Supports and Gatekeeping: Experiences of Schools of Social Work With Students With Mental Health Conditions

ABSTRACT

Some social work educators advocate for people with mental health conditions to become social workers because they may possess experiential knowledge and insights that equip them to help others achieve recovery goals. Educators also are tasked with gatekeeping, ensuring that students demonstrate social work competencies. Minimal research exists about how schools handle these dual responsibilities. Using an online survey of deans and directors and BSW and MSW coordinators of programs accredited by the Council on Social Work Education, this mixed-methods study asked about program administrators’ (a) experiences with students with mental health conditions and (b) existing and needed policies and practices related to these students. According to findings, a large majority described problems experienced by students with mental health conditions; schools managed mental health-related issues in a variety of ways; most said these students have graduated using supports; about half indicated students had been terminated because of mental health-related issues; disruptive behaviors, absences, and boundary issues were key challenges; and some programs’ practices might violate federal statutes. Student counseling, legal advice, and relationships with disability resource centers were desired resources. Implications include considerations for policies that are consistent with social work’s social justice mandate, federal laws, and our gatekeeping responsibilities.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Lynn C. Holley

Lynn C. Holley, PhD, ACSW, is an associate professor at Arizona State University. Jennifer L. K. Charles, PhD, is an assistant professor at The Catholic University of America. David C. Kondrat, MSW, PhD, is an associate professor at Indiana University, Purdue University, Indianapolis. Heather A. Walter-McCabe, JD, MSW, is an associate professor at Indiana University School of Social Work, Indianapolis, and an associate professor at Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law.