Using system archetypes to identify safety behaviours within the Malaysian construction industry

Abstract

The construction industry, particularly in Asia, experiences disproportionately high numbers of occupational injuries and fatalities. Malaysian construction fatality rates are more than double those in developed nations. Systems thinking has previously been used to identify ‘archetypal’ causal structures underpinning safety-related construction behaviours via a Grounded Theory analysis of interview data from construction safety professionals in New Zealand. This paper partially replicates the method of this prior work within a different cultural context in order to further validate the method and evaluate the extent to which the previously identified structures are indeed archetypal. Seven interviews were conducted with Malaysian construction industry professionals. Three potential archetypal structures were identified concerning: (1) effects of a migrant workforce, (2) corporate accountability and profit driven business culture, and (3) issues in the regulatory system. The structure of behavioural systems in Malaysian construction is depicted providing a view into the failings of construction safety management systems and the interventions to address them. Contractors’ drive for profit was determined as a primary contributing factor in most causal relationships identified. The method is shown to be useful and evidence produced to suggest at least one of the previously proposed causal structures is archetypal.

Keywords:

• Construction safety
• systems thinking
• archetypes
• Malaysian construction
• systems dynamics

Correction Statement

This article has been republished with minor changes. These changes do not impact the academic content of the article.

Acknowledgements

The authors wish to thank all the interviewees who gave their valuable time and expertise to participate in the research process.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Luke Farrand

Luke Farrand is studying for a Masters Degree in Civil Engineering at the University of Bristol.

Neil James Carhart

Neil James Carhart is a Lecturer in Infrastructure Systems within the Department of Civil Engineering, University of Bristol. His research, as part of the UK Collaboratorium for Research in Infrastructure and Cities (UKCRIC) includes the investigation of infrastructure interdependencies and systems approaches to emergent failures.