Tree fine root Ca/Al molar ratio – Indicator of Al and acidity stress

Abstract

High soil acidity and elevated soil Al concentrations limit plant growth in many terrestrial ecosystems. Aluminium toxicity can be ameliorated by Ca. Thus, Ca/Al molar ratios in soil solution and in plant tissues have been proposed as superior indicators than Al concentration itself for evaluating the Al toxicity stress to trees (Cronan & Grigal, J Environ Qual 1995;24:209 – 226). This article presents an overview of publications since 1995 where the reduced Ca/Al ratio in fine tree roots has been used as an indicator of stress for Al and/or soil acidity. The main aim of this review was to evaluate the use and the critical threshold of the fine root Ca/Al ratio as a potential indicator for Al toxicity stress to trees in acid soils. Based on the reviewed literature, the fine root Ca/Al molar ratio was strongly negatively related to Al stress in small tree seedlings in controlled environments, whereas the response was not clear under field conditions where other environmental factors interact. Fine root Ca/Al ranged from 0.03 to 17 in tree seedlings and from 0.1 to 18 in mature trees depending on experimental and site conditions, as well as the tolerance and uptake mechanisms of the different tree species. Fine root Ca/Al was positively related to the soil solution Ca/Al molar ratio. Fine root Ca/Al ratios were related positively to fine root length, growth, specific root length, and biomass, and negatively to root diameter, callose formation, respiration chain activity, starch concentration, and root necromass. A number of relationships have been also found between the fine root Ca/Al and above-ground seedling and/or mature tree growth and nutrient uptake. The critical thresholds for the Ca/Al fine root ratio of 0.2 suggested by Cronan and Grigal (1995) is estimated to represent 90% risk of inverse impact on root and above-ground tree growth. Values of Ca/Al molar ratio in the fine roots of mature trees were only rarely determined below the critical 0.2. The caveats for the use and the interpretation of Ca/Al ratio in fine roots have been addressed in detail. A protocol for root processing and elemental analysis to obtain reliable and comparable results of Ca and Al concentrations in roots is also provided. The article concludes with recommendations for a wider use of the Ca/Al ratio in roots as a bioindicator of Al toxicity to trees in acid soils.

Key words:

• Aluminium
• Ca/Al molar ratio
• environmental indicator
• fine roots
• soil acidity
• tree health

Acknowledgements

Financial support for this study by COST E38 “Woody root processes under changing environment”, the Norwegian Forest and Landscape Institute and Forestry Commission, UK, are gratefully acknowledged. Yasuhiro Hirano was financially supported by a Grant-in-Aid (No. 18681006) for scientific research from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology, Japan. Thanks to Dr. Andy Moffat, Dr. Sheila Palmer and the anonymous reviewers for their valuable comments on the manuscript and considerable improvement of the English.