India’s Handling of the Covid-19 Crisis: Could a Rights-Based Approach Overcome Systematic Inadequacies?

Abstract

Covid-19 exposed the fragility and inadequacies in India’s health care system, especially in its public health services. The sudden lockdown imposed during the first wave of the virus severely impacted the livelihoods of millions of migrant workers. Then, in spite of warnings about an impending second wave of infection, the government’s failure to prepare the health infrastructure, together with delays in vaccine distribution, cost the lives of hundreds of thousands of people. Unlike the first wave of infection, the second wave impacted rural India very badly. Taking into consideration the existing social hierarchies and inequalities, it was marginalised groups of the population who bore the brunt of the pandemic. This article analyses the failures of the Indian government in handling the Covid-19 crisis, especially during the second wave, and concludes by suggesting ways in which the state needs to intervene to avert disasters of this kind in the future. It argues for the adoption of a ‘rights-based’ approach to public health on the grounds that successive governments have not been properly held to account for their long-term failures to address the issue.

Keywords:

• Governance
• Informal Sector
• Lockdown
• Migrants
• Public Health Care

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 Abraham Samuel, and Gorky Chakroborty et al., ‘Emerging Governmentality and Biopolitics of Covid-19 in India’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 55. Issue 37 (2020): 26–28.

2 Ibid.

3 Dipankar Sinha, Pandemic, Governance and Communication: The Curious Case of Covid-19. New York: Routledge, 2022, p. 2.

4 Indira Chakravarthi and Imrana Qadeer, ‘Covid 19: Reinforcing the ‘Technical Fix’ and Distorting Public Health in India’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 56. Issue 51 (2021): p. 14.

5 Isabelle Guérin, et al., ‘Surviving Debt and Survival Debt in Times of Lockdown’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 57. Issue 1 (2022): 41–49.

6 Saurabh Kumar, ‘Second Wave of COVID-19: Emergency Situation in India’. Journal of Travel Medicine Vol. 28. Issue 7 (2021).

7 ‘India Covid 19 cases skyrocket amid election campaign’, Al Jazeera, January 8, 2022, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/1/8/india-covid-19-cases-skyrocket-amid-election-campaigns.

8 Hannah Ellis Peterson and Akash Hassan, ‘Kumbh Mela: How a Superspreader Festival Seeded Covid Across India’. The Guardian, May 30, 2021, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/30/kumbh-mela-how-a-superspreader-festival-seeded-covid-across-india.

9 Outlook India, ‘From Pinarayi Vijayan To Kanimozhi, Here’s A List Of Politicians Who Tested Covid Positive While Campaigning’, Outlook India, April 13, 2021, https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-assembly-polls-from-pinarayi-vijayan-to-kanimozhi-heres-a-list-of-politicians-who-tested-covid-positive-while-campaigni/380078 (accessed 20 November 2021).

10 Department-Related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health and Family Welfare, One Hundred Twenty Third Report on the Outbreak of Pandemic Covid-19 and its Management, Parliament of India, November 21, 2020, pp. 21–22, https://rajyasabha.nic.in/rsnew/Committee_site/Committee_File/ReportFile/14/142/123_2020_11_15.pdf (accessed 13 November 2021).

11 P. Singh, ‘India’s COVID-19 emergency’. The Lancet, May 6, 2021, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33965073/2021 (accessed 18 November 2021).

12 Department-Related Parliamentary Standing Committee, op. cit., p. 90.

13 Bhopal Guru, ‘Accumulation of Poor Health Infrastructure’. Economic & Political Weekly, Vol. 56. No. 18 (2021).

14 Pavitra Mohan and Ram Kumar, ‘Strengthening Primary Care in Rural India: Lessons from Indian and Global Evidence and Experience’. J Family Med Prim Care Vol. 8. Issue 7 (2019). https://doi.org/10.4103%2Fjfmpc.jfmpc_426_19.

15 N. Sethi and K. Shrivastava, ‘Frustration in National Covid-19 Task Force’. Article 14, April 24, 2020, https://www.article-14.com/post/no-action-taken-frustration-in-national-covid-19-task-force (accessed 12 March 2022).

16 The Hindu, ‘Centre, States failed to prepare for predictable second wave, says International Commission of Jurists’. The Hindu, April 29, 2021, https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/centre-states-failed-to-prepare-for-predictable-second-wave-says-international-commission-of-jurists/article34441167.ece (accessed 13 November 2021).

17 Department-Related Parliamentary Standing Committee, op. cit., p. 11.

18 Ibid., p. 18.

19 Rajani Suresh, Justine James and R. S. Balraju, ‘Migrant Workers at Crossroads–The Covid-19 Pandemic and the Migrant Experience in India’. Social Work in Public Health Vol. 35. Issue 7 (2020): 633–635.

20 Ibid.

21 Harsh Mander, Locking Down the Poor. New Delhi: Speaking Tiger Books, 2021, p. 18.

22 Suresh, James and Balraju, op. cit., pp. 633–635.

23 Subodh Chandra Pal, Asish Saha, Indrajit Chowdhuri, Paramita Roy, Rabin Chakrabortty and Manisa Shit, op. cit.

24 Utsa Sarmin, ‘Hunger, Humiliation and Death: Perils of Migrant Workers in the Time of COVID-19’, in Ritajyoti Bandhopadhyay, Paula Banerjee and Ranbir Samaddar (Eds.), India’s Migrant Workers and the Pandemic. NY: Routledge, 2022, p. 169.

25 ‘Over 8,700 people died on tracks in 2020 lockdown — many of them were migrants’. The Indian Express, June 2, 2021, https://indianexpress.com/article/india/over-8700-people-died-on-tracks-in-2020-lockdown-many-of-them-were-migrants-7341473 (accessed 13 July 2022).

26 Uma Lele, Sangeeta Bansal and J V Meenakshi, ‘Health and Nutrition of India’s Labour Force and COVID-19 Challenges’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 55. Issue 21 (2020): 13–16.

27 ‘Union govt's schizophrenia led to COVID ravages, says Amartya Sen’. The Hindu, June 5, 2021, https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/indian-govts-schizophrenia-led-to-covid-ravages-says-amartya-sen/article34733278.ece (accessed 18 November 2021).

28 Mander, op. cit., p. 101.

29 Prem Shankar Jha, ‘India Needs a Big-Bang Stimulus, Not Sermons on How There is No Free Lunch’. The Wire, May 12, 2020, https://thewire.in/economy/india-big-bang-stimulus-revival (accessed 15 March 2022).

30 Mahesh Vyas, ‘The Jobs Bloodbath of April 2020’. Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy, May 5, 2020, https://cmie.com/kommon/bin/sr.php?kall=warticle&dt=2020-05-05%2008:22:21&msec=776 (accessed 15 March 2022).

31 Rajan Pandey and Ritajyoti Bandyopadhyay, ‘Covid-19 Migration, Informality, and Postcolonial Capitalist Development’, in Ritajyoti Bandhopadhyay, Paula Banerjee and Ranbir Samaddar (Eds.), India’s migrant Workers and the Pandemic. NY: Routledge, 2022, p. 112.

32 Krishna ram and Shivani Yadav, ‘The Impact of COVID-19 on Poverty Estimates in India: A Study Across Caste, Class and Religion’. Contemporary Voice of Dalit (2021) https://doi.org/10.1177/2455328X211051432. (accessed 12 March 2022).

33 Mahesh Vyas, ‘Treacherous labour statistics’. Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy, February 14, 2022, https://www.cmie.com/kommon/bin/sr.php?kall=warticle&dt=20220214110650&msec=373 (accessed 11 March 2022).

34 Vyas, ‘Treacherous Labour Statistics’, op. cit.

35 Mahesh Vyas, ‘Households have not Recovered’. Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy, December 13, 2021, https://www.cmie.com/kommon/bin/sr.php?kall=warticle&dt=20211213163154&msec=186 (accessed 11 March 2022).

36 K. R. Shyam Sundar and Rahul Suresh Sapkal, ‘Changes to Labour Laws by State Governments will Lead to Anarchy in the Labour Market’, Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 55. Issue 23, 6 Jun 2020.

37 Harsh Mander and Anr. v. Union of India W.P.(C), D.No. 10801/2020.

38 Sonu Pandey, ‘Social Security for Migrant Workers during COVID-19’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 55. No. 26–27 (2020): 22–24.

39 Chakravarthi, op. cit.

40 Dipankar, op. cit.

41 Aseem Prakash and Hem Borker, ‘Pandemic Precarity: Life, Livelihood and Death in the Time of the Pandemic’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 57. Issue No. 5, 29 Jan, 2022, https://www.epw.in/journal/2022/5/review-urban-affairs/pandemic-precarity.html (accessed 7 September 2022)

42 UNICEF, ‘Assessing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic’, https://www.unicef.org/india/reports/assessing-impact-covid-19-pandemic#:~:text=Highlights,to%20health%20services%20and%20education. (accessed 13 July 2022).

43 ‘Global Annual Results Report 2021: Gender equality’, https://www.unicef.org/reports/global-annual-results-2021-gender-equality (accessed 13 July 2022).

44 Ibid., p. 14.

45 Prashansa Srivastava and Prachi Shukla, ‘Crisis behind Closed Doors Domestic Workers’ Struggles during the Pandemic and Beyond’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 56. Issue 22 (2021): 17.

46 E. P. Abdul Azeez, Dandub Palzor Negi, Asha Rani and A. P. Senthil Kumar, ‘The Impact of COVID-19 on Migrant Women Workers in India’. Eurasian Geography and Economics Vol. 62. Issue 1 (2021): 93–112.

47 World Bank, ‘Data: Population, total – India’, https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?end=2019&locations=IN&start=2008 (accessed 12 November 2021).

48 Mathew George, ‘Re-instating a ‘Public Health’ System Under Universal Health Care in India’. Journal of Public Health Policy Vol. 36. Issue 1 (2015): 17. Imrana Qadeer, Health Care Systems in Transition III. India, Part I. The Indian Experience’. Journal of Public Health Medicine Vol. 22, No. 1 (March 2000): 25–32.

49 Atul Bhardwaj, ‘The Second Wave of Death & Disaster: Holding the MEA to Account’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 51. Issue 22 (2021): 10–11.

50 Shruti Dhapola, ‘India’s Covid-19 Vaccine Roll Out Strategy has a Digital Gap; Here are Those Struggling to Plug It’. The Indian Express, June 2, 2021, https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/tech-news-technology/india-covid-19-cowin-portal-vaccine-rollout-strategy-has-a-digital-gap-those-trying-to-fix-it-7338250/.

51 Vrinda Mehta and Shruti Gandhi, ‘The Repercussions of Covid-19 on Health Care Workers in India’. International Journal of Policy Sciences & Law Vol. 2. Issue 2 (2022): 3710–3745.

52 Council of Civil Service Unions v. Minister for the Civil Service, (1984) 3 All ER 935.

53 ‘How Rs 35000 Crores Budget Allocation Spent For Vaccines? Why Can't It Be Used To Vaccinate 18–44 Years Group? SC Asks Centre’. Livelaw.in, June 2, 2021, https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/supreme-court-covid-vaccine-budget-allocation-rs-35000-crores-centre-175098 (accessed 19 November 2021).

54 Sibha S. V. Union of India, Represented by the Secretary and Others, 2021 SCC OnLine Ker 2545.

55 R. Sarwal, U. Prasad, Kalal Madangopal, D. Kaur, A. Kumar, P. Regy, and J. Sharma, ‘Investment Opportunities in India’s Healthcare Sector’. NITI.Gov.in, https://www.niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2021-03/InvestmentOpportunities_HealthcareSector_0.pdf (accessed 16 December 2021).

56 Department-Related Parliamentary Standing Committee, op. cit. (accessed 13 November 2021).

57 Narayan, op. cit.

58 Mark Dayan, Deborah Ward, Tim Gardner and Elaine Kelly, ‘How Good is the NHS?’. The King’s Fund, June 25, 2018, https://www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/files/2018-06/the-nhs-at-70-how-good-is-the-nhs.pdf (accessed 20 December 2021).

59 Daksha Parmar, ‘Public Health During Pandemics and Beyond’. Economic & Political Weekly Vol. 55. Issue 17 (2020): 16.

60 Belinda Bennett and Terry Carney, ‘Pandemic Preparedness in Asia: A Role for Law and Ethics?’. Asia Pacific Journal of Public Health Vol. 23. Issue 3 (2011): 419–425.

61 Pande, op. cit., p. 45.

62 Peter C. Doherty, ‘COVID-19 and Beyond’, The Round Table, 110:1, 171–172, 2021, https://doi.org/10.1080/00358533.2021.1875717 (accessed 16 November 2021).

63 George, op. cit., p. 18.

64 Global Health Security Index, ‘India Overall’, Global Health Security Index, 2021, Ghsindex.org/country/india/ (accessed 20 November 2021).

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Sharmila Narayana

Dr. Sharmila Narayana is a Professor at Christ (Deemed to be University), Bangalore, India.

Nia Susan Chaly

Nia Susan Chaly is a student pursuing her 3rd year B.A. LL.B course in School of Law, Christ (Deemed to be University), Bangalore, India.