The comparative ‘court politics’ of Covid-19: explaining government responses to the pandemic

ABSTRACT

What has shaped the different responses to COVID-19? The orthodoxy in the crisis management literature holds that the response to events like COVID-19 is primarily shaped by a decentralized group of actors on the ground. In this paper, we argue that a top-down explanation, focused on the actions and intentions of the core executive, is an essential complement to this bottom-up emphasis on a distributed network. Specifically, we advance a ‘court politics’ understanding of how governing elites have taken advice and made decisions, and sketch out the impact this has had in framing and constraining crisis response efforts. The argument uses an interpretive framework centred on the dilemmas that governing elites face in managing crisis. We illustrate the underlying ‘court politics’ which has driven responses to COVID-19 in England and Denmark. We show that pathologies and dysfunctions in Johnson’s court have filtered through into inertia and indecisiveness, while the centralization of authority in Frederiksen’s court has enabled swift and decisive intervention. Our analysis shows that a top-down emphasis on executive government – and the ‘court politics’ therein – offers a fruitful agenda for understanding and comparing COVID-19 crisis response.

KEYWORDS:

• COVID-19
• core executive
• interpretivism
• court politics
• UK
• Denmark

Acknowledgement

We would like to thank Paul Cairney, Richard Gleave and Jørgen Grønnegård Christensen for invaluable comments on earlier drafts. We also thank the Special Issue editors and anonymous reviewers for their helpful feedback.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 See, for example, multiple contributions to recent COVID-themed special issues in the International Review of Administrative Sciences and Policy and Society.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

John Boswell

John Boswell is an Associate Professor in Politics at the University of Southampton.

Jack Corbett

Jack Corbett is Professor in Politics at the University of Southampton.

R. A. W. Rhodes

R. A. W. Rhodes is Professor in Government and Director of the Centre for Political Ethnography at the University of Southampton.

Heidi Houlberg Salomonsen

Heidi Houlberg Salomonsen is an Associate Professor in the Department of Management at Aarhus University.