Notes
‘Dr. A. Smith … has asserted the necessity of a limitation of paper … but he has done this in terms which are inaccurate, and he has given an erroneous and inadequate idea of the evil which may result from a very extended emission’ (Thornton Citation1802: 245; Murphy Citation2003: 443).
Thornton's decision not to accuse Smith of adhering to the real bills doctrine is consistent with recent studies by Perlman (Citation1989) and Gherity (Citation1994), both of whom absolve Smith of any attachment to the doctrine promulgated by the anti-bullionists.
And apparently to David Laidler as well; see Murphy Citation2003: 452, n. 12.
I have argued (in Skaggs Citation1995, Citation2003) that Thornton should be viewed as the father of the Banking School.
It hardly needs to be said that Thornton's sense of justice was highly developed compared to most of his contemporaries.
Thornton
H
1802
An Enquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Paper Credit of Great Britain
London: Hatchard, Edited with an introduction by F.A. Hayek, 1939. London: Allen and Unwin. Reprinted Fairfield, NJ, USA: A. M. Kelley, 1978
Murphy
,
A
.
2003
.
Paper credit and the multi-personae Mr. Henry Thornton
.
European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
,
10
:
429
–
53
.
Perlman
,
M
.
1989
.
Adam Smith and the paternity of the real bills doctrine
.
History of Political Economy
,
21
:
77
–
90
.
Gherity
,
JA
.
1994
.
The evolution of Adam Smith's Theory of Banking
.
History of Political Economy
,
26
:
423
–
41
.
Murphy
,
A
.
2003
.
Paper credit and the multi-personae Mr. Henry Thornton
.
European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
,
10
:
429
–
53
.
Skaggs
,
NT
.
1995
.
Henry Thornton and the development of classical monetary economics
.
Canadian Journal of Economics
,
28
:
1212
–
27
.
Skaggs
,
NT
.
2003
.
Thomas Tooke, Henry Thornton, and the development of British monetary orthodoxy
.
Journal of the History of Economic Thought
,
25
:
177
–
97
.