448
Views
4
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

Fundamental but not eternal: The public–private distinction, from normative projects to cognitive grid in Western political thought

Pages 211-223 | Published online: 30 Apr 2013
 

Abstract

Although the public–private distinction is a historical construction it has been deeply internalized and taken for granted in Western ways of thinking about society and politics. Therefore, we often apply it uncritically as a way to categorizing and coding non-Western societies. Doing so unreflectively may distort our observations as well as policies of state- and peacebuilding. I outline the history of the public–private distinction by emphasizing its role in state-formation processes. This distinction was essential to the formation of the state and society as distinct categories. Indeed, it was and is a pre-condition of the autonomy of the state.

Notes

 1. CitationWeintraub and Kumar ‘Preface’, xii; CitationWeintraub ‘Theory and Politics’, 2.

 2. CitationWeintraub and Kumar ‘Preface’, xii.

 3. CitationElias, Was Ist Soziologie?

 4. CitationLuhmann, Social Systems.

 5. CitationÅkerstrøm Andersen, Discursive Analytical Strategies, 63–92.

 6. Luhmann argues that the state is the self-description of the political system. Since the public–private distinction is central to the creation of the state, this code must be a pre-condition of the political system.

 7. CitationArendt, The Human Condition, 27; CitationWeintraub, ‘Theory and Politics’, 10–12, 35.

 8. CitationWeintraub, ‘Theory and Politics’, 13.

 9. CitationStolleis, Geschichte des öffentlichen Rechts in Deutschland, 86.

10. CitationBrunner, Land und Herrschaft, 4; CitationNetterstrøm and Poulsen, Feud.

11. CitationJanssen, ‘Krieg’, 574.

12. CitationHallberg and Wittrock, ‘From koinonìa politiké’, 37.

13. CitationWeintraub, ‘Theory and Politics’ 13–14. For an overview, see CitationRainer, Das Römische Recht.

14. CitationStolleis, Geschichte des öffentlichen Rechts, 67, 70, 394–395.

15. CitationStolleis, Geschichte des öffentlichen Rechts, 71.

16. CitationGierke, Community in Historical Perspective, 114–115.

17. In CitationCutler, ‘Artifice, ideology and paradox’, 272.

18. In CitationCutler, ‘Artifice, ideology and paradox’, 263.

19. CitationHorwitz, ‘Public/Private Distinction’, 1424.

20. CitationHallberg and Wittrock, ‘From koinonìa politiké’, 30, 45.

21. CitationHabermas, Structural Transformation.

22. CitationFoucault, ‘Governmentality’.

23. CitationGiddens, The Consequences of Modernity, 36–45.

24. CitationHabermas, Structural Transformation.

25. Since the 1980s the public/private distinction has been eroded in many areas of legal doctrine. See CitationStone, ‘Corporate Vices’.

26. CitationFlinders, ‘Public/Private’, 230.

27. CitationEsping-Andersen, The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism.

28. See, for example, CitationBelloni, State Building; CitationPaffenholz, Civil Society & Peacebuilding.

29. CitationKuper, ‘Lineage Theory’, 86.

30. CitationSchatz, Modern Clan Politics; CitationKilcullen, The Accidental Guerrilla.

31. CitationEgnell and Haldén, ‘Laudable, ahistorical and overambitious’, 43–44.

32. CitationMarch and Olsen, Rediscovering Institutions, 23.

33. CitationAustin and Urmson, How to Do Things with Words.

34. CitationThomas and Lauderdale, ‘State Authority and National Welfare Programs’.

35. Nietzsche, quoted in CitationStrong, The Self and Political Order, 168.

36. CitationThomas and Lauderdale, ‘State Authority and National Welfare Programs’.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.