1,264
Views
7
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Sensitisation to molecular components in patients with atopic dermatitis, relation to asthma bronchiale and allergic rhinitis

, , , , &
Pages 600-629 | Received 27 Jan 2020, Accepted 19 Mar 2020, Published online: 27 Jul 2020

ABSTRACT

Backround and aim: To evaluate the sensitisation to molecular components in atopic dermatitis patients with the use of Multiplex ISAC testing. Method: The complete dermatological and allergological examination including the examination of the sensitisation to molecular components with Multiplex ISAC testing was performed. Results and conclusion: Eighty one patients were examined – 40 men, 41 women, average age 41.7 years. The positivity was recorded most frequently to molecular components of timothy, birch, house dust mite, animals dander, bermuda grass, peach, apple, hazel pollen, kiwi, peanut and hazelnut, Alternaria and Aspergillus. Molecular components such as Equ c 1 (Horse), Alt a 6 (Alternaria), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat) and Can f 1, Can f 5 (Dog) are recorded with the significant higher occurrence simultaneously in patients suffering from severe form of AD, asthma bronchiale and allergic rhinitis; these molecular components play the most important role in the atopic march.

Introduction

Atopic dermatitis (AD) constitutes together with allergic rhinitis (AR) and asthma, the triad of atopic diseases. The pathogenesis of AD involves interactions among multiple factors, including susceptibility genes, environmental factors (food and inhalant allergens), skin barrier defects, and immunologic factors (Czarnowicki et al., Citation2017; Paller et al., Citation2019). The progression of atopic disorders from AD in infants to AR and asthma in children is used to describe as an atopic march and this concept has been supported by cross-sectional and longitudinal studies as well as the inter-relationships between subsequent allergic manifestations (Czarnowicki et al., Citation2017; Paller et al., Citation2019). Mechanisms for developing atopic comorbidities after AD onset are poorly understood but can involve the impaired cutaneous barrier, which facilitates cutaneous sensitisation. The association can also be driven or amplified in susceptible subjects by a systemic TH2-dominant immune response to cutaneous inflammation (Paller et al., Citation2019).

The initial laboratory approach in the diagnosis of allergies (such as AD, rhinitis, and wheezing disorders) is to detect the type of allergic reaction, i.e. whether the patient’s allergy is mediated by immunoglobulin E (IgE) or not. Various allergens play a role in the elicitation or exacerbation of eczematous skin lesions in AD, and much research effort has been focused on improving diagnostic tests to identify causative allergens. The main allergenic sources are foods, fungi, trees, weeds, grasses, mites, and finally animals; with the largest number of allergenic proteins being found in foods and the smallest in animals (He et al., Citation2014). Currently, allergens could be defined as proteins, glycoproteins, lipoproteins, or protein-conjugated haptens, which have unique molecular and structural properties (He et al., Citation2014).

Progress in laboratory diagnostics of IgE-mediated allergy is the use of component-resolved diagnosis (CRD) or molecular diagnosis of allergies. The CRD approach has been developed when highly purified or recombinant allergen molecules have become available. These molecules are the allergenic proteins towards which the specific and clinically relevant IgE immune response is directed. The introduction of allergen molecules has had a major effect on analytic specificity and allergy diagnosis. They are used in both singleplex ImmunoCAP and multiplex ImmunoCAP ISAC assays. The major advantage of ISAC is the comprehensive IgE pattern obtained with a minute amount of serum (van Hage et al., Citation2017). ImmunoCAP ISAC (Thermo Fisher), based on 112 different molecular components (both extracted and recombinant), is the most studied and most frequently used molecular diagnostic tool based on a microarray (Melioli et al., Citation2011). Determination of sIgE against allergenic components may significantly improve current diagnostics of allergy (Dodig & Čepelak, Citation2018). In our previous studies, we evaluated also the occurrence of sensitisation to food and inhalant allergens in relation to the severity of AD, but the sensitisation was determined according to the extract-specific IgE, atopy patch test, and skin prick tests without using CRD (Čelakovská & Bukač, Citation2017). There is a lack of reports focusing on the course of AD with respect to its evolution and association with sensitisation to foods and to aeroallergens in adolescent and adult patients suffering from AD. Only few reports demonstrate the comorbidity of allergy to food and inhalant allergens and the severity of AD evaluated with SCORAD index (Ott et al., Citation2010; Röckmann et al., Citation2014). The SCORAD index has been developed on consensus by the European Task Force on Atopic Dermatitis (ETFAD) in 1993. The acronym SCORAD was proposed by Arnold Oranje and stands for SCORing Atopic Dermatitis (European Task Force on Atopic Dermatitis, Citation1993). The use of this instrument makes different studies more comparable in routine practice, as well as in observational or double-blind randomised clinical trials.

Aim of the study

The aim of this study is to evaluate the sensitisation to molecular components in AD patients with the use of Multiplex ISAC testing and to evaluate the relation to the severity of AD, occurrence of asthma bronchiale (AB), and AR in this group of patients. Also, we evaluate if there is some relation between the level of specific IgE to molecular components and the severity of AD, the occurrence of AB and AR.

Patients and methods

In the period 2018–2019, 81 patients suffering from AD at the age of 14 years and older were examined. All these patients were examined in the Department of Dermatology, Faculty Hospital Hradec Králové, Charles University, Czech Republic. The diagnosis of AD was made with the Hanifin–Rajka criteria (Hanifin & Rajka, Citation1980). Exclusion criteria were long-term therapy with cyclosporin or systemic corticoids, pregnancy, and breastfeeding. Patients with AD having other systemic diseases were excluded from the study as well. The complete dermatological and allergological examination was performed in patients included in the study. This study was approved by Ethics committee of Faculty Hospital Hradec Králové, Charles University of Prague, Czech Republic.

Examination of specific IgE to molecular components

The serum level of the sIgE was measured by the CRD microarray-based sIgE detection assay ImmunoCAP ISAC (Phadia, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Uppsala, Sweden). ImmunoCAP ISAC is a solid-phase multiple immunoassay which enables to determine 112 different components from 51 allergen sources (Choi et al., Citation2014; Jakob et al., Citation2015). The allergens are applied in triplicates to ensure the test reproducibility. The specific IgE values are presented in arbitrary units called ISAC Standardized Units (measuring range of 0.3–100 ISU-E). The level of specific IgE >0.3 ISU-E was assessed as positive (Jakob et al., Citation2015). The level of molecular components in ISU-E was evaluated: <0.3 – negative, 0.3–0.9 ISU-E low positivity, 0.9–15 ISU-E moderate positivity, and >15 ISU-E very high positivity (Choi et al., Citation2014; Jakob et al., Citation2015).

Severity of atopic dermatitis

The severity of AD was scored in agreement with SCORAD (Scoring of atopic dermatitis) with the assessment of topography items (affected skin area), intensity criteria, and subjective parameters. The severity of AD was evaluated with SCORAD as a mild form to 25 points, as moderate over 25–50 points, as a severe form over 50 points (European Task Force on Atopic Dermatitis, Citation1993). This examination was performed during one year every two months and the average SCORAD index was calculated.

The diagnosis of AB was made according to the results in spirometry at allergological outpatients department.

The evaluation of allergic rhinitis (AR) (seasonal or perennial) was made according to the allergolocical examination.

Statistical analysis

We analysed the data to determine whether there is some difference of sensitisation to examine molecular components in the mild, moderate and severe form of AD, in patients suffering from AB and AR. Also, we evaluated if there is some difference between the severity of AD and the level of specific IgE to molecular components. Allergens were ordered in the decreasing order to find out the one with the highest probability. We continued by testing the difference between the highest underlying probability and the following one and we found out that the null hypothesis of equality of those underlying probabilities was confirmed. It follows that we have to consider a set of allergens with the highest probability. The question of calculating which allergens fall in the set of those with the highest probability is found in the study of the change-point problem. A typical setting of this branch of statistics appears as a time series. The independent variable plotted on the time-axis on which it is represented by equidistant points. This is definitely not our case because we are looking for a change in underlying probabilities of events that are sorted in a decreasing order with respect to the magnitude of their relative frequencies. In our application of finding the change-point, it really does not matter that we do not use the time series model.

We prefer to use an intuitive approach. We consider events with the highest probabilities, denote their probabilities as p(1), p(2),  … , p(k), and ask if we may include one more event with probability p(k + 1). The null hypothesis may be written as H0: p(i) = p, for i = 1,  … , k+1 for some probability p common to all the k + 1 events, whereas the alternative hypothesis is Ha: p(i) = p for i = 1,  … , k but p(k + 1) is not equal to p.

This says that the event with this distinct probability p(k + 1) is not in the set of events with the highest probability. Since the probabilities p(1),  … , p(k) are the same, we can add all the numbers of successes (positive results of tests) and all the numbers of trials in binomial distributions with the same parameter p and, provided the trials are independent, the cumulative sum of the numbers of successes out of the cumulative sum of trials have a binomial distribution with the same parameter p. We compare this probability p with the probability p(k + 1) of the next k + 1th event.

As Worsley would put it, essentially, we are dealing with the association in a 2 × 2 contingency table. Our conclusion is that such an association may be tested by implementing the well-known chi-squared test (Worsley, Citation1983). Essentially, the method of maximum likelihood estimates K by choosing the value of k that gives the strongest association in a 2 × 2 contingency table formed by combining all periods up to and including k and all periods after k, against success and failure (Worsley, Citation1983).

For the evaluation of the relation between the severity of AD and the level of specific IgE, we formed a contingency table with the severity of AD as one classification and level of specific IgE of the molecular component as the other classification (0.3–0.9 ISU-E low positivity, 0.9–15 ISU-E moderate positivity, >15 ISU-E very high positivity). The p-value is on the bottom line.

For the evaluation of the relation between the occurrence of AB (AR) and the level of specific IgE, we formed a contingency table with the occurrence of AB (AR) as one classification and level of specific IgE of the molecular component as the other classification.

We tested if there are significant differences in relative frequencies of molecular components in mild, moderate, and severe forms of AD, in patients suffering from AB and AR. The results are recorded in tables. The heading of each table contains the column sums (enclosed in parentheses), numbers of patients with positive test results are recorded on each separate line next to their molecular component abbreviations. The negative test results would be obtained by subtracting the positive results from the column sum in the headings. This is the way we form a 2 by 3 (in the case of severity of AD) or 2 by 2 (in the case of AB and AR). Such a table could be evaluated by the usual Chi-squared test. The p-value is displayed in the right-hand column. Unfortunately, zeroes appeared in many of the tables and one has to be careful in making conclusions.

Results

Patients

In 81 patients included in the study (40 men and 41 women with the average age 41.7 years and with the average SCORAD 39, s.d.13.1 points), 112 different components from 51 allergen sources were examined. The mild form of AD was recorded in 11 patients (13.6%), moderate form in 45 patients (55.6%), and severe form in 25 patients (30.9%). In the included patients, 46 patients (56.8%) suffer from AB and 65 patients (80.2%) suffer from rhinitis. The positive results in sensitisation to molecular components were recorded in 75 patients (92.6%). The characteristics of patients is shown in .

Table 1. The characteristic of patients with atopic dermatitis.

The number of patients with positive reactions to different types of allergens, number of positive reactions to molecular components, and the level of molecular components in ISU-E (min., max., mean) are recorded in . The order of allergens according to the positivity at least in one of the molecular component in 81 patients is shown in . The positivity to some of the molecular components was recorded to timothy in 60 patients (74.1%), in 48 patients (59.3%) to birch, in 45 patients (64.2%) to house dust mite, in 40 patients (49.4%) to the dog, in 40 patients (49.4%) to the cat, and in 39 patients (48.1%) to peach followed by others allergens.

Table 2. Results of examination in 81 patients. Number of patients with positive reactions to different types of allergens, number of positive reactions to molecular components and the level of molecular components in ISU-E (min., max., mean). The mean of sIgE above 15 ISU-E is marked extra bold.

Table 3. The list of allergens according to positivity to one or more of molecular components in the allergen (81 patients = 100%).

The list of molecular components with the level of specific IgE >15 ISU-E (high positivity) is shown in . The highest level of specific IgE was recorded to these molecular components: Der p 10 (House dust mite), Pla l 1(Plantain), Phl p 1 (Timothy), Can f 1 (Dog), and Fel d 1 (Cat), from food allergens to Pen m 1 (Shrimp), to Mal d 1 (Apple), and Ani s 3 (Anisakis).

Table 4. The list of allergens and molecular components with the level of specific IgE above 15 ISU-E (high positivity).

The number of negative and positive reactions (low, moderate, and high positivity of the level of specific IgE) in a mild, moderate, and severe form of AD is shown in . The significant relationship between the severity of AD and the level of specific IgE to molecular components was confirmed (p-value = .000).

Table 5. The number of negative and positive reactions (low, moderate, and high positivity of the level of specific IgE to molecular component) in mild, moderate and severe form of atopic dermatitis. The significant relation between the severity of AD and the level of specific IgE to molecular components was confirmed (p-value = .000).

The list of positive results to molecular components in all included patients and the list in the mild, moderate, and severe form of AD is shown in . The leading molecular components are Bet v 1 (Birch) in mild and moderate form of AD, and Phl p 1 (Timothy) in severe form of AD followed by other molecular components as shown in . According to the statistical evaluation, the order of molecular components in mild, moderate, and severe form (the underlying probability of the occurrence) is not statistically significant. We compared also the conditional relative frequency of positivity of molecular components in patients suffering from a mild, moderate and severe form of AD. The increasing relative frequency of positive reactions to molecular components from mild to moderate and to severe form was recorded (). The significant relation between the severity of AD and the positivity to these molecular components was confirmed: Bet v 2 (Birch), Alt v 6 (Alternaria), Asp f 6 (Aspergillus), Der f 2 and Der p 2 (House dust mite), Fel d 4 (Cat), Can f 1 (Dog), Equ c 1 (Horse), Ves v 5 (Common wasp venom), Tri a A (Wheat), Gal d 2 (Egg white), Pen m 2 (Shrimp), and Ara h 1 (Peanut).

Table 6. The list of molecular components in all included patients and the list in mild, moderate and severe form of AD (81 patients = 100%). According to the statistical evaluation, the order of molecular components in mild, moderate and severe form (the underlying probability of the occurrence) is not statistically significant.

Table 7. The conditional relative frequency of positivity of molecular components in patients suffering from mild, moderate and severe form of atopic dermatitis.

Regarding the occurrence of AB in our group of patients, we evaluated the level of specific IgE to molecular components (low, moderate, and high positivity of specific IgE), the underlying probability of the positive results to molecular components and the relative frequency of sensitisation to molecular components in patients with AB and without AB. The number of positive reactions to molecular components (low, moderate and high positivity of specific IgE) in patients with and without AB is shown in . The significant difference in the level of specific IgE to molecular components between the patients with and without AB was confirmed (p-value = .000).

Table 8. The number of positive reactions to molecular components (low, moderate and high positivity of specific IgE) in patients with and without AB. The significant difference in the level of specific IgE to molecular components between the patients with and without AB was confirmed (p-value = .000).

We evaluated the order of molecular components in patients suffering from AB and in patients without AB. The first 25 molecular components with the highest underlying probability in patients suffering from AB were found to be different from those not suffering from AB. Molecular components such as Der f 2 (House dust mite), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat), Mal d 1 (Apple), Phl p 2, Phl p 5, (Timothy), Cora 1.0101, Cora 10401 (Hazelnut), Der f 1,Der p 1 (House dust mite), Ara h 8 (Peanut), Aln g 1 (Alder), Gly m 4 (Soy), Pen m 2 (Shrimp), and Alt a 1 (Alternaria) are not recorded among the first 25 molecular components in patients without AB (). The relative frequency of the positive results in molecular components in patients with AB and without AB is shown in . These molecular components were recorded with the significant higher occurrence in AD patients suffering from AB: Ara h 8, Ara h 9 (Peanut), Equ c 1 (Horse), Mus m 1 (Mouse), MUXF 3 (Sugar epitope from Bromelain (CCD)), Pen m 2 (Shrimp), Alt a 1 (Alternaria), Ole e 9 (Oliva pollen), Art v 1 (Mugwort), Can f 3 (Dog), Cora 1.0101, Cora 1.0401 (Hazelnut), Der f 1, Der f 2 (House dust mite), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat), Gly m 4 (Soy), Hev b 5, Hev b 8 (Latex), Mal d 1 (Apple), Phl p 2, Phl p 4, Phl p 5, Phl p 11 (Timothy), Pla l 1 (Plantain), and Act d 2 (Kiwi). The positivity to molecular components such as Der f 2 (House dust mite), Phl p 2 (Timothy), Cora1.0101 (Hazelnut), and Fel d 4 (Cat) is recorded only in patients suffering from AB (). On the other hand, other molecular components were recorded with the significant higher occurrence in AD patients without AB: Ara h 6 (Peanut), Api m 4 (Honey bee venom), Bos d 6 (Cow’s milk), Gal d 5 (Egg yolk), Ole e 1 (Oliva pollen), Tri gliadin (Wheat), Ani s 1 (Anisakis), Bla g 7 (Cockroach), Can f 5 (Dog), Blot 5 (House dust mite), Par j 2 (Wall pelitory), Che a 1 (Gossefoot), and Hev b 6 and Hev b 6 (Latex) ().

Table 9. The order of molecular components with postive results in patients suffering from AB and in patients without AB. The first 25 molecular components with the highest underlying probability in patients suffering from AB were found to be different from those not suffering from AB.

Table 10. The relative frequency of positivity to molecular components in patients with AB (46 patients = 100%) in comparison to patients without AB (35 patients = 100%).

Regarding the occurrence of AR in our group of patients, we evaluated the level of specific IgE to molecular components (low, moderate, and high positivity of specific IgE), the underlying probability of the positive results to molecular components, and the relative frequency of sensitisation to molecular components in patients with and without AR. The number of positive reactions to molecular components (low, moderate, and high positivity of specific IgE) in patients with and without AR is shown in . The significant difference in the level of specific IgE to molecular components between the patients with and without AR and was not confirmed (p-value = .099). The list of positive results to molecular components in patients suffering from AR and in patients without AR was recorded. According to the statistical evaluation, the order of molecular components in these groups of patients is not statistically significant, it means that there is not the statistically important difference in the underlying probability in the order of molecular components in patients suffering from AR and in patients without AR. On the other hand, in patients suffering from AR, we can observe the increasing relative frequency of positive results in all molecular components (). These molecular components were recorded with the significant higher occurrence in AD patients suffering from AR: Pru p 1 (Peach), Cyn d 1 (Bermuda grass), Equ c 1 (Horse), Mus m1 (Mouse),Ole e 9 (Oliva pollen), Alt a 6 (Alternaria), Asp f 6 (Aspergillus), Can f 1 (Dog), Cor a 1.0101 (Hazelnut), Fel d 1 and Fel d 4 (Cat), Mal d 1 (Apple), and Phl p 4, 5, 6 (Timothy).

Table 11. The number of positive reactions to molecular components (low, moderate, and high positivity of specific IgE) in patients with and without AR. The difference between the patients with and without AR and the level of molecular components was not confirmed (p-value = .099).

Table 12. The increasing relative frequency of positive results in molecular components in patients with AR (65 patients = 100%) in comparison to patients without AR (16 patients = 100%).

The summary list of allergens and molecular components with significantly higher occurrence in patients suffering from AB, AR, and severe form of AD is shown in . Molecular components such as Equ c 1 (Horse), Alt a 6 (Alternaria), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat), and Can f 1, Can f 5 (Dog) are recorded with the significant higher occurrence simultaneously in patients suffering from a severe form of AD, AB, and AR.

Table 13. The summary list of allergens and molecular components with significant higher occurrence in patients suffering from AB, AR and severe form of AD.

Discussion

This study evaluates the sensitisation and the level of specific IgE to molecular components with the use of Multipex ISAC testing in the group of 81 AD patients. We evaluated this sensitisation with the underlying probability of the occurrence according to the severity of AD, according to the occurrence of AB, and AR. There are few studies dealing with this question in adolescents and adults suffering from AD according to the database in Medline, Pubmed, and Web of Science. Although we found some studies dealing with the examination of molecular components in AD patients, we did not find any similar one going to the detailed description of the results with CRD examination with the use of the statistical method as used in our study. The most common positivity of molecular components were observed to allergens such as timothy, birch, house dust mite, dog, cat, peach, Bermuda grass, apple, hazel pollen, kiwi, peanut, hazelnut, alternaria, soybean. As Bermuda grass pollen is not present in our region, possible cross-reactivity with β-expansins from other grasses could be the explanation for the results with high sensitisation to Cyn d 1 in our study. In a more detailed examination of the results, we found some significant differences in the positivity to molecular components in patients suffering from a mild, moderate, and severe form of AD and in subgroup of patients suffering from AB and AR. Patients suffering from the severe form of AD differ from patients with moderate and mild form in several characteristics. First, severe AD patients were characterised by the fact that they reacted to a larger panel of environmental allergens than patients with moderate AD and mild AD. Although we observe the difference in the order of molecular components in the different form of AD, there is no statistically important difference in the underlying probability in the mild, moderate, and severe form of AD, and in patients suffering from AR. So far, we cannot decide which allergen has the highest probability in different forms of AD and AR. In patients suffering from a different form of AD (mild, moderate, severe), the set of allergens is large and we believe it makes no sense to discuss the differences due to the severity of AD. An approach like this would require a much larger number of patients. The main reason for this approach was to determine which allergens (molecular components) should be tested first. On the other hand, we show that in some allergens (molecular components), the difference in frequencies depending on the severity of AD was found. The same would hold true in the case of AR. Only in patients suffering from AB, we can see that the first 25 molecular components with the highest underlying probability were found to be different from those not suffering from AB.

After calculation of the relative frequency, we can observe, in the majority of molecular components, the increase in relative frequency from mild to moderate and to severe form of AD and in patients with AR. But the statistically significant difference was confirmed only in some of the molecular components. Regarding the severity of AD, the significant difference was confirmed in molecular components such as Bet v 2 (Birch), Alt v 6 (Alternaria), Asp f 6 (Aspergillus), Der f 2 and Der p 2 (House dust mite), Fel d 4 (Cat), Can f 1 (Dog), Equ c 1 (Horse), Ves v 5 (Common wasp venom), Tri a A (Wheat), Gal d 2 (Egg white), Pen m 2 (Shrimp), and Ara h 1 (Peanut). Regarding the occurrence of AR, we can also observe the increasing relative frequency of positive results in all molecular components in patients with AR. The significant difference was confirmed in molecular components such as Pru p 1 (Peach), Cyn d 1 (Bermuda grass), Equ c 1 (Horse), Mus m1 (Mouse),Ole e 9 (Oliva pollen), Alt a 6 (Alternaria), Asp f 6 (Aspergillus), Can f 1 (Dog), Cor a 1.0101 (Hazelnut), and Fel d 1 and Fel d 4 (Cat). On the other hand, in patients suffering from AB, we calculated the underlying probability and we show the first 25 molecular components with higher underlying probability in these patients. Regarding the subgroup of patients suffering from AB, these molecular components were recorded with significantly higher occurrence: Ara h 6, Ara h 8, Ara h 9 (Peanut), Equ c 1 (Horse), Mus m 1 (Mouse), Pen m 2 (Shrimp), Alt a 1 (Alternaria), Ole e 9 (Oliva pollen), Art v 1 (Mugwort), Can f 3 (Dog), Cora 1.0101, Cora 1.0401 (Hazelnut), Der f 1, Der f 2 (House dust mite), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat), Gly m 4 (Soy), Hev b 8 (Latex), Mal d 1 (Apple), Phl p 2, Phl p 4, Phl p 5, Phl p 11 (Timothy), Pla l 1 (Plantain), and Act d 2 (Kiwi). On the other hand, the other molecular components were recorded with significant higher occurrence in AD patients without AB: Api m 4 (Honey bee venom), Bos d (Cow ´s milk), Gal d 5 (Egg yolk), Ole e 1 (Oliva pollen), Tri gliadin (Wheat), Ani s 1 (Anisakis), Bla g 7 (Cockroach), Can f 5 (Dog), Blot 5 (House dust mite), Par j 2 (Wall pelitory), Che a 1 (Gossefoot), Hev b 6, and Hev b 5 (Latex). Interestingly, molecular components such as Der f 2 (House dust mite), Phl p 2 (Timothy), Cora1.0101 (Hazelnut), and Fel d 4 (Cat) are positive only in patients suffering from AB. Thus, these components might be useful serological marker allergens for the identification of a subgroup of AD patients suffering from AB.

In the similar study, Wojciechowska et al. used the ImmunoCAP ISAC test to analyse allergic phenotypes in adult patients with AD. They included 19 adult patients with AD and the severity of AD was assessed using the SCORAD index. Positive results of the ISAC test were documented in 84.2% of the study subjects. All patients synthesised sIgE against species-specific respiratory allergens; major components of animal allergens (57.8%), tree pollen allergens (47.3%), grass pollen allergens (42.1%), dust mite allergens (26.3%), and major allergen of mugwort (26.3%). In their study, no statistically significant relationships were observed between the severity or duration of AD and the prevalence and levels of slgE against the allergens included in the ISAC panel (Wojciechowska et al., Citation2018 Aug). Choi et al. evaluated the serum samples of 25 AD patients by using ISAC and a multiple allergen simultaneous test-enzyme immunoassay (MAST-EIA). ISAC results in AD correlated well with the SPT results, and compared favourably to the MAST-EIA results (Choi et al., Citation2014). According to Mothes, the novel concept “from molecules to clinic” offers a reliable diagnostic workup in shorter time. It is especially applicable for young children and seniors, in atopic patients, and whenever skin tests get difficult or unreliable (Mothes-Luksch et al., Citation2018). Patients reporting hazelnut allergy (n = 423) from 12 European cities were tested for IgE against individual hazelnut allergens; a model combining CRD with a clinical background and extract-based serology was superior to CRD alone in assessing the risk of severe reactions to hazelnut, particularly in ruling out severe reactions (Datema et al., Citation2018). In the research project MeDALL, IgE reactivities towards a large number of micro-arrayed allergen molecules have been determined in several European birth cohorts using the MeDALL allergen chip (Lupinek et al., Citation2014). Data obtained in the MeDALL project seem to confirm that patients with AD are often polysensitised towards a large number of different allergen molecules and thus exhibit extremely complex IgE sensitisation profiles (Anto et al., Citation2017; Asarnoj et al., Citation2016; Asarnoj et al., Citation2017; Bousquet et al., Citation2015; Lupinek et al., Citation2014; Posa et al., Citation2017; Westman et al., Citation2015). Multiallergen tests, mainly chip tests based on micro-arrayed allergen molecules utilizing the ImmunoCAP-ISAC technology, have been used for the analysis of IgE reactivity profiles in cohorts of children with AD and adult patients with AD (Banerjee et al., Citation2015; Fedenko et al., Citation2016 Foong et al., Citation2016; Gray et al., Citation2016; Mittermann et al., Citation2016). Banerjee et al. studied the importance of the high-molecular-weight group 11 allergen from Dermatophagoides pteronyssinus (Der p 11) in house dust mite (HDM) allergy. Interestingly, they found that Der p 11 is a major allergen for patients suffering from AD, whereas it is only a minor allergen for patients suffering from respiratory forms of HDM allergy. Thus, rDer p 11 might be a useful serological marker allergen for the identification of a subgroup of HDM-allergic patients suffering from HDM-associated AD (Banerjee et al., Citation2015). In ISAC testing, the molecular component Der p 11 is not present, so we cannot compare it with our results. According to our results, the main molecular component from HDM is Der f 2 in patients suffering from moderate and severe form of AD and in patients suffering from AB.

Mitterman et al. characterised in their study the specificities of IgE reactivity in patients with AD to a broad panel of exogenous allergens including microbial and human antigens. In their study, adult patients with AD were grouped according to the SCORAD index, into severe (n = 53) and moderate AD (n = 126). IgE reactivity was detected in 92% of patients with severe and 83% of patients with moderate AD. Sensitisation to cat allergens occurred most frequently, followed by sensitisation to birch pollen, grass pollen, and to the skin commensal yeast M. sympodialis. Patients with severe AD showed a significantly higher frequency of IgE reactivity to allergens like cat (Fel d 1) and house dust mite (Der p 4 and 10), there were no significant differences in the frequencies of IgE reactivity to the grass pollen allergens Phl p 1, 2, 5 and 6 between the two AD groups and the IgE reactivity profile of patients with severe AD was more spread towards several different allergen molecules when compared with patients with moderate AD. The conclusion of their study is that they revealed a hitherto unknown difference regarding the molecular sensitisation profile in patients with severe and moderate AD. Molecular profiling towards allergen components may provide a basis for future investigations aiming to explore the environmental, genetic and epigenetic factors which could be responsible for the different appearance and severity of disease phenotypes in AD (Mittermann et al., Citation2016). According to the Mitterman’s study, it would suggest that grass pollen allergens are less important as trigger factors for AD compared to birch pollen and indoor allergens in their studied population. On the other hand, in our study, we confirmed that the molecular component Phl p1 is the leading allergen in patients suffering from moderate and severe form of AD. The difference between birch pollen and grass pollen is unexpected because grass pollen contains several very potent allergens whereas birch contains only one major allergen (Bet v 1). Furthermore, the grass pollen season lasts longer than the birch pollen season and allergen loads are typically higher for grass pollen (Asarnoj et al., Citation2017; Schappi et al., Citation1997). Since the route of exposure should be the same for both pollens, it is quite conceivable that other factors play a role such as climatic effects where low humidity and cold temperatures negatively affect skin barrier functions and increase the risk of dermatitis (Engebretsen et al., Citation2016 Schappi et al., Citation1997, Citation1999). According to other studies, the analysis of complex IgE-reactivity profiles by a molecular diagnosis can improve disease management following the principle of precision and personalised medicine approaches in allergy (Ferrando et al., Citation2017; McGhee, Citation2011; Riccio et al., Citation2016). Flohr performed the first systematic review analysing the evidence on the diagnostic accuracy of CRD for a range of food allergies. This systematic review included 11 studies that assessed the accuracy of CRD in diagnosing cow's milk, hen's egg, peanut, hazelnut, and shrimp allergies. According to Flor, the last findings suggest that some CRD components have the potential to diagnose cow's milk, hen's egg, peanut, hazelnut, and shrimp allergies with high specificity, but low sensitivity. Nevertheless, at present, there is not enough methodologically robust evidence to draw definite conclusions. Further studies employing double-blind, placebo-controlled food challenge test as the reference standard are urgently needed to effectively evaluate the effectiveness of CRD, as well as standardisation of the components assessed and CRD assays used, and consensus on study reporting (Flores et al., Citation2018 Aug). Röckmann et al. (Citation2014) investigated the pattern of food sensitisation in 211 adults with AD in relation to AD severity using multiplexed allergen microarray. Specific IgE levels were routinely measured using a microarray immunoassay (Immuno Solid-phase allergen Chip (ImmunoCAP ISAC®, VBC Genomics and Phadia)) with 103 allergens. Sensitisation to PR-10 related food allergens occurred most frequently (63.5%) and was independent from AD severity. Of all plant food allergens, only sensitisation to nAra h 1 was significantly more frequent in patients with severe AD. In the total group, 75 (35.5%) patients with AD showed sensitisation to any animal food allergen. The percentage was significantly higher in patients with severe AD (51.4%) compared to patients with mild/moderate AD (27.7%) (Röckmann et al., Citation2014). According to our results, the sensitisation to Bet v 2 (Birch), Alt v 6 (Alternaria), Asp f 6 (Aspergillus), Der f 2 and Der p 2 (House dust mite), Fel d 4 (Cat), Can f 1 (Dog), Equ c 1 (Horse), Ves v 5 (Common wasp venom), Tri a A (Wheat), Gal d 2 (Egg white), Pen m 2 (Shrimp), and Ara h 1 (Peanut) was significantly higher in patients with moderate and severe AD. In our study, the positivity to PR10 protein allergens (Gly m 4 – soy, Cora 10101 – hazelnut, Pru p 1 – peach, Ara h 8 – peanut, Mal d 1 – apple) is higher in severe form in comparison to moderate and mild form AD, but the difference is not significant. On the other hand, the relative frequency Bet v 1 is higher in the mild form in comparison to the moderate and severe form, but the difference is not significant as well. Unfortunately, zeroes appeared in many of the tables and one has to be careful in making definite conclusions. Regarding the level of specific IgE (low, moderate, high positivity) to molecular components in mild, moderate, and severe form of AD, the difference is statistically significant. The moderate positivity and high positivity of specific IgE to molecular components were recorded significantly more often in patients suffering from moderate and severe form of AD and in subgroup of patients suffering from AB.

In our previous studies, we evaluated the occurrence of sensitisation to food and inhalant allergens according to the severity of AD. Two hundred and eighty-three patients were examined, the significant relation was recorded between the severity of AD and sensitisation to tested inhalant allergens. The significant relation was also found between the severity of AD and IgE-mediated food allergy. It turns out that the higher time to reaction, the higher the severity of AD (Čelakovská & Bukač, Citation2011, Citation2016, Citation2017; Čelakovská et al. Citation2015a). Also, we evaluated the relation between the severity of AD and the occurrence of AB and rhinitis. A significant relationship was confirmed between the occurrence of AB, the occurrence of AR, the duration of the skin lesions, and the severity of AD evaluated with the SCORAD index. The occurrence of bronchial asthma, AR, and persistent eczematous lesions was significantly higher in moderate and severe forms of AD evaluated by using the SCORAD index (Čelakovská & Bukač, Citation2017; Čelakovská et al., Citation2017). According to our results in another study, AD patients with sensitisation to mites and animal dander suffer significantly more often from AB, rhinitis, persistent eczematic lesions and have positive data about atopy in their family history. Patients with the sensitisation to bird feather have the onset of AD more often >5 years of age. Sensitisation to dust is in significant relationship with the occurrence of rhinitis, but not with the occurrence of AB (Čelakovská et al. Citation2015b).

Negaoui et al. tried to investigate the allergenic properties of bovine lactoferrin (bLf) at different doses. The lactoferrin (LF) allergenicity was explored using the murine model of allergy through measuring anti-LF IgG, IgG1 and IgE antibodies (Abs) responses and by in vivo anaphylactic reactions in LF-sensitised mice. Concerning the in vivo reactions, all groups developed clinical symptoms of anaphylactic reactions at different stages. Their findings show that LF-sensitised mice at 5% and 10% developed important clinical symptoms after intraperitoneal challenge with LF (Negaoui et al., Citation2016).

Little is known about pollen-food allergy syndrome (PFS) in China. Ma Shikun et al. investigated the clinical characteristics, as well as sensitisation patterns, of PFS in China. Clinical parameters and serum IgE responses to prevalent pollens, plant foods, and corresponding allergen components were evaluated. The top three most common pollen-associated allergenic foods were peach, apple, and pear. Peach was the most common allergenic food in PFS patients. Patients with PFS in China showed an LTP-dominant sensitisation profile and usually presented systemic reactions upon consumption of the allergenic foods (Ma et al., Citation2018).

Wheat is one of the major cereals consumed throughout the world; there has been a radical increase in the population suffering from many wheat-related disorders. The Kumar’s study was conducted to screen low immunogenic hexaploid and tetraploid wheat varieties. A total of 34 different wheat varieties were tested for its total protein content, gliadin content, and immunoreactivity with immunoglobulins of celiac (IgA) and wheat allergy patients (IgE). The immunoblot assays for IgE reactivity have revealed that gliadin subunits present in all varieties are found to be allergic proteins. The principal component analysis biplot showed that tetraploid wheat varieties are less immunoreactive than hexaploids. The low immunogenic wheat varieties are suitable for plant breeding and preparation of low gluten or hypo-immunogenic products (Kumar et al., Citation2017). Food allergies, including kiwi fruit allergy, have been the subject of extensive research in the last few years. The aim of Gavrovic-Jankulovic’s study was to examine a possible relationship between the developmental stage of kiwi fruit and its allergenic potency. The protein and allergen patterns of kiwi fruit extracts in September, October, November, and December fruit in the period from 2000 to 2002 were analysed. One of the factors that may contribute to the difficulties in proposing well-defined and standardised fruit extracts should also be the time of fruit harvesting. In this particular case, when the kiwi fruit was edible throughout November and December, they showed discrepancies in allergen content and potencies both in qualitative and quantitative terms. Two major allergens of kiwi fruit, Act c 1 and Act c 2, mainly accounted for the highest allergenic potential of November kiwi extract in vivo and in vitro. Not only the content of major allergens but also the ratio of different proteins and even isoforms of the same allergen (Act c 2) changes with fruit ripening. These findings should be taken into account during the preparation of extracts for allergy diagnosis (Gavrovic-Jankulovic et al., Citation2005).

The prevalence of fish allergies has become a serious health problem and has increased alarmingly over the past few years. Liu’s study attempted to identify and purify the major allergen implicated in the allergic response to largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides), a freshwater fish widely consumed in China. According to their results, nucleoside diphosphate kinase B was identified as a novel fish allergen in largemouth bass. This finding is important for allergy diagnoses and the treatment of freshwater fish–allergic disorders (Liu et al., Citation2014). More recently, other proteins such as arginine kinases, myosin light chains, troponins, and sarcoplasmic calcium-binding proteins have been regarded as relevant allergens in fish, crustaceans, and molluscs. Fernandes’ review focuses on seafood allergens, reporting an updated and compiled list of allergens from fish, crustaceans, and mollusc species, with an overview on the most representative analytical methods for their detection (Fernandes et al., Citation2015). Wan’s study determined whether food allergen sensitivity is a marker for increased asthma incidence in primary school children in Taiwan. Food allergen sensitivity was evaluated in 6- to 8-year-old primary school students (n=1010) using the Phadia ImmunoCAP, Phadiatop Infant, and radioallergosorbent tests. The most prevalent food allergies were scallop, abalone, lobster, pork, casein, alpha-lactalbumin, and garlic. According to their results, food allergen hypersensitivity may be an important marker of inhaled allergen-induced respiratory allergy in later childhood (Wan & Chiu, Citation2012).

The quality of an applied protein extract is important in both serological and in vivo diagnosis of allergy, and for allergen detection methods. In Dooper’s study, the effects of the extraction procedure and hazelnut source on antibody binding to hazelnut (Corylus avellana) proteins were investigated. This study indicates that for the production of hazelnut protein extracts, the use of fresh hazelnuts is important. A quick, vigorous extraction in a tris buffer might contribute positively, at least for extraction of Cor a 9 (Dooper et al., Citation2008).

Mechanisms for developing atopic comorbidities after AD onset are poorly understood but can involve the impaired cutaneous barrier, which facilitates cutaneous sensitisation. The association can also be driven or amplified in susceptible subjects by a systemic TH2-dominant immune response to cutaneous inflammation (Paller et al., Citation2019). However, these associations might merely involve shared genetic loci and environmental triggers, including microbiome dysregulation, with the temporal sequence reflecting tissue-specific peak time of occurrence of each disease, suggesting more of a clustering of disorders than a march. Prospective longitudinal cohort studies provide an opportunity to explore the relationships between postdermatitis development of atopic disorders and potential predictive phenotypic, genotypic, and environmental factors. Early intervention studies to repair the epidermal barrier or alter exposure to the microbiome or allergens might elucidate the relative roles of barrier defects, genetic locus alterations, and environmental exposures in the risk and sequence of occurrence of TH2 activation disorders (Paller et al., Citation2019).

The purpose of our study was to evaluate the sensitisation to molecular components in AD patients and to find some molecular components, which may play the important role in a severe form of AD and in a subgroup of patients suffering from AB and AR. Molecular components such as Equ c 1 (Horse), Alt a 6 (Alternaria), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat), and Can f 1, Can f 5 (Dog) are recorded with the significant higher occurrence simultaneously in patients suffering from a severe form of AD, AB and AR. It seems that these molecular components play the most important role in the atopic march.

Conclusion

In patients suffering from AD, the positivity was recorded most frequently to molecular components of timothy, birch, house dust mite, animals dander, peach, apple, hazel pollen, kiwi, peanut and hazelnut, Alternaria, and Aspergillus. The highest level of specific IgE was recorded to molecular components of House dust mite, Timothy, Dog, Cat, Shrimp, Apple, and Anisakis. The moderate and high positivity of specific IgE to molecular components were recorded significantly more often in patients suffering from a moderate and severe form of AD and in the subgroup of patients suffering from AB, not in patients suffering from AR. Molecular components such as Equ c 1 (Horse), Alt a 6 (Alternaria), Fel d 1, Fel d 4 (Cat), and Can f 1, Can f 5 (Dog) are recorded with the significant higher occurrence simultaneously in patients suffering from a severe form of AD, AB, and AR. It seems that these molecular components play the most important role in the atopic march.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

References