Diagrammatic mental representation: a methodological bridge

Abstract

While computer-mediated user studies tend to rely on surveys, observations, focus groups, and ethnography, participant-generated mental model diagrammatic representation can yield valuable data involving complex and abstract user practices and behaviour. Computer-mediated research has struggled with eliciting users’ beliefs of concrete representations in technology interactions. Using an investigation of authentication and user perceptions of security, we tested a method to elicit user mental model representations. We asked this overarching question: What are user perceptions of security when logging in to third-party apps and services via existing Facebook, Google, and Twitter accounts? Drawing from approaches to researching technology from the sub-fields of human-computer interaction, user studies, visual and risk communication, while incorporating methodological techniques from psychology on mental models, we offer a methodological innovation. We found evidence suggesting that a diagrammatic approach to representing mental models is feasible in addressing some of the challenges faced by existing computer-mediated approaches.

DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

No potential conflict of interest was reported by the authors.

Additional information

Notes on contributors

Hervé Saint-Louis

Hervé Saint-Louis, is assistant professor of emerging media at the Université du Québec à Chicoutimi.

Rhonda McEwen

Rhonda McEwen, Canada Research Chair in Tactile Interfaces, Communication and Cognition, is Associate Professor of New Media & Communication, Institute of Communication, Culture, Information, & Technology, University of Toronto Mississauga.