pre-defined code list was developed based on a literature review and this was expanded during coding process. To enhance the reliability of analysis, the coding was done by both authors separately, as they read the transcriptions and coded the texts independent of each other, and compared and discussed afterwards. Major codes included definitions of sexual abuse, causes, consequences and strategies to address sexual abuse. In addition, all interviews were read once again and a conceptual map of emerging themes and issues was prepared manually. The participants are quoted in length below to give them voice and to allow the readers draw their own conclusions.
Lived experiences at secondary schools
When asked about prevalence of sexual violence, teachers offered some contrasting narratives: a few of them argued that there was ‘none’ or ‘not much’ sexual violence at their school, while some others claimed that there was definitely a lot. Nevertheless, there was an overall recognition of its presence at secondary schools in general, particularly in rural areas. The small size of our sample is not conducive to making statistical inferences or making generalisations about female or male teachers. Nevertheless, it is interesting to note that there was much more awareness and recognition of sexual violence among male teachers in our sample, or they had chosen to speak about it more candidly.
There is no much harassment in our school …. No problem in this school. (Female teacher 6)
I hear from my colleagues, friends about this. And even in different schools, teachers also abuse girl students for sex … this is a major problem in our country, even in the countryside. (Male teacher 4)
I am telling you the truth. I have noticed that many teachers, not many teachers but few … some teachers that I know personally have relationship, sexual relationship with students … I know one of the teachers has a child by one of his students. (Male teacher 8, FGD)
Sexual violence perpetrated by boys was framed within a broader framework of gender-based violence and a pervasive culture of male aggression. The following were discussed as violent behaviour: boys forcing or seeking to entice girls into having sex; insulting, hitting and beating girls in an effort to feel stronger and more powerful; throwing rocks at them; taking girls’ property without permission; making girls carry the belongingness of boys; and forcing girls to do boys’ homework or providing answers during exams. Some teachers also highlighted the excessive scale of verbal abuse to frighten and distress girls. There were also unwelcome comments on dresses and on one’s appearance, girls with bigger breasts and nice hair being disproportionately targeted in such instances:
They hit, they abuse them [girls]. They tell unnecessary words …. So many words. I hear, and I forget them. (Female teacher 1)
Male students, boys, can always insult the girls. In most cases what you dress, what you look like … just verbal. (Female teacher 3)
If they asked you a relationship … and you say, no I am not ready for this, they do not accept you did not want it … If they loved you and if you say no, they will come by force … [they would say] I will kill you, I will hit you. (Female teacher 4)
Such accounts were also reported in Ugandan secondary schools by Muhanguzi (Citation2011) ‘all the girls testified that their rejection of boys’ invitations were always met with horrid abuse and harassment’ (718). Moreover, Leach (Citation2003) suggests similar patterns in Zimbabwe: ‘Threatening or violent behaviour, or sexually explicit verbal abuse designed to humiliate her, was often the consequence of a girl turning down a boy’s proposal’ (390).
Teachers are also implicated as perpetrators of sexual violence, even though none of the teachers interviewed reported any wrongdoing. Some teachers sought (forced or consensual) sexual liaisons with their students, in particular to bargain sex in exchange for higher grades or financial support. Examples of teacher harassment also included going to sports classes and staring at girls and commenting on their look in ways that make girls highly uncomfortable. The following remarks are illustrative:
Female students, without their interest, they are forced to start the love, the love relationship …. Most of the time, they do not want, but by force they do it. Because [they are] afraid of their teachers. (Female teacher 8, FGD)
He will appoint her to come home and unless she goes home and do some things with him, he will not correct her exam results. (Male NGO expert 3)
Some teachers kick the female students …. A teacher picks her because he wants to do this sexual intercourse with her, but she refuses, by covering that situation he only say ‘she is stupid, she doesn’t want to learn, so I kick her’. (Male teacher 3)
The students, in the night they will dress some convenient way, they will stand over on the roads, and some guys pick them up. And they do the sexual intercourse for money. (Male teacher 3)
I have seen with my naked eyes … at the break time and at the lunch time, they [drivers] stopped their car in front of the school and they had an appointment with girls. They had girls in their cars. And they drove away and took her. (Male teacher 2, FGD)
If there is someone who is assigned to hear all the complaints, then we would have gone to that person to report. But, one there is no law, second there is no one to hear it for you …. Because all the teachers are friends in the school. So if you are going to report the case, he can easily deceive the information and he uses to advantage and influence other teachers. (Female NGO expert 2)
They might say ‘Ah no we have never heard of sexual violence in the school’. They could say that. But, you just tell them that there are more, because that’s why you need the literature, references. Then you say that there have been many sexual harassments or violence happening in schools, but never been reported. (Female NGO expert 2)
Consequences of sexual violence
The consequences of sexual violence were mainly discussed in relation to how they adversely affect girls, focusing on implications for physical and mental health, social wellbeing and education. Concerns about physical health highlighted sexually transmitted infections (particularly HIV), unwanted pregnancies, abortions and their possible negative implications on health. Detrimental effects on girls’ psychological wellbeing included anxiety, a pervasive sense of fear and insecurity, loss of self-esteem and confidence, overwhelmingly negative self-image and depression. Furthermore, girls’ social wellbeing was undermined due to self-inflicted isolation, decrease in participation in social activities and loneliness. Girls also experienced stigmatisation and discrimination within their social environment, particularly due to pregnancy as it considered a taboo before marriage. Several of these have direct consequences on girls’ schooling in terms of achievement levels, the quality of educational experiences and continuation of their schooling. Participants referred to lack of concentration in the class, prolonged absences from school and early drop-out:
The girls always, you know, give up …. Some of the students may break their learning and drop out of school. They try to solve their problems by withdrawing from the school. (Female teacher 5)
They [girls] will not follow the education, so they fail in education. (Male teacher 3)
Underlying causes
The participants highlighted the embeddedness and multi-dimensionality of sexual violence in schooling contexts, and discussed a wide range of factors related to individuals involved, peer influence, families and broader society. This debate also underscored the fact that violence is not peculiar to schools. In fact, what is happening at schools needed to be interpreted and understood within its broader societal context:
Be it at school, at the family level, or on the way, violence is there … not only forced sex … but it is mental, psychologically, everything. (Male NGO expert 1)
Individual factors
On an individual level, boys’ aggression and sexual behaviour is mainly explained by their age and developmental stage, but love and attraction were also cited. Boys were described as being in the ‘fire age’ and having ‘uncontrollable’ urges. They were also seen as immature and unable to comprehend the consequences of their actions. Moreover, boys appeared to lack awareness about gender equality and they were unable to understand the dynamics of intimate relationships, for example the imperative of love and respect in relationships or how forcing girls to do things without their consent is unacceptable:
Because these students are in adolescent age. In adolescent age they are not too matured … so in biology it is the time of this sexual violence … as you know in their biology, nature also forces them. (Female teacher 1)
Students are in fire age. (Female teacher 2)
Some teachers, you know, can need sexual relation with students. Students [are] scared, because they make up low results. (Female teacher 3)
We are professionals here. So, the problem is the teacher’s problem. If a teacher has committed this mistake, one way or the other, it’s totally the mistake of the teachers. (Male teacher 8, FGD)
The mindset of policemen, the mindset of community … of the judge and court is as usual. Not yet changed. (Male NGO expert 1)
Laws should be in place. However, in this country even when there are laws they are not effectively implemented. It is not that the government does not want to implement them but they do not have the capacity. (Male SRHR expert at a bilateral donor agency)
Furthermore, a wide range of casual explanations related to girls were also proposed to explain their vulnerability to sexual violence. Some suggested that girls are ‘weak’ to stop abusive acts and they learn to accept it as the ‘norm’ since ‘it happens all the time’. Most of the claims about girls point toward some personality characteristics that create an environment in which sexual violence is tolerated and perpetuated, such as lack of confidence and assertiveness, submissiveness, obedience, low self-esteem, sense of inferiority or inability to express or protect themselves. These narratives portray a ‘deficit’ model of girls:
They [girls] do not have respect for themselves. (Male teacher 4)
They are too shy and they are too afraid to defend themselves if they are asked in such a way. They don’t have the intention to report the issue to the concerned body also. (Male teacher, 2 FGD)
As you know in nature, female do not resist the power of the male. Because of that they can attack. (Female teacher 1)
She does not have any chance to stop it, so instead of [getting] angry on that thing, she smiles and goes. (Male teacher 3)
I mean, it’s just like selling sex with a grade, transactional sex. So I don’t know whether they are forced to do it, like one girl I told you she had a relationship with her teacher. But … I can’t tell you whether she’s forced, or she wanted to have it. But it’s a win-win. Some girls also take that advantage …. They don’t have to study or work hard to get an A. (Female NGO expert 2)
Peer influence and family
The influence of peers was brought up, particularly the way girls might influence one another into seeking transactional sex:
When you see a friend of them, when she gets money from a guy, and when she spends it on buying clothes and wearing shoes something like that, it is easy to understand how her friend could be influenced … yes, it’s a common thing in schools. For little time they spend, they get big money. (Male teacher 1)
The powerful socialisation effect of the home environment, effectively ‘normalising’ gender inequality and gender-based violence, was also debated in this regard:
Even the person who tells you that women in all aspects … are equal to men, if you go to his home, he may do the same thing what he accepts from their parents or from this culture. (Male teacher 1)
Moreover, the ‘big gap’ between parents and children is pointed out in Ethiopian culture, making it very difficult to have open communication on sensitive issues (see also Browes Citation2015). For instance, one teacher noted that when girls share their experiences or apprehensions, they do not necessarily get support from their parents. Talking about sex remains a taboo. Moreover, parents do not allow boys and girls to be friends; such encounters are not viewed ‘decent’, often having (or fearing) adverse consequences for girls:
A lot of things are in our culture, most words we can never talk. Even talking about sex is … yes. So, most of them [girls] are scared. (Female teacher 3)
Societal factors
The participants also discussed broader societal and economic factors to analyse the pervasiveness of sexual violence. These included gender inequality, poverty, adverse cultural practices and norms, religion, lack of education and the impact of globalisation and modernisation. They referred to deeply held gender perspectives and norms that treated women and girls unfairly and accorded them little voice and rights. Many perceived sexual violence as a symptom of such inequalities that are deeply ingrained within society:
I think the basic cause for sexual violence is gender inequality … most of the time males feel superior than females and nothing will happen if he performs any kind of sexual violence on girls. (Male teacher 4)
Men are expected to be dominant and they are aggressive. Many husbands hurt their wives. It’s clearly shown in Ethiopia. (Male teacher 7, FGD)
One saying in Amharic [for woman] is ‘personal belongingness’. Women are like if this [grabs a mobile phone] is yours, if you’re a man, then this is the woman …. A woman is just like that …. Personal belongingness to a man. Or, to a family. Like a woman cannot say anything, or [have] power. (Female NGO expert 2)
Even sometimes some religion will support females to be dependent on her husband and the like things. So that has to be solved. (Male teacher 4)
If a girl is not educated, if she doesn’t have income, I don’t think there will be a solution. (Female NGO expert 2)
They are exposed to pornography, they are exposed to foreign films, movies … to songs like rap. So when they are watching that, they directly perceive things and they try to. (Male teacher 7, FGD)
Even in small towns you can easily get Internet …. So those information are very biased, for example, the music we see, like this Western American music, all naked girls. It gives them the wrong impression about growing up. You have to be like show your boobs or your ass and all these sexual messages are biased …. Because of that, young people are very sexual now at the time then it was before. (Female NGO expert 2)
They get these things from globalization. They see different kinds of films. So, that’s why they do this sexual violence. (Female teacher 8, FGD)
Addressing sexual violence
Female teachers were more reserved in acknowledging sexual violence, recognising the scale of it, and attributing responsibilities to teachers. One of the rare studies on teacher voice on the subject also documents similar tendencies among female teachers in South Africa, ‘with women teachers from the same school, we heard a more tentative voice, hesitant in identifying and ascribing blame to males in an outright way’ (de Lange, Mitchell, and Bhana Citation2012, 500). Relative silences among female teachers might be informed by the patriarchal nature of Ethiopian society, and a culture that does not encourage women to speak up, criticise and confront injustices, particularly when they concern male behaviour. Such socialisation and conditioning are likely to impede female teachers’ determination and capacity to address sexual violence in their schools. Nevertheless, when we asked teachers how they reacted to the instances of sexual violence in their daily work, female teachers were more articulate about how they intervened:
I will interfere between them: ‘Don’t touch her!’ Then, they will also argue with me. ‘Why not teacher, why? You are female so you will support them.’ (Female teacher 1)
Some other female teachers also noted how they monitored their classrooms in order to make sure that appropriate behaviour is observed by everyone. They talked about the importance of education, how education is for all and that both sexes are equal. They also offered guidance and specific advices depending on the situation. A female teacher who had training in psychology had many girls coming to her to talk about their concerns, instances of rape or deliberate low grading by teachers to ask for sexual favours. She informed the management and sought a solution. Yet, she was also concerned that many girls were scared, that so many instances went unreported. She also had girl representatives in all classrooms who acted as mediators between the teacher and the girls who were hesitant to talk about their experiences of sexual violence. The representatives would speak to their classmates to encourage them to speak out and seek help. In some cases, the management involved parents as well. Furthermore, female teachers emphasised the importance of approaching boys in a peaceful manner not to fuel their anger or to be the target of their aggressiveness. One teacher particularly noted how some of the boys were much bigger than themselves and how they could be physically intimidating.
Male teachers, however, reported few instances of girls seeking their support, which is not surprising considering the gendered roles and the culture of silencing girls in the presence of men. Girls were perceived as shy and not knowing how to express their feelings. This created a dilemma for male teachers: they wanted to help, but how could they if girls did not talk about their problems? Several male teachers talked about the importance of girls’ clubs that inform the girls as well as train them in specific competencies.
Furthermore, lack of counselling services for students who experience sexual violence remained a concern. The counsellors were mostly preoccupied with students coming late to school and there were few students who consulted them about sexual abuse. According to a male teacher, this was mainly due to discomfort and unease they felt in approaching counsellors and discussing issues involving sexuality. During an FGD with male teachers, some argued that students should be able to approach counsellors even when they were in love, or attracted to someone, just to express their feelings and seek advice. Yet, such matters were hardly ever discussed openly and mostly kept hidden.
Overall, addressing sexual violence was viewed as a complex, multifaceted and challenging undertaking by the participants. They discussed a range of strategies in this respect, including sexuality education, involving parents, training teachers and installing clear rules and regulations. A general sentiment pointed to the need for an inclusive and holistic approach and assigning clear responsibilities to the respective stakeholders.
You can’t ignore that there is the issue, but all the issues, all the plans, goals, objectives, and all this efforts, remain only on paper. So nobody is accountable to perform it in action, to solve the problem. (Male teacher 2)
If the person is an educated person, he will understand you that you do not want … if you study, if you develop yourself, your future is always bright. It goes bright. (Female teacher 4)
Conclusion
Our findings point to overwhelming evidence that sexual violence is persistent in secondary schools and in other social contexts in Ethiopia. Although some studies report how teachers downplay or dismiss sexual violence (Mirsky Citation2003), teachers – particularly male teachers – in our sample were forthcoming in revealing its scale and nature. Within the context of this discussion, we found two observations rather intriguing. First, as teachers were discussing grave implications of sexual violence on young girls, they appeared to be detached emotionally from the topic, displayed little empathy with girls and rarely expressed a sense of outrage at the injustices. Rather, their approach seemed to be quite pragmatic and their views on how to address the problem were almost technical at times. This may explain in part why school-based interventions, such as CSE programmes, have had so little impact. While the CSE programmes contributed to more sympathetic peer relations (see Le Mat Citation2016), future studies might explore how teachers and their responsibilities can be better incorporated and consulted in addressing sexual violence.Second, the implications of sexual violence concerned only the ‘victims’. There seemed to be no adverse effects on boys or teachers as long as their case is not ‘successfully’ brought to the court, which happens very rarely. We believe that in order to move the discussion further on sexual violence, there needs to be more attention on how undermining the dignity and well-being of a fellow human being compromises the mental and spiritual development of perpetrators as well. Interdisciplinary research and interventions could further explore such consequences. For instance, CSE programmes could create opportunities for boys to undertake such self-inquiry, or they might be invited to have open and candid talks with girls to enable them to better empathise with their lived experiences. As Davies (Citation2008) remarks:
Gendered violence is not just a problem for the ‘victims’ nor even for the perpetrators, but for culture and society generally. A society that ignores it, or normalises it, has something deeply amiss for all its citizens and for its future as a peaceful or progressive society. (646)
The role of education in this debate was paradoxical. Teacher narratives confirmed a reverse relationship between sexual violence and education, demonstrating a lot of trust in what education can do to eliminate sexual violence. Because of its surrounding context (high poverty levels and the close proximity of sex work), our case study school was keen to raise awareness of young people on sexuality and prepare them for a healthy sexual life. Nevertheless, many teachers noted that schools mirror the injustices and inequalities of the broader society. In fact, young people continue to experience more sexual violence at schools compared to other contexts. This contradiction sends highly mixed messages to students: on the one hand teachers were perceived as an authority, as knowledgeable and wise beings. On the other hand, they were among the perpetrators of sexual violence, and often failed to intervene or demonstrated indifference when such harassment took place. Consequently, schools fail to have a transformative role in the lives of young people. Particularly for young girls, such experiences seem to lead to a strong sense of alienation and frustration (see also Le Mat Citation2016).
As a final note, we like to point to the silence and indifference that surround sexual violence. Even if there is increasing attention paid to the issue, particularly at the level of the international donor community, silences surrounding sexuality and violence need to be overcome to acknowledge the scale and nature of the problem and develop strategic solutions. This is also imperative to challenge the permission given to male students or teachers to commit sexual violence. Furthermore, discussions on the underlying causes of sexual violence reveals a tendency to externalise the problem, which inadvertently denies individual or institutional responsibility. Admittedly, sexual violence is a contextual phenomenon and its elimination requires a concerted effort at many levels (Parkes and Unterhalter Citation2015). Nevertheless, this should not lead to a sense of powerlessness or indifference among teachers or denial of their own agency as persons in position of power.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.
Acknowledgements
We are most thankful to the teachers and SRHR experts who participated in this research.
References
- Bekele, A. B. 2012. “Determinants of Sexual Violence among Eastern Ethiopian Secondary School Students.” Unpublished PhD Dissertation, University of Utrecht.
- Berhane, Y., Y. Gossaye, M. Emmelin, and U. Hogberg. 2001. “Women's Health in a Rural Setting in Societal Transition in Ethiopia.” Social Science & Medicine 53 (11): 1525–1539. doi:10.1016/S0277-9536(00)00441-X.
- Bloor, M., J. Frankland, M. Thomas, and K. Robson. 2001. Focus Groups in Social Research. London: Sage.10.4135/9781849209175
- Browes, N. C. 2015. “Comprehensive Sexuality Education, Culture and Gender: The Effect of the Cultural Setting on a Sexuality Education Programme in Ethiopia.” Sex Education: Sexuality, Society and Learning 15 (6): 655–670. doi:10.1080/14681811.2015.1065476.
- Connell, R. W. 2002. Gender. Cambridge: Polity.
- Davies, L. 2008. “Book Reviews. “Combating Gender Violence in and around Schools”.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 38 (5): 645–647. doi:10.1080/03057920802351507.
- Deyassa, N., Y. Berhane, A. Alem, M. Ellsberg, M. Emmelin, U. Hogberg, and G. Kullgren. 2009. “Intimate Partner Violence and Depression among Women in Rural Ethiopia: A Cross-Sectional Study.” Clinical Practice and Epidemiology in Mental Health 5 (8): 1–10. doi:10.1186/1745-0179-5-8.
- Gelaye, B., D. Arnold, M. A. Williams, M. Goshu, and Y. Berhane. 2009. “Depressive Symptoms among Female College Students Experiencing Gender-Based Violence in Awassa, Ethiopia.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence 24 (3): 464–481. doi:10.1177/0886260508317173.
- Gossaye, Y., N. Deyessa, Y. Berhane, M. Ellsberg, M. Emmelin, M. Ashenafi, A. Alem, et al. 2003. “Butajira Rural Health Program: Women’s Health and Life Events Study in Rural Ethiopia.” Ethiopian Journal of Health Development 17 (2): 1–51.
- Gwirayi, P. 2012. “Child Sexual Abuse among Secondary School Pupils: Impact of Family Characteristics and Family Structure.” International Review of Social Sciences and Humanities 3 (1): 36–50.
- Gwirayi, P. 2013. “The Prevalence of Child Sexual Abuse among Secondary School Pupils in Gweru, Zimbabwe.” Journal of Sexual Aggression 19 (3): 253–263. doi:10.1080/13552600.2012.723755.
- Haile, R. T., N. D. Kebeta, and G. M. Kassie. 2013. “Prevalence of Sexual Abuse of Male High School Students in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.” BMC International Health and Human Rights 13 (24): 1–8. doi:10.1186/1472-698X-13-24.
- Heslop, J., J. Parkes, E. Januario, S. S. Samwel, and T. Hess. 2015. “Sexuality, Sexual Norms and Schooling: Choice-Coercion Dilemmas.” In Gender Violence in Poverty Contexts: The Educational Challenge, edited by Jenny Parkes, 135–150. London and New York: Routledge.
- Human Rights Watch. 2001. Scared at School: Sexual Violence against Girls in South African Schools. New York: Human Rights Watch.
- Human Rights Watch. 2016. “Ethiopia: Country Summary.” https://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/ethiopia.pdf
- Jewkes, R., and N. Abrahams. 2002. “The Epidemiology of Rape and Sexual Coercion in South Africa: An Overview.” Social Science & Medicine 55 (7): 1231–1244. doi:10.1016/S0277-9536(01)00242-8.
- Kebede, M. T., P. K. Hilden, and A. Middelthon. 2014. “Negotiated Silence: The Management of the Self as a Moral Subject in Young Ethiopian Women's Discourse about Sexuality.” Sexuality Education: Sexuality, Society and Learning 14 (6): 666–678. doi:10.1080/14681811.2014.924918.
- Lalor, K. 2004. “Child Sexual Abuse in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Literature Review.” Child Abuse & Neglect 28 (4): 439–460. doi:10.1016/j.chiabu.2003.07.005.
- de Lange, N., C. Mitchell, and D. Bhana. 2012. “Voices of Women Teachers about Gender Inequalities and Gender-Based Violence in Rural South Africa.” Gender and Education 24 (5): 499–514.10.1080/09540253.2011.645022
- Le Mat, M. 2016. “‘Sexual Violence is Not Good for Our Country’s Development’. Students’ Interpretations of Sexual Violence in a Secondary School in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.” Gender and Education 28 (4): 562–580.10.1080/09540253.2015.1134768
- Leach, F. 2003. “Learning to Be Violent: The Role of the School in Developing Adolescent Gendered Behaviour.” Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 33 (3): 385–400. doi:10.1080/03057920302587.
- Leach, F. 2015. “Researching Gender Violence in Schools in Poverty Contexts: Conceptual and Methodological Challenges.” In Gender Violence in Poverty Contexts: The Educational Challenge, edited by Jenny Parkes, 30–47. London and New York: Routledge.
- Leach, F., and P. Machakanja. 2000. Preliminary Investigation into the Abuse of Girls in Zimbabwean Junior Secondary Schools. Education Research Report No. 39, London: DfiD.
- Leach, F., and C. Mitchell, eds. 2006. Combating Gender Violence in and around Schools. Stoke-on-Trent: Trentham.
- Leach, F., V. Fiscian, E. Kadzamira, E. Lemani, and P. Machakanja. 2003. An Investigative Study of the Abuse of Girls in African Schools. Education Research Report No. 56. London: DfID.
- Madu, S. N., and K. Peltzer. 2000. “Risk Factors and Child Sexual Abuse among Secondary School Students in the Northern Province (South Africa).” Child Abuse and Neglect 24 (2): 259–268. doi:10.1016/S0145-2134(99)00128-3.
- Mirsky, J. 2003. Beyond Victims and Villains: Addressing Sexual Violence in the Education Sector. Panos Report No. 47. London: Panos.
- Muhanguzi, F. K. 2011. “Gender and Sexual Vulnerability of Young Women in Africa: Experiences of Young Girls in Secondary Schools in Uganda.” Culture, Health & Sexuality 13 (6): 713–725. doi:10.1080/13691058.2011.571290.
- Mullu, G., A. Gizachew, D. Amare, A. Alebel, F. Wagnew, C. Tiruneh, M. Worku, R. Kediri, S. Tamiru and T. Demsie. 2015. “Prevalence of Gender Based Violence and Associated Factors among Female Students of Menkorer High School in Debre Markos Town, Northwest Ethiopia.” Science Journal of Public Health 3 (1): 67–74. doi:10.11648/j.sjph.20150301.22.
- Parkes, J., and E. Unterhalter. 2015. “Hope and History: Education Engagements with Poverty, Inequality and Gender Violence.” In Gender Violence in Poverty Contexts: The Educational Challenge, edited by Jenny Parkes, 11–29. London and New York: Routledge.
- UN-HABITAT. 2008. Ethiopia: Addis Ababa, Urban Profile. Nairobi: UNON.
- Wible, B. 2004. Making Schools Safe for Girls: Combating Gender-Based Violence in Benin. Washington, DC: US Academy for Educational Development.
- World Health Organisation. 2002. World Report on Violence and Health. Geneva: WHO.
- World Health Organisation. 2004. “Child Sexual Abuse: Salient Health Emergency.” Regional Committee for Africa, Fifty-fourth Session, Brazzaville, Republic of Congo, 30 August–3 September.
- World Health Organization. 2005. WHO Multi-Country Study on Women’s Health and Domestic Violence against Women: Summary Report of Initial Results on Prevalence, Health Outcomes and Women’s Responses. Geneva: WHO.
- World Health Organization. 2014. Understanding and Addressing Violence against Women. Fact Sheet. Geneva: World Health Organization.