Attitudes to the Teaching of History and the use of Creative Skills in Japan and England: a comparative study

Abstract

Students in Cambridgeshire comprehensive schools and in Yamanashi junior high schools aged between 12 and 13 years were given the same questionnaires which explored their views on the nature of history and their experience of history teaching methods. They undertook a test on the creative use of four historical pictures dealing with life for black South Africans in the 1970s, a topic which none had studied at school. The English National Foundation for Educational Research non‐verbal test of intelligence was also administered. In spite of the fact that the use of sources and empathetic historical thinking do not form part of the Japanese historical curriculum, the Japanese students did not perform significantly worse than the English, for whom the interrogation of sources and the deployment of creative thinking are a normal part of the history curriculum. If Japanese teachers want to make a change in their students’ attainment in history, there will be no alteration until there is a change in attitude about the nature of history, the way it is taught and the manner in which is is assessed.