Linking a throughput simulation to a systems dynamics simulation to assess the utility of a US Navy foreign humanitarian aid mission

Abstract

The success of any humanitarian aid mission is generally measured by the timeliness of critical supplies that are delivered to the affected area. However, a more interesting analysis may be to determine the effect of the aid on the overall satisfaction of the local population. The authors' research focused on the delivery of humanitarian aid to a notional region that was decimated by flooding with ships, landing craft and security personnel provided by the US Navy and Marines. While the research effort addressed naval force structure, the focus of the research was: (1) to assess different delivery methods for the aid; and (2) to determine how the aid delivery impacted the overall satisfaction of the local population. To examine both concerns, two simulation models were developed, with one examining the throughput of aid delivered during the operation, and the other the satisfaction of the population based on the humanitarian aid effort.

Keywords:

• stability-based operations
• humanitarian assistance
• disaster relief
• forward logistic sites
• logistic satellite sites
• delivery requirements
• effectiveness
• courses of action
• non-governmental organizations

Notes

N.V. Beach, ‘Systems Architecture of a Sea Base Surface Connector System in a 2020 Humanitarian Assistance/Disaster Relief Joint Operational Environment’ (master's thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA, 2010).

United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Field Operating Guide Version 4.0 (Washington, DC: United States Agency International Development, 2005).

US Marine Corps Wargaming Division, Marine Corps Warfighting Laboratory, ‘Expeditionary Warrior 2010: Operationalize the Sea Base, DRAFT Player Book’ (Wargame documents presented on 22–26 February at Bolger Center, Potomoc, MD, 2010).

United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Field Operating Guide Version 4.0.

Military.com Equipment Guide, http://tech.military.com/equipment/home.do (accessed May 8, 2012).

H.J. Bodden, ‘A Survivability Assessment of the Transformable Craft in an Operational Environment’ (master's thesis, Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA, 2010).

Military.com Equipment Guide, http://tech.military.com/equipment/home.do (accessed May 8, 2012).

Ibid.

Arnold Buss, SimKit (Version 1.3.8) [Computer Software] (Monterey, CA: Naval Post Graduate School, 2009).

Barry Richmond, An Introduction to Systems Thinking (Lebanon, NH: ISEE Systems, 2004).

Steven Goode, ‘A Historical Basis for Force Requirements in a Counterinsurgency’, Parameters: US Army War College Quarterly (Winter 2009–2010): 45–57, http://www.carlisle.army.mil/usawc/parameters/Articles/09winter/goode.pdf (accessed May 1, 2012).

Susmita Roy, The Impact of Natural Disasters on Violent Crime (Christchurch, New Zealand: University of Canterbury, 2010).

United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Field Operating Guide Version 4.0.

James A. Hodges and James A. Dewar, Is it You or your Model Talking: A Framework for Model Validation (Santa Monica, CA: RAND, National Defense Research Institute, 1992).