Risk governance in the transition towards sustainability, the case of bio-based plastic food packaging materials

Abstract

In the transition to a sustainable society, many new technologies and materials are developed. These often have disadvantages, examples thereof with a sustainability claim that entailed risks to public health are identified. Risk Governance should ideally address and deal with those potential risks. However, governance mechanisms to efficiently deal with these risks seem to be lacking. In this study, the Risk Governance in the lifecycle of three innovative bio-based plastic food contact materials (FCMs) were evaluated. Interviews were conducted with representatives of all stages in the lifecycle to identify risk management strategies to prevent or control public health risk. Experts were asked to share their views on the identified strategies. Nineteen different risk management strategies have been identified from the three case studies and compared with the principles of the International Risk Governance Council (IRGC) framework and showed that less than 50% corresponded to those of the IRGC framework. In addition, eighteen randomly sampled bio-based FCMs were chemically analysed to get insight in the presence of potentially hazardous substances. The presence of hazardous chemicals in the bio-based FCMs provide indications of potential chemical health risks. Apparently, there is no structural application of risk governance in the three bio-based FCM studied. Strategies are applied to manage public health risks, but these are usually implemented too limited to effectively manage the identified risks.

KEYWORDS:

• Bio-based plastics
• food contact materials
• innovation
• public health
• risk governance
• risk migration
• sustainability

Acknowledgement

The authors like to thank Dr. Dirk van Aken from the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA) Office for Risk Assessment & Research and Dr. Ir. Lily Fredrix from the Open University for their professional advice, feedback and support during this research. Also, they are very thankful to Ing. Dita Kalsbeek-van Wijk and Lodewijk Steendam from the NVWA Product Safety Laboratory for performing the chemical analyses and their professional contribution to the interpretation of the findings.

Disclosure statement

The Authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.