Personal Network Characteristics of Youth in Substance Use Treatment: Motivation for and Perceived Difficulty of Positive Network Change

ABSTRACT

Background: Among youth in substance use treatment, peer substance use consistently predicts worse treatment outcomes. This study characterized personal (egocentric) networks of treated youth and examined predictors of adolescents’ motivation and perceived difficulty in making changes in the peer network to support recovery. Methods: Adolescents (aged 14–18; N = 155) recruited from substance use treatment reported on substance use severity, motivation to abstain from substance use, abstinence goals such as “temporary abstinence,” motivation and perceived difficulty in reducing contact with substance-using peers, and personal network characteristics. Personal network variables included composition (proportion of abstinent peers) and structure (number of network members, extent of ties among members) for household and nonhousehold (peer) members. Results: Although a majority of peer network members were perceived as using alcohol or marijuana, youth in treatment had relatively high motivation to abstain from substance use. However, treated youths’ motivation to reduce contact with substance-using peers was relatively low. In particular, a goal of temporary abstinence was associated with lower motivation to change the peer network. For marijuana, specifically, network composition features (proportion of abstinent peers) were associated with motivation and perceived difficulty to change the peer network. For marijuana, in particular, network structural variables (extent of ties among members) were associated only with perceived difficulty of changing the peer network. Conclusions: Despite high motivation to abstain from substance use during treatment, adolescents reported low motivation to reduce contact with substance-using peers. Personal motivation to abstain and abstinence goal predicted motivation to reduce contact with substance-using peers. In contrast, particularly for marijuana, network structure predicted perceived difficulty of network change. Results highlight the potential utility of addressing motivation and perceived difficulty to change the peer network as part of youth network-based interventions.

Keywords:

• Adolescent
• alcohol
• marijuana
• social network
• substance use treatment

ACKNOWLEGMENTS

We thank Allan Clifton for his consultation on the project. Portions of this work were presented as a poster at the 2012 Research Society on Alcoholism meeting.

Fundind

This work was supported by National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) grants R01 AA014357, K02 AA018195, and 2K05 AA16928. The funding agency was not involved in the work reported or in the composition of the manuscript.

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

Dr. Chung was responsible for study design and data analysis. Ms. Abraham, Ms. Ruglovsky, and Ms. Schall were involved in data collection. Dr. Chung, Ms. Sealy, Ms. Abraham, Ms. Ruglovsky, Ms. Schall, and Dr. Maisto were involved in interpretation of results and the writing and revision of the manuscript.