Experiences of the use of riverine nutrient models in stakeholder dialogues

Abstract

The potential of models to assist in stakeholder dialogues is assessed regarding options for the reduction of riverine nitrogen loads in a 357‐km² river basin in south central Sweden. Scenarios of remedies based on stakeholders' suggestions were used to stimulate discussions in a panel incorporating farmers, municipality staff, politicians and technical advisers. The farmers perceived the model‐derived discussion material as valuable, although only average conditions at a generic farm were simulated. The panellists demonstrated caution when using regionalized information, but did not request quantitative uncertainty estimates. There was a desire to have phosphorus included in the model‐derived discussion material and to include the impacts of other environmental goals than ‘no eutrophication’. The inclusion of different stakeholder groups in the panel sessions was acknowledged as a way to establish a shared perception of the existing environmental status of the basin and to define the pros and cons of various remedies. This was seen by the panellists as a way to facilitate local implementation of the Water Framework Directive (WFD). Use of model‐stimulated local stakeholder panels is also a way to ensure that involved stakeholders perceive local environmental goals as realistic and acceptable. However, to establish river‐basin stakeholder dialogues as part of the nation‐wide implementation of the WFD directive, it will be necessary to develop a model approach that can be used by local advisers. Perhaps the most critical factor is the moderators' ability to provide an atmosphere of mutual respect between all those involved in contrast to performing one‐way lectures to the participants.

Notes

Correspondence Address: L. Andersson, Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute, S‐601 76 Norrköping, Sweden. Email: [email protected]

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Lotta Andersson

Correspondence Address: L. Andersson, Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute, S‐601 76 Norrköping, Sweden. Email: [email protected]