Carbon stocks, net cash flow and family benefits from four small coffee plantation types in Nicaragua

Abstract

This study sought to identify agroforestry systems with coffee that simultaneously generate financial profits, provide goods for family consumption, and store significant amounts of carbon in aboveground biomass. We studied 27 coffee plantations in Nicaragua, grouped in four typologies defined a priori: C1, full-sun coffee; C2, coffee, bananas and service trees; C3, coffee, bananas, service and timber trees; C4, coffee, bananas, service, timber and fruit trees. Carbon stock in aboveground biomass, agroforestry production (coffee, fruits, bananas, standing timber and firewood), cash costs (hired labor and materials), in-kind costs (family labor and materials produced on the farm), income from sales, and domestic consumption valued in money, were measured to estimate net cash flow, net income and family benefits. Carbon stocks varied from 8.8 Mg ha⁻¹ in full-sun coffee plantations (C1) to 38.6 Mg ha⁻¹ in coffee plantations with diverse shade (C4). Coffee generated the most earnings, but all other agroforestry products contribute positively to net cash flow, net income and family benefits. In shaded coffee plantations, the consumption and sale of coffee, fruits, timber, and other agroforestry products equal the returns from full-sun coffee plantations. This study demonstrates that it is possible to find shaded coffee plantations with high yields and attractive profit (coffee and other agroforestry products) while retaining significant quantities of carbon in aboveground wood. Good crop (coffee) husbandry (inorganic fertilization, pests and diseases control, and yearly coffee pruning) is a pre-requisite for realizing these synergies.

Keywords:

• Agroforestry
• domestic consumption
• climate change
• timber
• fruits
• firewood
• shade canopy
• financial indicators
• synergies
• tradeoffs

Acknowledgments

This research was co-funded by both CATIE-MAP (Mesoamerican Agroenvironmental Program) and FTA/CATIE (Forest, Trees and Agroforestry). Many thanks to the families who shared their farms and experiences with us; to MAPNorway project staff in Matagalpa for their useful guidance; to Elvin Navarrete, José Menéndez, Nelson Quinteros and Antonio Navarrete for their help in field data collection; to Sergio Vílchez for his help in data analysis.