Step-by-step decision-making process in third party assisted reproduction: a qualitative study

Abstract

This study explores the experience of decision-making about the third party assisted reproduction in Iranian infertile patients using a qualitative approach. Data were collected in 2017–2019 through in-depth interviews of 20 infertile participants (3 couples and 14 individuals) who became pregnant or had children through third-party reproduction and 12 specialists. The interviews were transcribed verbatim, the data were managed using the MAXQDA 10 and analysed using a conventional content analysis approach. The main category that emerged was ‘step-by-step process of adjustment to third party assisted reproduction’. From this, five sub-categories were extracted: (i) ‘parental preference for biological children over non-biological children’; (ii) ‘parental preference for non-biological children over childlessness threats’; (iii) ‘strong preference for having partial genetic link with children’; (iv) ‘flexibility in removing or overcoming barriers to third party reproduction’; and (v) ‘parental preference for adopted children over childlessness’. The findings in the present study suggest the importance of lineage and biological relatedness in Iranian culture. Patients adjusted to non-biological parenting as a treatment option only if they have to. Using a step-by-step decision-making process helped participants make more thoughtful decisions by organising relevant information and defining alternatives. The results of the present study can help healthcare providers with counselling regarding parenting with or without genetic ties.

Keywords:

• Infertility
• assisted reproductive technologies
• donor conception
• third party reproduction
• decision making

Acknowledgments

This is a part of the first author’s PhD dissertation and the authors acknowledge Central Tehran Branch of Islamic Azad University for the support of this project. Authors are grateful to the participants for sharing their experiences.

Disclosure statement

The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.