388
Views
0
CrossRef citations to date
0
Altmetric
Articles

“We used to have lice … ” interethnic imagery in post-war upland Laos

Pages 171-197 | Received 24 Nov 2021, Accepted 16 Jan 2022, Published online: 02 Feb 2022
 

ABSTRACT

This paper discusses interethnic dynamics in a multi-ethnic Khmu and Akha village in the uplands of Phongsali Province, far-north Laos. It offers an intimate vignette on how local Khmu people’s patronizing disposition towards their Akha neighbors – and Sino-Tibetan highlanders more broadly – has been shaped by Laos’ recent history of war, revolution, and development. In particular, it shows how essentializing images of Akha as backward bumpkins in need of civilizing tutelage have provided local Khmu with a foil and platform for their pursuit of a culturally specific sense of modernity. In so doing, this paper refocuses the analysis of interethnic relations in Laos away from state-centered, lowland-upland, majority-minority frameworks, and towards localized, micro-regional and, most significantly, intra-upland dynamics. Concomitant to this refocus, this paper offers novel insights into the localized impact of Laos’ watershed civil war and its lingering aftermath. It also speaks to broader issues, including the applicability of the scholarly trope of “internal Orientalism” across scales, as well as the ethics and politics of researching inter-ethnic relations in a society still marked by the trauma of war.

Acknowledgements

I thank Nathan Badenoch, Charles P. Zuckerman, Oliver Tappe, Rosalie Stolz, and Michele Ford for helpful comments on earlier drafts. I thank the Sydney Southeast Asia Centre for supporting the writing of this paper with a Writing Fellowship. Last but first, I deeply thank the people of Sanjing. All mistakes are mine.

Disclosure statement

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).

Notes

1 Local names are pseudonyms.

2 “Tai-Lao” refers to the national majority Lao and seven smaller Tai-speaking groups.

3 Zuckermann Citation2012; Pholsena Citation2002

4 E.g. Michaud Citation2009.

5 Leach Citation1964; see also Robinne and Sadan Citation2007

6 Much of this research has been provoked by James Scott’s productive but ultimately oversimplifying synopsis of Southeast Asian uplanders as anarchic state-evaders (Scott Citation2009). See, for example, Evans Citation2000; Cohen Citation2000; Culas and Robbine Citation2010; Badenoch and Tomita Citation2013; Jonsson Citation2014; Sevenig Citation2015; Bouté Citation2018; Bouté Citation2018; Évrard Citation2007, Citation2019; Tappe and Badenoch Citation2021; Tappe Citation2018, Citation2021; Stolz and Tappe Citation2021. For my use of Tai, see Tappe and Badenoch Citation2021, 3–5.

7 In a rare exception, Tappe and Badenoch (Citation2021) allude to the significance of Khmu in Phong self-identification.

8 Petit Citation2006, Citation2012; Pholsena Citation2020; Bouté Citation2017, Citation2021. For partial exceptions, see Évrard Citation2007, 139–140; Sevenig Citation2015.

9 I conducted twelve months of fieldwork between May 2017 and January 2020.

10 Pholsena and Tappe Citation2013; Dwyer Citation2012; Pholsena Citation2018; High Citation2021; Pholsena Citation2006; Lutz Citation2021a; Pholsena and Promphakping Citation2021; High Citation2021.

11 Schein Citation1997.

12 Lutz Citation2021a; 23–26

13 LSB Citation2015, 37.

14 To be sure, and not withstanding their valuation of self-reliance, Sanjing’s Khmu have long engaged with wider economies. See Lutz Citation2021b.

16 LSB Citation2015; 37.

17 Cf. Tooker Citation2012.

18 Lutz Citation2021a, 183–184, 398–405

19 Even here, many hire Akha. Cf. Cohen Citation2000; 191 ff.

20 Lutz Citation2021b.

21 These rumors quickly dissipated. As I write this, none of Sanjing’s Akha have moved elsewhere.

22 Cf. High Citation2008; High et al. Citation2009; Petit Citation2020; Bouté Citation2017, 2021. As I discuss below, the fact that Sanjing’s Khmu and Akha remain upland peasants impacts interethnic relations in Sanjing today.

23 High Citation2021; 86 cf. Pholsena Citation2006; Pholsena and Tappe Citation2013 Pholsena and Promphakping Citation2021; Dwyer Citation2012; London Citation2012. To be sure, Laos’ civil war cannot be reduced to interethnic conflict. In many places, Khmu fought for US-backed royalists, just as Akha fought with the leftist PL. What I describe in this paper is a micro-regional dynamic that likely owes as much to how things are remembered as to what actually happened during the war.

24 Lutz Citation2021a; 379–383 cf. Dwyer Citation2012; 45–64.

25 Lutz Citation2021a; 132–134.

26 High Citation2006, 2021; 39.

27 Pholsena and Promphakping Citation2021; High Citation2021; 39ff.

28 Holt Citation2009, 129ff; Petit Citation2020, 167–169.

29 Somewhat ironically, news of the birth reached Sanjing via mobile phone.

30 On vanguards see below and High Citation2021; 12ff.

31 Cf. Creak Citation2018.

32 Cf. Lutz Citation2022, 115

33 Approve/allow/recognize: habhɔŋ

34 Sit is referring to the Lao state’s focal site development campaign. See Noonan Citation2015 on the “Three Builds.”

35 This was the same ridge mentioned by Wan and Aen in this paper’s opening vignette.

36 Cf. Évrard Citation2019.

37 Lutz Citation2021a; 2022 cf. Stolz Citation2021; High Citation2021, 59ff.

38 Khmu lore abounds with self-deprecating tales of losing literacy, knowledge, and lowland kingdoms to the more clever and cunning Tai-Lao. See Lutz Citation2021a, 103–108; Proschan Citation2001. To be sure, Sanjing’s Khmu do not articulate an overarching discourse of Indigeneity, not least because Indigeneity is an unrecognized – and controversial – category in contemporary Laos.

39 Turton Citation2000.

40 Lutz Citation2021a, Évrard 2007, 2019; Proschan Citation1998.

41 Cf. Proschan Citation2001.

42 Aijmer Citation1979; Evans Citation1998; 142–145.

43 Zuckermann Citation2012; Tappe and Badenoch Citation2021.

44 In all likelihood, Sanjing Khmu were involved in both the colonial-era and royalist administration of their area. See Lutz Citation2021, 88–95, 202–208. The allegiances of Phukor’s Akha likely owed more to circumstantial factors than ideological commitment.

45 Cf. Tappe and Badenoch Citation2021, 4. In other parts of northern Laos, Khmu have disowned the label Lao Terng (Nathan Badenoch, pers. Commun.).

46 Evans Citation1998, 2000, 285; Pholsena Citation2006, 58ff; 2020 1872–1873; 1880. But see High Citation2021 on the continuing salience of socialism.

47 Lutz Citation2021a, 242; Évrard Citation2019, 238–239; Petit Citation2008, 131; Tappe and Badenoch Citation2021, 12–13; Pholsena Citation2006, 180ff; Petit Citation2020; 1879.

48 Holt Citation2009, 271–275.

49 In Sanjing, wrist-tying has replaced the erstwhile practice of strengthening souls/life-force by smearing sacrificial blood on kneecaps. Cf. Sprenger Citation2009.

50 Lutz Citation2021a; 175–176.

51 Lutz Citation2021a, 43; High Citation2008; Thongchai Citation2000, 57.

52 China’s rise is engendering a seismic shift to this compass of global civility. See Lutz Citation2022; 118–124.

53 Turton Citation2000; Culas and Robbine Citation2010; Evans Citation2012, 74–78; Duncan Citation2004; Li Citation2014, 30–57; Fiskesjö Citation1999, 2015, 515; Petit Citation2006.

54 Schein Citation1997, 2012; Said Citation1978.

55 Schein Citation2012, 129; Fiskesjö Citation1999.

56 Schein Citation2012, 120 see also Fiskesjö 2014.

57 Said Citation1978, 22.

58 Recall Sit noting there are “thirty [groups]” of Lao Soung.

59 Fiskesjö Citation1999.

60 Zuckermann Citation2012; Culas and Robbine Citation2010.

61 Ortner Citation1995, 178; Lyttleton Citation2011, 171; Evans Citation2012; 74–78.

62 Lyttleton Citation2011; Schein Citation1997; 87.

63 Schein Citation2012; 123.

64 Fiskesjö Citation2015; Thongchai Citation2000, 51; Petit Citation2006, 30–31.

65 This is a fear that again, and somewhat ironically, mirrors and displaces Tai-Lao images of the backward yet spiritually potent Khmu.

66 When Sanjing’s Khmu note “we can’t just abandon all our hróoy!” they refer primarily to hróoy gaang. See also Stolz Citation2021; 121–157.

67 Lutz Citation2021a, cf. Bouté Citation2021; 755–756.

68 Said Citation1978, 21.

69 Indeed, I repeatedly found myself appropriating Khmu positional superiority. See Lutz Citation2021a; 248.

70 Scott Citation1990; Evans Citation2000, 272.

71 Note here Vandee’s appropriation of PL vantage.

72 aai-nɔŋ is the Lao term for relatives/kin. It is used in Sanjing and elsewhere as polite slang for the PL.

73 Cf. High et al. 2009; 617.

74 Lutz Citation2022; 116–118

75 Cf. Pholsena Citation2020

76 Take, for instance, the RLG air raid on Sanjing during the war. As I have noted, Sanjing Khmu accuse Phukor-based “Lao Soung enemies” of calling in the raid. Those old enough to remember, however, hastened to add that it was all a tragic mistake. Just days before the raid, a group of Phukor Akha had attempted to enter the valley to barter for salt (by all accounts, a common occurrence during the war). Vexed at being turned back by the PL soldiers manning a checkpoint just downhill from Sanjing, the Akha asked their local militia head to call in an airstrike. Most unfortunately, the pilots mistook Sanjing for that checkpoint.

77 Asked if the spirit healing ritual he was performing for Dosaa’s ailing wife () was “according to Khmu or Akha custom,” brother Rao replied with revealing nonchalance, “both!” Such eclecticism may perhaps even allude to a shared cultural substratum. Cf. Mus, Mabbett, and Chandler Citation2010 [Citation1933]; Holt Citation2009; High Citation2022.

78 Recall Phetsamone’s statement that “when it comes to local/territorial spirits, we yield to the Lao Terng.”

79 Pace Badenoch and Tomita Citation2013.

80 Again echoing Orientalist discourse, Khmu conceptions about the Akha proved remarkably resilient to fact-checking. During a courtesy visit to a funeral in Phukor, Sanjing Khmu and I learned that the deceased would not lie in state for ten days as people claimed, but would in fact be buried the following day. Confronted with this information, Wan shrugged his shoulders, noting “we’re still worried.”

81 High Citation2021; 12ff.

82 Tappe Citation2013b. To be sure, Sanjing’s Khmu also strive to fix and align their personal histories with the official history of the war (recall that Sit himself is the son of a royalist official). See Lutz Citation2021a, 115–143, 203–208; Cf. Pholsena Citation2006, 143–144; Petit Citation2020, 1884. Such eschewals suggest that while ostensibly subalterns are usually portrayed as using local memories to challenge dominant versions of the past, they may also conspire to do the opposite and use dominant versions of the past to subdue inconveniently multivocal memories. Cf. Tappe Citation2013a.

83 Petit Citation2020; Petit Citation2008; 118–119.

84 Cf. Schein Citation2012, 17–21; Wilcox Citation2016.

85 Ambivalent images of Chinese hydropower, in particular, are becoming increasingly salient in local Khmu engagements with Lao PDR modernity. See Lutz Citation2022; 118–124.

86 Lutz Citation2021b.

87 To be sure, distinct Khmu and Akha identities will remain salient for decades to come – even if in modernized, folklorized and/or Lao-icized forms. The ostensible Khmu-ization/Lao-izaton of Sanjing’s Akha is a topic beyond the scope of this paper. I hope to address this issue in future work. Cf. Évrard Citation2019; Petit Citation2020, 33ff.

88 Customarily, Phukor’s Akha have married off their daughters without money changing hands.

89 Ortner Citation1995.

Additional information

Funding

This paper was written as part of a Writing Fellowship at the Sydney Southeast Asia Centre, University of Sydney, Australia.

Notes on contributors

Paul-David Lutz

Dr. Paul-David Lutz recently completed his doctorate in anthropology at the University of Sydney. He is currently an honorary associate and sessional teacher at the University of Sydney’s School of Social and Political Sciences, and a writing fellow at the Sydney Southeast Asia Centre. Prior to his graduate studies, Paul-David worked for several years on rural development projects in the uplands of Laos and Vietnam.

Reprints and Corporate Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below:

Academic Permissions

Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content?

Obtain permissions instantly via Rightslink by clicking on the button below:

If you are unable to obtain permissions via Rightslink, please complete and submit this Permissions form. For more information, please visit our Permissions help page.