ABSTRACT
In this paper, I describe the impact of cultural heritage classifications amongst the Orochen ethnic minority in north-east China. Building upon the expanding literature on critical heritage studies, I argue that while heritage is often used as a top-down strategy by the Chinese state for rural and economic development, particularly in minority areas, it is important to consider the bottom-up experiences of heritage-making and the use of heritage by minority actors to facilitate development and generate improvements in their own minority communities. Presenting an ethnographic case-study from the Orochen township of Tuohe, I show how heritage does not operate through the prism of a static and hierarchical relationship between a ‘Han-Chinese’ state, on the one hand, and a small-numbered ‘ethnic minority’, on the other. Instead, it is driven largely by Orochen themselves and, in particular, ethnic minority cadres and intellectuals who use heritage and the corollary allocation of funding to channel development projects and fulfil the needs and expectations of local communities. In the process, I argue that heritage-making must be seen as a dual process in China, increasing governmentality and interpellation of minority actors while simultaneously creating spaces for cultural autonomy, innovation, and alternate expressions of modernity and tradition.
Disclosure statement
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author.
Notes
2. Between 1953–1954, the CCP sent teams of researchers to assess the ‘nationality’ status of groups seeking to apply for recognition. Initially, over 400 groups applied, however, in the 1964 census only 54 were recognised, later increased to the current 55 (McCarthy Citation2011; Harwood Citation2013). In north-east China, classification was made difficult by the multiple auto and exo-ethnonyms used by and for ethnic groups (Dumont Citation2017), and was complicated in the Orochen case by the wide distribution of clans and lack of a unified community. Their official classification was formalised in 1957 at a meeting between government officials, intellectuals, and select local leaders. Significantly, this did not include representatives from all Orochen clans and the more northeastern sub-groups were not represented at all, and today remain under the jurisdiction of the Heilongjiang government.
3. The Orochen Autonomous Banner was initially demarcated for use by Orochen only under the Regional Autonomy Law. At the time, 97% of the Banner was covered by forest an area larger than Switzerland (Lundberg and Zhou Citation2009). Speaking with Orochen elders today, they emphasise wide support for the Autonomous Banner, encompassing such a vast area and given the ability to hunt (Feng and Whaley Citation2004).
5. I have carried out fieldwork amongst Orochen communities in China since 2009. The fieldwork upon which this paper is based was carried out in the winter and summer of 2016–17. I spent 4 months in total in Tuohe Orochen township, engaging in participant-observation and carrying structured and unstructured interviews. I also followed members of a craft producers collective manufacturing and marketing their handicrafts, with Orochen youth engaging in traditional music performances, and with illegal hunters in the forest.
6. Arguably the best example of this is the ‘China Folk Culture Village’ in Shenzhen. It is a cultural theme park which features displays of the daily life and architecture of China’s 56 ethnic groups while employing minority people as performers and guides (Stanley and Chung Citation1995).
7. In China, the State Administration of Cultural Heritage (SACH) classifies and administers nationally significant cultural relics and tangible cultural heritage, while the Ministry of Culture manages intangible cultural heritage.
Oakes, T. 1997. “Ethnic Tourism in Rural Guizhou: Sense of Place and the Commerce of Authenticity.” In Tourism, Ethnicity, and the State in Asian and Pacific Societies, edited by M. Picard and R. Wood, 35–70. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press. Oakes, T. 2012. “Touring Modernities: Disordered Tourism in China.” In Real Tourism: Practice, Care, and Politics in Contemporary Travel Culture, edited by C. Minca and T. Oakes, 117–136. London: Routledge. Oakes, T. 2013. “Heritage as Improvement: Cultural Display and Contested Governance in Rural China.” Modern China 39 (4): 380–407. doi:10.1177/0097700412467011. Oakes, T. 2016. “Villagizing the City: Turning Rural Ethnic Heritage into Urban Modernity in Southwest China.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 22 (10): 751–765. doi:10.1080/13527258.2016.1212387. An, L., and J. A. Gjestrum. 1999. “The Ecomuseum in Theory and Practice: The First Chinese Ecomuseum Established.” Nordisk Museologi 2: 65–86. Sofield, T., and S. Li. 1998. “Tourism Development and Cultural Policies in China.” Annals of Tourism Research 25 (2): 362–392. doi:10.1016/S0160-7383(97)00092-3. Shepherd, R. J., 2016. Faith in Heritage: Displacement, Development, and Religious Tourism in Contemporary China. Routledge. Henderson, J., G. K. Teck, D. Ng, and T. Si‐Rong. 2009. “Tourism in Ethnic Communities: Two Miao Villages in China.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 15 (6): 529–539. doi:10.1080/13527250903210811. Blumenfield, T., and H. Silverman, eds. 2013. Cultural Heritage Politics in China. New York: Springer. Blumenfield, T. 2018. “Recognition and Misrecognition: The Politics of Intangible Cultural Heritage in Southwest China.” In Chinese Cultural Heritage in the Making. Experiences, Negotiations and Contestations, edited by C. Maags and M. Svensson, 169–194. Amsterdam University Press. Blumenfield, T., and H. Silverman, eds. 2013. Cultural Heritage Politics in China. New York: Springer. Denton, K. 2014. Exhibiting the Past: Historical Memory and the Politics of Museums in Postsocialist China. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press. Taylor, K. 2015. “Cultural Heritage Politics in China.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 21 (3): 309–311. doi:10.1080/13527258.2014.989355. Abrahams, R. 2015. “Tourism and the Reconfiguration of Host Group Identities: A Case Study of Ethnic Tourism in Rural Guangxi, China.” Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change 13 (1): 39–55. doi:10.1080/14766825.2014.892505. Li, Y., S. Turner, and H. Cui. 2016. “Confrontations and Concessions: an Everyday Politics of Tourism in Three Ethnic Minority Villages, Guizhou Province, China.” Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change 14 (1): 45–61. Zhang, Y., and Z. Wu. 2016. “The Reproduction of Heritage in a Chinese Village: Whose Heritage, Whose Pasts?” International Journal of Heritage Studies 22 (3): 228–241. Su, J. 2018. “Conceptualising the Subjective Authenticity of Intangible Cultural Heritage.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 24 (9): 919–937. doi:10.1080/13527258.2018.1428662. Ashton, C. 2013. Beijing Museums in the Context of the 2008 Beijing Olympics, in Cultural Heritage Politics in China, edited by T. Blumenfield and H. Silverman, 187–203. New York: Springer. McCarthy, S. 2011. Communist Multiculturalism: Ethnic Revival in Southwest China. University of Washington Press. Harwood, R. 2013. China's New Socialist Countryside: Modernity Arrives in The Nu River Valley. Washington: University of Washington Press. Dumont, A. 2017. “Declining Evenki ‘Identities’: Playing with Loyalty in Modern and Contemporary China.” History and Anthropology 28 (4): 515–530. doi:10.1080/02757206.2017.1351363. Lundberg, M., and Y. Zhou. 2009. “Hunting-Prohibition in the Hunters Autonomous Area: Legal Rights of Oroqen People and the Implementation of Regional National Autonomy Law.” International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 16 (3): 349–397. doi:10.1163/138819009X12474964197638. Feng, L., and L. Whaley. 2004. “The End of Nomadism: Oroqen History, Migration and Current Distribution.” Proceedings of the First International Conference on Manchu-Tungus Studies (Bonn, August 28-September 1, 2000): Trends in Tungusic and Siberian linguistics, Otto Harrassowitz Verlag, Bonn, Germany. Oakes, T. 1997. “Ethnic Tourism in Rural Guizhou: Sense of Place and the Commerce of Authenticity.” In Tourism, Ethnicity, and the State in Asian and Pacific Societies, edited by M. Picard and R. Wood, 35–70. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press. Oakes, T. 2012. “Touring Modernities: Disordered Tourism in China.” In Real Tourism: Practice, Care, and Politics in Contemporary Travel Culture, edited by C. Minca and T. Oakes, 117–136. London: Routledge. Oakes, T. 2013. “Heritage as Improvement: Cultural Display and Contested Governance in Rural China.” Modern China 39 (4): 380–407. doi:10.1177/0097700412467011. Oakes, T. 2016. “Villagizing the City: Turning Rural Ethnic Heritage into Urban Modernity in Southwest China.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 22 (10): 751–765. doi:10.1080/13527258.2016.1212387. Sofield, T., and S. Li. 1998. “Tourism Development and Cultural Policies in China.” Annals of Tourism Research 25 (2): 362–392. doi:10.1016/S0160-7383(97)00092-3. Li, F. M. S., and T. H Sofield. 2009. “Huangshan (Yellow Mountain), China: The Meaning of Harmonious Relationships.” In Tourism in China, 175–185. Routledge. An, L., and J. A. Gjestrum. 1999. “The Ecomuseum in Theory and Practice: The First Chinese Ecomuseum Established.” Nordisk Museologi 2: 65–86. Shepherd, R. J., 2016. Faith in Heritage: Displacement, Development, and Religious Tourism in Contemporary China. Routledge. Henderson, J., G. K. Teck, D. Ng, and T. Si‐Rong. 2009. “Tourism in Ethnic Communities: Two Miao Villages in China.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 15 (6): 529–539. doi:10.1080/13527250903210811. Sofield, T., and S. Li. 2011. “Tourism Governance and Sustainable National Development in China: A Macro-Level Synthesis.” Journal of Sustainable Tourism 19 (4–5): 501–534. doi:10.1080/09669582.2011.571693. Svensson, M. 2012. “Heritage Struggles and Place-Makings in Zhejiang Province: Local Media, Cross-Regional Media Interactions, and Media Strategies from Below.” In Mapping Media in China: Region, Province and Locality, edited by W. Sun and J. Chio, 193–211. London: Routledge. Blumenfield, T., and H. Silverman, eds. 2013. Cultural Heritage Politics in China. New York: Springer. Denton, K. 2014. Exhibiting the Past: Historical Memory and the Politics of Museums in Postsocialist China. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press. Taylor, K. 2015. “Cultural Heritage Politics in China.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 21 (3): 309–311. doi:10.1080/13527258.2014.989355. Abrahams, R. 2015. “Tourism and the Reconfiguration of Host Group Identities: A Case Study of Ethnic Tourism in Rural Guangxi, China.” Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change 13 (1): 39–55. doi:10.1080/14766825.2014.892505. Li, Y., S. Turner, and H. Cui. 2016. “Confrontations and Concessions: an Everyday Politics of Tourism in Three Ethnic Minority Villages, Guizhou Province, China.” Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change 14 (1): 45–61. Zhang, Y., and Z. Wu. 2016. “The Reproduction of Heritage in a Chinese Village: Whose Heritage, Whose Pasts?” International Journal of Heritage Studies 22 (3): 228–241. Maags, C., and M. Svensson. 2018. “Mapping the Chinese Heritage Regime Ruptures, Governmentality, and Agency.” In Chinese Cultural Heritage in the Making: Experiences, Negotiations and Contestations, edited by M. Svensson and C. Maags, 11–40. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. Blumenfield, T. 2018. “Recognition and Misrecognition: The Politics of Intangible Cultural Heritage in Southwest China.” In Chinese Cultural Heritage in the Making. Experiences, Negotiations and Contestations, edited by C. Maags and M. Svensson, 169–194. Amsterdam University Press. Su, J. 2018. “Conceptualising the Subjective Authenticity of Intangible Cultural Heritage.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 24 (9): 919–937. doi:10.1080/13527258.2018.1428662. Nyíri, P. 2006. Scenic Spots: Chinese Tourism, the State, and Cultural Authority. Seattle: University of Washington Press. Stanley, N., and S. K. Chung. 1995. “Representing the past as the Future: The Shenzhen Chinese Folk Culture Villages and the Marketing of Chinese Identity.” Journal of Museum Ethnography (7): 25–40. Additional information
Funding
This work was supported by the Arts and Humanities Research Council.
Notes on contributors
Richard Fraser
Richard Fraser is an anthropologist and Associate Professor at the Collaborative Innovation Centre for Security and Development of Western Frontier at Sichuan University, China. He completed his PhD in anthropology at the University of Leiden and was recently a postdoctoral researcher at the Mongolia and Inner Asia Studies Unit at the University of Cambridge. Richard has carried out fieldwork with Evenki, Orochen, and Mongol communities in China’s Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region and Heilongjiang province since 2007, and with Darhad and Tsaatan communities in Mongolia since 2010. His regional specialisation is Northern and Inner Asia, specifically China and China’s minorities, Mongolia, and Siberia. His research interests span human-environment relationships; phenomenological-existential anthropology; pastoralism, hunting and land-use; cultural heritage and ethnic tourism; ethnic minorities and the state; skill and learning; displacement and resettlement; mining and resources; renewable and non-renewable energy; climate change; human-animal relations; shamanism and animism; and socialism and postsocialism.