The effect of material choice on biofilm formation in a model warm water distribution system

Abstract

Water distribution systems (WDS) are composed of a variety of materials and may harbour potential pathogens within surface-attached microbial biofilms. Biofilm formation on four plumbing materials, viz. copper, stainless steel 316 (SS316), ethylene propylene diene monomer (EPDM) and cross-linked polyethylene (PEX), was investigated using scanning electron microscope (SEM)/confocal microscopy, ATP-/culture-based analysis, and molecular analysis. Material ‘inserts’ were incorporated into a mains water fed, model WDS. All materials supported biofilm growth to various degrees. After 84 days, copper and SS316 showed no significant overall differences in terms of the level of biofilm formation observed, whilst PEX supported a significantly higher level ofbiofilm. EPDM exhibited gross contamination by a complex, multispecies biofilm, at a level significantly higherthan was observed on the other materials, regardless of the analytical method used. PCR-DGGE analysis showed clear differences in the composition of the biofilm community on all materials after 84 days. The primary conclusion of this study has been to identify EPDM as a potentially unsuitable material for use as a major component in WDS.

Keywords:

• biofilm formation
• water distribution system
• EPDM
• PEX
• copper
• stainless steel

Acknowledgements

This work was undertaken as part of the research project ‘Biofilm formation and control in a novel warm water distribution system' (PhD), which was sponsored by Dart Valley Systems Ltd and Plymouth University. The authors would like to thank Mr Colin Richards and Mr Rick Preston for technical assistance.