Lung Fiber Burden in the Nottingham Gas Mask Cohort

Abstract

A cohort of 1,154 employees, mainly women, who had worked 1940–1945 on the manufacture of military gas masks using filter pads containing 20% crocidolite, was traced through 2003, by which time 65 were known to have died from mesothelioma. The last known death with mesothelioma was in 1994, whereas a further 5 cases would have been expected in those with known duration of exposure. Lung tissue samples, from 50 deaths from mesothelioma and 20 other causes, had been analyzed for mineral fiber content. For ten of the mesothelioma cases data on fiber size were collected. Crocidolite fiber concentrations were analyzed in relation to exposure by time and duration. Fiber concentrations overall fell fairly steadily by decade of death, and increased with length of exposure up to 36 months and then fell sharply. The annual rate of elimination estimated by regression was 7.5% corresponding to a half life of 9.2 years. The proportion of fibers longer than 6 μm increased over time implying that the shorter fibers were eliminated more rapidly than the longer ones. The decline in concentrations with time confirms the hypothesis that crocidolite and, by inference, other amphibole fibers are slowly removed from the lung, but since the longer more carcinogenic fibers were cleared more slowly it is unclear to what extent this clearance explains the slowing down of the increase in mesothelioma mortality from about 40 years from the most recent exposure. The exact biostatistical models which most closely conform with the data remain open to question.

We wish to acknowledge the great help given in all phases of this research by Magda Wheatley. Without the original work and records of the late Professor Stephen Jones, it would have been impossible to carry out this study. We also thank the reviewers for their suggestion that we obtain data on fiber length.