Direct Comparison of Biological Effectiveness of Protons and Alpha-particles of the Same LET. III. Initial Yield of DNA Double-strand Breaks in V79 Cells

Abstract

The results reported form part of a series of experiments to substantiate and extend the findings by Belli et al. (1989) that protons are more biologically effective at cell killing than α-particles of the same LET. The irradiations were carried out using the Variable Energy Cyclotron (VEC) at the Harwell Laboratories. V79-4 Chinese hamster cells were exposed to α-particles and protons with LETs of 20 and 23 keV µ⁻¹ in the dose range 40–150 Gy. X-rays were also used for comparison. Two methods were used for measurement of initial DNA double-strand breaks: sedimentation and DNA precipitation assays. The dose-response relationships were found to be well fitted by straight lines in all cases. With the sedimentation assay a slightly lower yield of dsb was found from protons than from α-particles of the same LET. The yield from X-rays was not significantly different from either. The precipitation assay showed similar yields of DNA damage from both particle types but significantly higher yields from X-rays. This may reflect a difference in the type of lesions scored by the two methods. Since the initial amount of dsb does not account for the observed differences in cellular response to radiations of different qualities, it is likely that these are related to the nature of the dsb (affecting reparability) or to the occurrence of other types of molecular damage.