What's the point of arms transfer controls?

Abstract

This essay examines the contemporary architecture of conventional arms transfer restrictions and concludes that it is deficient. In part this is simply due to the absence of political will to effectively implement existing arms transfer restraint. However, it is also the case that the globalization of the defense industry, the growing employment of dual-use technology and the pervasiveness and flexibility of illicit networks are, in combination, substantially eroding the utility of existing restrictions on arms circulation. It is argued, therefore, that such trends require a shift from a predominantly supplier-oriented model of restriction to a system of regulatory diffusion that matches the reality of arms diffusion in the international system. Such a system encompasses a variety of initiatives but particularly includes a greater emphasis on recipient initiatives, an enhanced role for civil society and the incorporation of an outputs/impacts model of arms regulation.

I would like to thank Rob Dover, Jocelyn Mawdsley and Ann Stavrianakis for their insightful comments on earlier drafts of this paper as well as the anonymous referees. Research for this paper has been facilitated by an ESRC grant under the New Security Challenges Programme ESRC Res: 223-25-0071.

Notes

1. J. Cirincione, ‘Addressing Proliferation Through Multilateral Agreement: Success and Failure in the Nonproliferation Regime’, in Janne E. Nolan, Bernard I. Finel and Brian D. Finley (eds.), Combating Weapons of Mass Destruction: Ultimate Security (New York: The Century Foundation Press, 2003), p.59.

2. SIPRI, SIPRI Yearbook 2005: Armaments, Disarmament and International Security (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005), p.434.

3. SIPRI, SIPRI Yearbook 2003: Armaments, Disarmament and International Security (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003), p.448.

4. United Nations, Report of the Panel of Experts Appointed Pursuant to Security Council Resolution 1343 (2201), Paragraph 19, Concerning Liberia, p.36, para.159.

5. Amnesty International, Democratic Republic of Congo: Arming the East (June 2005), see <http://web.amnesty.org/library/Index/ENGAFR620062005>.

6. Cited in Mark Phythian, ‘Intelligence and the Illicit Arms Trade: Problem or Solution’, Paper presented at the BISA Conference, London School of Economics, 16–18 December 2002, p.11.

7. Neil Cooper, ‘Arms Exports, New Labour and the Pariah Agenda’, Contemporary Security Policy, Vol.21, No.3 (December 2000), pp.54–77.

8. Report by European NGOs, Taking Control: The Case for a More Effective European Union Code of Conduct on Arms Exports (London: Saferworld, 2004), p.1.

9. Emma Mayhew, ‘A Dead Giveaway: A Critical Analysis of New Labour's Rationales for Supporting Military Export’, Contemporary Security Policy, Vol. 26, No. 1 (April 2005), pp.62–83.

10. Amnesty International, IANSA, Oxfam, The G8: Global Arms Exporters: Failing to Prevent Irresponsible Arms Transfers, Control Arms Briefing Paper (June 2005), see <http://www.controlarms.org>.

11. Global Witness, The Role of Liberia's Logging Industry on National and Regional Insecurity: Briefing to the UN Security Council by Global Witness (January 2001), see <http://www.globalwitness.org/>; Global Witness, The Usual Suspects: Liberia's Weapons and Mercenaries in Côte d'Ivoire and Sierra Leone. Why It's Still Possible, How it Works and How to Break the Trend (March 2003); United Nations, Report of the Panel of Experts Appointed Pursuant to Security Council Resolution 1306 (2000), Paragraph 4, in Relation to Liberia. S/2002/470 (19 April 2002), see <http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/docs/minindx.htm>.

12. United Nations, Report of the Panel of Experts on Violations of Security Council Sanctions Against UNITA, S/2000/203 (10 March 2000).

13. Elizabeth Kirkham and Catherine Flew, Strengthening Embargoes and Enhancing Human Security, Biting the Bullet, Briefing No.17, p.24, see <http://www.brad.ac.uk/acad/cics/publications/>.

14. Amnesty International, Democratic Republic of Congo: Arming the East.

15. Joanna Spear, ‘Arms and Arms Control’, in Issues in World Politics (Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2005).

16. Small Arms Survey, Small Arms Survey 2004: Rights at Risk (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004), pp.77–97.

17. Spear, ‘Arms and Arms Control’; John Bolton, Plenary Address to the UN Conference on the Illicit Trade in Small Arms and Light Weapons, New York City, 9 July 2001, see <http://www.state.gov/t/us/rm/janjuly/4038.htm>.

18. See University of Bradford Arms Register website at <http://www.brad.ac.uk/acad/peace/pubs/bars.htm>.

19. SIPRI, SIPRI Yearbook 2005, Table 8A.1, pp.346–371.

20. SIPRI, SIPRI Yearbook 2005, Table 10A2, pp.453–454.

21. Richard A. Bitzinger, ‘Towards a Brave New Arms Industry’, Adelphi Paper, No.356 (London: IISS and Oxford University Press, 2003).

22. Paul Dunne, ‘The Restructuring of the International Arms Industry’, Paper presented at the Eighth Annual ECAAR Conference on Economics and Security, University of the West of England, 24–26 June 2004, see <http://carecon.org.uk/Conferences/Conf2004/CONF2004.html>.

23. BASIC, Brief Submission to the Biennial Meeting of States (BMS) on Small Arms and Light Weapons (July 2003), see <http://www.basicint.org/WT/smallarms/LPO.htm>.

24. EU NGOs, Taking Control, p.39.

25. Kim Cragin and Bruce Hoffman, Arms Trafficking and Colombia (Washington, DC: RAND, 2003), p.21.

26. John Mackinley, ‘Globalization and Insurgency’, Adelphi Paper No. 352 (Oxford: Oxford University Press for the IISS, 2002), pp.15–29.

27. David Held, Anthony G. McGrew, David Goldblatt and Jonathan Perraton, Global Transformations: Politics, Economics, and Culture (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1999), p.170.

28. Mackinley, Globalization and Insurgency.

29. Susan Willett, ‘Introduction: Globalisation and Insecurity’, in Susan Willett (ed.), Structural Conflict in the New Global Disorder: Insecurity and Development, IDS Bulletin, Vol. 32, No. 2 (April 2001), p.1.

30. Global Witness, The Usual Suspects: Liberia's Weapons and Mercenaries in Côte d'Ivoire and Sierra Leone. Why it's Still Possible, How it Works and How to Break the Trend (March 2003).

31. Cragin and Hoffman, Arms Trafficking and Colombia.

32. Amnesty International, Democratic Republic of Congo.

33. Small Arms Survey, Small Arms Survey 2005, p.47.

34. Small Arms Survey, Small Arms Survey 2005, Box 9.1, p.288.

35. Global Witness, Timber, Tailor, Soldier, Spy: How Liberia's uncontrolled resource exploitation, Charles Taylor's manipulation and the re-recruitment of ex-combatants are threatening regional peace (June 2005), p.22.

36. Michael T. Klare, ‘Light Weapons Diffusion and Global Violence in the Post-Cold War Era’, in Jasjit Singh (ed.), Light Weapons and International Security (London: British American Security Information Council, 1995), pp.1–40; Michael Klare and David Anderson, A Scourge of Guns: The Diffusion of Small Arms and Light Weapons in Latin America (Washington DC: Federation of American Scientists, Arms Sales Monitoring Project, 1996).

37. Control Arms, Tracking Lethal Tools: Marking and Tracing Arms and Ammunition: A Central Piece of the Arms Control Puzzle (Control Arms Campaign, December 2004).

38. Paul Ingram and Roy Isbister, Escaping the Subsidy Trap: Why Arms Exports are Bad for Britain (BASIC, Saferworld, Oxford Research Group, September 2004); Malcolm Chalmers, Neil V. Davies, Keith Hartley and Chris Wilkinson, The Economic Costs and Benefits of UK Defence Exports, Centre for Defence Economics, Research Monograph Series 13 (University of York, November 2001).

39. Joanna Spear, Carter and Arms Sales: Implementing the Carter Administration's Arms Transfer Restraint Policy (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1995).

40. Partnership AfricaCanada and Global Witness, Rich Man Poor Man. Development Diamonds and Poverty Diamonds: The Potential for Change in the Artisanal Alluvial Diamonds Fields of Africa (2004), see <http://pacweb.org/e/index.php?option = content&task = view&id = 42&Itemid = 65>.

41. Philippe Le Billon, ‘Fuelling War: Natural Resources and Armed Conflict’, Adelphi Paper No.373 (2005).

42. Ibid.

43. ‘Diamond Development Initiative Begins’, Other Facets, No.18 (September 2005), p.1.

44. Global Witness, Undermining Peace: Tin: The Explosive Trade in Cassiterite in Eastern DRC (June 2005).

45. Global Witness, Undermining Peace.

46. Sverre Lodgaard and Carsten F. Rønnfeldt (eds.), A Moratorium of Light Weapons in West Africa (Oslo: Norwegian Initiative on Small Arms Transfers and NUPI, 1998).

47. Michael A Levi and Michael O'Hanlon, The Future of Arms Control (Washington DC: Brookings Institution Press, 2005), p.123.

48. ‘Personal Security Dominates Brazil Poll’, BBC News, 24 October 2005, see <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/4371120.stm;> ‘Gun Control Loses Yet Again’, The Japan Times Online, 30 October 2005, see <http://www.japantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin/geted.pl5?eo20051030a1.htm>.

49. Small Arms Survey, Small Arms Survey 2005, Box. 10.5, pp.282–283.

50. Biting the Bullet, International Action on Small Arms 2005: Examining Implementation of the UN Programme of Action by Biting the Bullet (2005), p.279 <http://www.saferworld.org.uk/>.

51. Jeremy Ginifer with Mike Bourne and Owen Greene, Considering Armed Violence in the Post-conflict Transition: DDR and Small Arms and Light Weapons Reduction Initiatives (CICS, Briefing Paper, September 2004), p.7, see <http://www.brad.ac.uk/acad/cics/>.

52. Owen Greene, ‘SALW in Conflict Prevention and Peacebuilding’, Paper presented at the BISA Conference, University of St Andrews, 19–21 December 2005.

53. Richard Price, ‘Reversing the Gun Sights: Transnational Civil Society Targets Land Mines’, International Organization, Vol.52, No.3 (Summer 1998), pp.613–644.

54. Biting the Bullet, International Action on Small Arms 2005, p.40.

55. Noam Chomsky, The New Military Humanism: Lessons From Kosovo (London: Pluto, 1999).

56. Neil Cooper, ‘Putting Disarmament Back in the Frame’, Review of International Studies, forthcoming.

57. Kirkham and Flew, Strengthening Embargoes and Enhancing Human Security.

58. FAFO and International Peace Academy (IPA), Business and International Crimes: Assessing the Liability of Business Entities for Grave Violations of International Law RAFO Report 467 (Oslo: FAFO, 2004), p.22.

59. Jim Lobe, ‘Attorney General Attacks Key law’, Inter Press Service, 15 May 2003, cited in Le Billon, Fuelling War, p.73.

60. FAFO and IPA, Business and International Crimes.

61. Dan Plesch, The Beauty Queen's Guide to World Peace: Money, Power and Mayhem in the Twenty-First Century (London: Politico's, 2004).

62. ‘Microsoft Faces Fines of €2m a Day’, The Guardian, 22 December 2005.

63. ‘Cigarette Giant to Pay $1 bn to EU’, The Guardian, 6 April 2004.