Exploring impacts of multi-year, community-based care programs for orphans and vulnerable children: A case study from Kenya

Abstract

The Community-Based Care for Orphans and Vulnerable Children (CBCO) program operated in Kenya during 2006–2010. In Eastern Province, the program provided support to approximately 3000 orphans and vulnerable children (OVC) living in 1500 households. A primary focus of the program was to support savings and loan associations composed of OVC caregivers (typically elderly women) to improve household and OVC welfare. Cross-sectional data were collected in 2011 from 1500 randomly selected households from 3 populations: program participants (CBCO group, n=500), households in the same villages as program participants but not in the program (the local-community-group = Group L, n=300), and households living in nearby villages where the program did not operate (the adjacent-community-group, Group A, n=700). Primary welfare outcomes evaluated are household food security, as measured by the Household Food Insecurity Access instrument, and OVC educational attainment. We compared outcomes between the CBCO and the subset of Group L not meeting program eligibility criteria (L-N) to investigate disparities within local communities. We compared outcomes between the CBCO group and the subset of Group A meeting eligibility criteria (A-E) to consider program impact. We compared outcomes between households not eligible for the program in the local and adjacent community groups (L-N and A-N) to consider if the adjacent communities are similar to the local communities. In May–June 2011, at the end of the OVC program, the majority of CBCO households continued to be severely food insecure, with rates similar to other households living in nearby communities. Participation rates in primary school are high, reflecting free primary education. Among the 18–22 year olds who were “children” during the program years, relatively few children completed secondary school across all study groups. Although the CBCO program likely provided useful services and benefits to program participants, disparities continued to exist in food security and educational outcomes between program participants and their non-OVC peers in the local community. Outcomes for CBCO households were similar to those observed for OVC households in adjacent communities.

Keywords:

• orphans and vulnerable children
• village savings and loan associations
• food security
• educational attainment

Acknowledgements

While the authors are solely responsible for the analysis and results reported in this paper, they would like to thank the staff of Christian Aid and BIDII for their many levels of support during the completion of this study. This analysis could not have been completed without the support and advice of Claire Milligan, Jane Machira, Margaret Muthui, Ezekiel Ndondou, and the many SLA facilitators and mentors participating in the CBCO program. The study team also thanks USAID/Kenya and the local administration in the study locations for their advice, assistance, and general support during the implementation of the survey. In addition, we would like to thank Jon Simon, Andrea Halverson, Janet Shriberg, Jason Wolfe, and members of the PEPFAR Interagency OVC Technical Working Group for substantive comments, support, and advice during the completion of this study. This article was prepared to contribute to the Evaluation of the Community Response to HIV and AIDS led by the World Bank.