Taxonomic value of seed characters in the Erica tetralix L. group (Ericaceae)

A study of the seed morphology of Erica tetralix and the related species E. mackaiana and E. andevalensis was performed to evaluate the taxonomic importance of seed characters. Size and shape of seeds and surface cells were studied, and area, perimeter, main axis lengths, elongation and sinuosity were measured. Levels of intraspecific variation were considered by means of nested analysis of variance. The study of the intraspecific variation of the characters shows significant differences for lower levels, higher than variations between species for most characters. Levels of variation must be based upon the numerical analysis of seed characters for a correct approach to determining systematic value. E. mackaiana and E. andevalensis group together versus E. tetralix for sinuosity of testa cells. This is a good taxonomic character because it shows significant differences between species and no significant differences between populations. E. tetralix has strongly undulated testa cells while E. mackaiana and E. andevalensis have slightly undulated or curved testa cells. These two species can be discriminated by size of the seed, with seeds of 0.37-0.38 mm for E. andevalensis and 0.4 - 0.45 mm for E. mackaiana. Similarities are found in seed morphology for E. mackaiana and E. andevalensis, but we nevertheless consider the species status for the three taxa as the most natural taxonomic assignment. A key to the species is provided.

Keywords:

• Ericaceae
• seed morphology
• Erica tetralix
• Erica mackaiana
• Erica andevalensis
• taxonomy
• numerical analysis