Passivation of bimetallic catalysts used in water treatment: Prevention and reactivation

Abstract

With respect to degradation rates and the range in contaminants treated, bimetals such as Ni-Fe or Pd-Fe generally outperform unamended granular iron. However, the catalytic enhancement is generally short-lived, lasting from a few days to months. To take advantage of the significant benefits of bimetals, this study aims at developing an effective method for the rejuvenation of passivated bimetals and alternatively, the prevention of rapid reactivity loss of bimetals. Because the most likely cause of Ni-Fe and Pd-Fe passivation is the deposition of iron oxide films over the catalyst sites, it is hypothesized that removal of the iron oxide films will restore the lost reactivity or avoiding the deposition of iron oxide films will prevent passivation. Two organic ligands (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), and [s,s]-ethylenediaminedisuccinate acid ([s,s]-EDDS)) and two acids (citric acid and sulphuric acid) were tested as possible chemical reagents for both passivation rejuvenation and prevention. Trichloroethene (TCE) and Ni-Fe were chosen as probes for chlorinated solvents and bimetals respectively. The test was carried out using small glass columns packed with Ni-Fe. TCE solution containing a single reagent at various concentrations was pumped through the Ni-Fe columns with a residence time in the Ni-Fe of about 6.6 min. TCE concentrations in the influent and effluent were measured to evaluate the performance of each chemical reagent. The results show that (i) for passivated Ni-Fe, flushing with a low concentration of acid or ligand solution without mechanical mixing can fully restore the lost reactivity; and (ii) for passivation prevention, adding a small amount of a ligand or an acid to the feed solution can successfully prevent or at least substantially reduce Ni-Fe passivation. All four chemicals tested are effective in both rejuvenation and prevention, but sulphuric acid and citric acid are considered to be the most practical reagents due to their relatively low costs and environmentally friendly nature. This study suggests that the use of bimetals in above-groundwater treatment applications could become practical with appropriate engineering design.

Keywords:

• Bimetallic catalysts
• nickel-iron
• passivation
• reactivation
• prevention
• ligand
• EDDS
• citric acid
• sulphuric acid

Acknowledgments

Funding for this research was provided through the NSERC/DuPont/EnviroMetal Industrial Research Chair held by R.W. Gillham. We thank Dr. Reardon and Dr. Odziemkowski for the numerous helpful discussions during the experimental stage of the study. Special thanks are also due Wayne Noble and Greg Friday for the technical assistance in the laboratory.